The homepage makes a strong promise in a block called "Total Rebate": "Full refund if you don't love it." A cautious first-time buyer who wants to check it clicks "Refund Policy" in the footer and lands back on the homepage, because that link, along with "Privacy Policy", "Terms of Service", "Search" and "Shop", points to "/". The real refund page does exist, but nothing in the footer reaches it, and it says only: "Refunds are reviewed on a case by case basis." So the best selling line on the site is contradicted by the one page meant to support it, on every page of the store.
First action
Open the footer menu in the Shopify theme editor and replace the five links that currently point to the homepage.
How to measure it
Sessions that reach checkout
- Now
- –
- Target
- +10%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Fix the footer links
Point Privacy, Refund, Terms, Search and Shop to their own pages, and Contact to /pages/contact-us.
Owner 30 minutes
Decide the real promise
Choose the window (for example 30 days), whether a photo is needed for melted or damaged orders, and how class bookings are refunded or moved.
Owner 1 hour
Rewrite the refund policy
Replace the single "case by case" sentence with the promise, the window, the steps to ask and the reply time.
Owner 1 hour
Fill in the other policies
Check that privacy and terms pages exist in Shopify's policy settings and are not empty before linking them.
Owner 1 hour
Rename and link the guarantee
Change "Total Rebate" to a clear name and link it to the refund policy.
Owner 15 minutes
Repeat it where people decide
Add the one-line guarantee under the add-to-cart button and in the cart.
Shopify freelancer 2 hours
Click-test every page
Check the footer on the homepage, a product, a collection and a page, on a phone.
Shop assistant 30 minutes
Track refunds
Log each refund request and reason for 60 days to confirm the promise is affordable.
Owner ongoing
Why it works
Do three things. First, point each footer link at its real destination: /policies/refund-policy, /policies/privacy-policy, /policies/terms-of-service, /search and /collections/all, and send "Contact" to the contact page. Second, rewrite the refund policy so it states the homepage promise in plain terms: who can ask, within how many days, how to ask, what happens for melted or damaged parcels, and how classes are handled. Third, rename the block from "Total Rebate" to something a shopper recognizes, such as "Love-it guarantee", link it to the policy, and repeat the one-line promise on product pages and in the cart.
Chocolate bought online is a gift or a treat from a maker the buyer has not tasted yet, so the guarantee does the reassuring. A promise that leads to a dead end reads as worse than no promise. Loon Chocolate, a New Hampshire maker shoppers may compare, states "Satisfaction 100% Guaranteed" on its site. Once the policy matches the promise, the guarantee can be used with confidence in emails, on product pages and in gift messaging.
Ready to use
ChecklistGuarantee and footer fix list
[ ] Refund Policy link -> /policies/refund-policy [ ] Privacy Policy link -> /policies/privacy-policy [ ] Terms of Service link -> /policies/terms-of-service [ ] Search link -> /search [ ] Shop link -> /collections/all [ ] Contact link -> /pages/contact-us [ ] Refund policy states: the promise, the number of days, how to ask, reply time [ ] Refund policy covers melted or damaged parcels and class bookings [ ] "Total Rebate" renamed and linked to the policy [ ] Guarantee line on product pages and in the cart [ ] Footer click-tested on a phone
Risks and how to handle them
More refund requests once the promise is easy to find
Set a clear window and ask for the order number; review the log after 60 days.
Melted parcels in warm months raise claims
State how warm-weather orders are handled and offer a replacement first.
Evidence
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 16, 2026): banner "Small-batch artisan truffles · Freshly crafted daily · Nationwide delivery available"; headline "We make chocolates so you can make memories" under "REAL CHOCOLATE, MINIMAL SUGAR."; a "Total Rebate" block that says "Full refund if you don't love it."; three testimonials with no names; a "Get Seasonal Releases" email signup; no address, opening hours, phone number or social links on the page.Source
- Your websiteFooter (the same on the homepage, the Christmas page and the classes page, checked November 16, 2026): "Privacy Policy", "Refund Policy", "Terms of Service", "Search" and "Shop" all link to the homepage; "Contact" opens an email instead of the contact page. The refund and shipping policy pages exist at /policies/refund-policy and /policies/shipping-policy, but no footer link leads to them.Source
- Your websiteRefund policy page, in full: "Refunds are reviewed on a case by case basis." It gives no time limit, no conditions and no way to ask for a refund.Source
- Competitor researchLoon Chocolate (Manchester and Bedford, NH): "Bean-to-Bar Craft Chocolate Bars Made in New Hampshire"; free shipping on orders of $50 or more and 10% off five or more bars; "Satisfaction 100% Guaranteed"; tasting classes, a build-your-own-bar class and factory tours; sold through more than 500 retail partners.Source