neweracap.com charges $8 for standard shipping on orders below $100 before tax, and the median product in the catalogue is $42.99. A fan buying one 59FIFTY or 9FORTY pays for shipping and then waits 3-5 business days for processing plus 7-10 business days for ground delivery. Lids, which lists New Era first among its headwear brands, ships US orders over $34 free. On the most common order, one cap, the brand's own store is the dearer and slower place to buy its own product.
First action
Pull last quarter's orders and abandoned carts between $40 and $100, with their conversion rate and the share that drop at the shipping step.
How to measure it
Cart-to-order rate for carts of $40-$100
- Now
- –
- Target
- +10%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Size the gap
Orders and abandoned carts between $40 and $100, and shipping cost per order today.
Director, E-commerce 2 days
Model the margin
Break-even threshold at current FedEx and UPS rates, with and without the add-on shelf.
E-commerce Finance Analyst 2 days
Build the split test
Half of US traffic sees the one-cap threshold, half sees $100.
Shopify Developer 3 days
Add the progress bar
"$X to free shipping" in the cart drawer and cart page.
Shopify Developer 2 days
Stock the add-on shelf
Beanies, 9FIFTY truckers and 9SEVENTY snaps under $30.
E-commerce Merchandising Manager 2 days
Align every message
Help page, announcement bar, cart and app show the same rule.
Customer Experience Manager 1 day
Decide
Keep the lower threshold, adjust it, or move free shipping into rewards.
Director, E-commerce after 4 weeks
Why it works
Run a four-week split test of a lower free-shipping threshold set just above one premium cap (for example $50) against today's $100, measuring checkout conversion, order value and shipping cost per order. Show the threshold in the cart with a progress bar, and offer a short shelf of $19-$28 add-ons (Everyday Classics beanies, 9FIFTY truckers, 9SEVENTY stretch-snaps) for carts just under it. If margin cannot carry a lower public threshold, make free shipping a rewards-member benefit, so joining is how a fan drops the $8. Update the shipping help page, the cart and the announcement bar together so all three show the same rule.
Unexpected shipping cost is one of the most common reasons shoppers abandon a cart, and here it lands on the core one-cap order where a big wholesale partner is cheaper. A threshold set at one cap changes the shopper's question from "where do I buy this" to "which cap", and the member version grows the rewards list at the same time.
Ready to use
ChecklistOne-cap shipping test checklist
[ ] Baseline: conversion and abandonment for carts $40-$100 [ ] Break-even threshold at current carrier rates [ ] 50/50 split: one-cap threshold vs $100 [ ] Cart progress bar: "$X to free shipping" [ ] Add-on shelf of items under $30 [ ] Same rule on help page, announcement bar, cart and app [ ] Readout after 4 weeks: conversion, revenue per visitor, shipping cost per order [ ] Fallback: free shipping as a rewards-member benefit
Risks and how to handle them
Shipping cost eats the margin
Limit the test to half of traffic and track shipping cost per order daily.
Average order value falls
Measure revenue per visitor, not just conversion, and lean on the add-on shelf.
Evidence
- Your websiteShipping help page (checked November 3, 2026): "most orders are shipped within 3-5 business days"; Standard Ground (7-10 business days) is free on pre-tax orders over $100.00 and $8.00 on orders of $99.99 or less; Expedited Ground (2-4 business days) costs $15.00 and Express Air (1-3 business days) $25.00; orders ship by FedEx or UPS.Source
- Your websiteCatalogue (500 products scanned November 3, 2026): prices run from $18.75 to $239.99 with a median of $42.99; lower-priced lines include Everyday Classics beanies at $18.75, 9FIFTY trucker hats at $21.99 and NFL 9SEVENTY stretch-snap hats at $26.24-$28.49; checkout takes PayPal, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay.Source
- Competitor researchLids homepage (checked November 3, 2026): "FREE SHIPPING ON U.S. ORDERS OVER $34"; its "Headwear Brands" list starts with New Era, then '47, Nike, Mitchell & Ness, Fanatics, Jordan Brand, Adidas and Under Armour; the footer links to "Custom Embroidery" and a "Loyalty Program".Source
- Competitor researchMitchell & Ness homepage: "Retro Sports Apparel & Vintage Jerseys", "Free Standard Shipping: US Orders $150+" and a "SIGN UP & SAVE 15%" offer.Source