Atari's Trustpilot page shows a TrustScore of 2.2 from just 39 reviews, 77% of them 1-star. Trustpilot itself notes the profile is unclaimed, that Atari has not invited customers to review, and no replies from Atari are shown. The recent complaints are fixable order problems: missing items in an order, wrong editions of physical Switch games, refunds and customs duties. Meanwhile the store's real customers are loyal: Atari Club reward redeemers average 4 orders a year and 75.5% buy again. A few dozen unhappy buyers are speaking for a store that thousands of repeat customers use.
First action
Claim the Trustpilot profile and reply to the ten most recent reviews.
How to measure it
TrustScore with 300+ reviews
- Now
- –
- Target
- 4.0
- By
- 6 months
Steps
Claim the profile
Verify atari.com on Trustpilot and add the support contact.
Head of E-commerce 1 day
Reply to every review
Public replies with a concrete fix for each review from the last 12 months; resolve the open orders privately.
Customer Support Lead 3 days
Tag the causes
Group complaints into missing items, wrong edition, late delivery, refunds and duties.
Customer Support Lead 1 day
Automate invites
Send a review invite to every delivered order a few days after delivery through the store's email tool.
CRM Manager 1 week
Fix the top cause
Start with split shipments and edition picking, the most common complaints.
Head of E-commerce 4 weeks
Reply within 48 hours
A standing rule for all new reviews.
Customer Support Lead ongoing
Show the rating
Add the score to product and preorder pages once it passes 4.0.
Head of E-commerce 1 day
Why it works
Claim the profile this week and reply publicly to every review from the last 12 months with a fix (reship, refund or a contact for the order). Then switch on automatic review invites from the Shopify and Klaviyo stack, sent a few days after delivery to every order, so the score reflects all buyers and not only the angriest. Feed the complaint reasons into order operations each month (split shipments, edition picking, refunds), and show the improved rating on product pages once it is earned.
People search "Atari store reviews" before they preorder a console or collector's edition, and a 2.2 score from 39 reviews is what they find. Profiles that invite every buyer collect far more reviews, the score moves towards the true experience, and public replies show prospective buyers that problems get fixed.
Ready to use
CopyPublic reply to an order complaint
Hi, thank you for telling us, and we're sorry your order arrived [missing an item / with the wrong edition / late]. That's not the experience we want for Atari fans. Our team has [reshipped the missing item / sent the correct edition / issued your refund] and you should hear from our support team by email within 24 hours. If anything is still open, reply to that email and we'll make it right. — Atari Store team
Risks and how to handle them
Invites bring in more complaints while order problems remain
Fix split shipments and edition picking in the same month, and reply to every new review.
Breaking review-platform rules
Invite every buyer, never only happy ones, and offer no reward for reviews.
Evidence
- TrustpilotAtari's Trustpilot page (checked November 3, 2026): TrustScore 2.2 ("Poor") from 39 reviews, 17 of them in the last 12 months; 77% are 1-star and 13% 5-star. The profile is unclaimed, Atari has not invited customers to review, and no replies from Atari are shown. The ten most recent reviews (December 2025 to October 2026) are mostly about orders not received or partly missing (one order arrived without its Gamestation Go and gamepad), wrong editions sent for physical Switch games, refunds and customs duties; the newest, on October 29, 2026, gives 5 stars for tech support.Source
- Loyalty case studyRivo's case study on the Atari Club (vendor-reported, first 10 months): reward redeemers have a lifetime value of $456 versus $144 for non-members, place 4 orders a year versus 1.1, spend $150 per order versus $129, and 75.5% buy again versus 9.4%; over 1,700 redemptions, including 1,000+ free Atari Club Tees (500 points) and nearly 500 $20 coupons. Points come from linking Steam, Xbox or Twitch, watching streams, MobyGames contributions and quests (Discord, screenshots, convention QR codes); a numbered 2,600-unit Woodgrain Super Pocket Atari Edition could only be redeemed with points. Atari merged its Discord servers into one Atari Club server of about 25,000 members in early 2025.Source
- Your websiteatari.com runs on Shopify behind Cloudflare and has a Klaviyo domain verification; atari.club redirects to atari.com/pages/atari-club. On November 3, 2026 the homepage and sitemap returned HTTP 403 to automated readers, and www.atari.com returned 429.Source