ProgrammableMarketing/neweracap.com (opens in a new tab)
PDF

Views

  • Plan
  • Roadmap
  • Research

On this page

  • The brief
  • Start here
  • Idea portfolio
  • Effort vs impact
  • This week · 6
  • This quarter · 11
  • Big bets · 3
  • Wildcards · 3
Generated Nov 9, 2026
  1. Programmable
  2. Playbooks
  3. New Era Cap
New Era Cap logo

growth playbook · Nov 9, 2026

neweracap.com (opens in a new tab)

New Era Cap growth playbook

Diagnosis

New Era owns the most recognised cap in sport and has the licences to prove it, but its own US store makes the most common order, one cap, the hardest to buy: free shipping starts at $100 against a $43 median price, delivery takes 3-5 processing days plus 7-10 for ground, and Lids ships the same caps free from $34.

Reviews show the cost: a 1.2 TrustScore, 302 BBB complaints in three years and repeated reports of late orders, small sizes and missing rewards points. The homepage also fails Google's Core Web Vitals for real visitors on layout shift and responsiveness.

This playbook fixes the direct-store basics first (a one-cap shipping threshold, honest delivery dates, a stable homepage and post-delivery reviews), then turns fit, rewards and the app into reasons to buy direct, links the new SoHo flagship and the Opa-Locka decoration capacity to the website, and finally uses New Era's sizing and demand data as an asset no wholesaler has.

Growth Score

6/10

Biggest Opportunity

Make neweracap.com the best place to buy a New Era cap: free shipping on one cap, a delivery date you can trust, a fit you get right first time, and exclusives you can only get direct.

Biggest Risk

Wholesale partners such as Lids sell the same caps with cheaper shipping and loyalty perks, so if the direct store stays slower and dearer, every brand campaign New Era runs sends fans to buy elsewhere while public reviews keep getting worse.

01

Start here

The three moves to make first. Each one is written up in full below.

  1. 1

    Free shipping starts at $100, but the typical cap costs $43: test a one-cap threshold against Lids' $34

    Pull last quarter's orders and abandoned carts between $40 and $100, with their conversion rate and the share that drop at the shipping step.

    High impact First result in 4 weeks
  2. 2

    Show an honest delivery date on every product page and in the cart

    Write the date formula: processing days plus transit days by speed, skipping weekends and holidays.

    High impact First result in 1 month
  3. 3

    Stop the homepage jumping: fix the layout shift that fails Core Web Vitals for real visitors

    Run a performance trace on the homepage and list every element that shifts.

    High impact First result in 1 month

02

Your idea portfolio

23 ideas, grouped by when to run them. Open any idea for how to run it: the steps, who to approach, copy you can use, and how to measure it.

  • 7 ideas are marked Unexpected: plays you are unlikely to have tried.

Every idea placed by the effort it takes against the impact it could have. Quick wins sit top left; select a number to open that idea. The filters below narrow the list by status, timing, category and what Programmable can build.

Effort vs impactEach number is an idea. Select one to open it.
Impact →
Quick wins · 3Big bets · 7Fill-ins · 4Reconsider · 9
Effort →

Showing 23 of 23 ideas

This week 6

Quick wins with a clear first action.

  • 01

    neweracap.com charges $8 for standard shipping on orders below $100 before tax, and the median product in the catalogue is $42.99. A fan buying one 59FIFTY or 9FORTY pays for shipping and then waits 3-5 business days for processing plus 7-10 business days for ground delivery. Lids, which lists New Era first among its headwear brands, ships US orders over $34 free. On the most common order, one cap, the brand's own store is the dearer and slower place to buy its own product.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 4 weeks Director

    First action

    Pull last quarter's orders and abandoned carts between $40 and $100, with their conversion rate and the share that drop at the shipping step.

    How to measure it

    Cart-to-order rate for carts of $40-$100

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Size the gap

      Orders and abandoned carts between $40 and $100, and shipping cost per order today.

      Director, E-commerce 2 days

    2. 2

      Model the margin

      Break-even threshold at current FedEx and UPS rates, with and without the add-on shelf.

      E-commerce Finance Analyst 2 days

    3. 3

      Build the split test

      Half of US traffic sees the one-cap threshold, half sees $100.

      Shopify Developer 3 days

    4. 4

      Add the progress bar

      "$X to free shipping" in the cart drawer and cart page.

      Shopify Developer 2 days

    5. 5

      Stock the add-on shelf

      Beanies, 9FIFTY truckers and 9SEVENTY snaps under $30.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 2 days

    6. 6

      Align every message

      Help page, announcement bar, cart and app show the same rule.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 day

    7. 7

      Decide

      Keep the lower threshold, adjust it, or move free shipping into rewards.

      Director, E-commerce after 4 weeks

    First result
    4 weeks
    Cost
    Shipping subsidy during the test plus about a week of developer time
    Owner
    Director, E commerce

    Smallest test

    Offer free shipping over $50 to email and SMS traffic only for one week and compare checkout completion.

    Why it works

    Run a four-week split test of a lower free-shipping threshold set just above one premium cap (for example $50) against today's $100, measuring checkout conversion, order value and shipping cost per order. Show the threshold in the cart with a progress bar, and offer a short shelf of $19-$28 add-ons (Everyday Classics beanies, 9FIFTY truckers, 9SEVENTY stretch-snaps) for carts just under it. If margin cannot carry a lower public threshold, make free shipping a rewards-member benefit, so joining is how a fan drops the $8. Update the shipping help page, the cart and the announcement bar together so all three show the same rule.

    Unexpected shipping cost is one of the most common reasons shoppers abandon a cart, and here it lands on the core one-cap order where a big wholesale partner is cheaper. A threshold set at one cap changes the shopper's question from "where do I buy this" to "which cap", and the member version grows the rewards list at the same time.

    Ready to use

    ChecklistOne-cap shipping test checklist

    [ ] Baseline: conversion and abandonment for carts $40-$100
    [ ] Break-even threshold at current carrier rates
    [ ] 50/50 split: one-cap threshold vs $100
    [ ] Cart progress bar: "$X to free shipping"
    [ ] Add-on shelf of items under $30
    [ ] Same rule on help page, announcement bar, cart and app
    [ ] Readout after 4 weeks: conversion, revenue per visitor, shipping cost per order
    [ ] Fallback: free shipping as a rewards-member benefit

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Shipping cost eats the margin

      Limit the test to half of traffic and track shipping cost per order daily.

    • Average order value falls

      Measure revenue per visitor, not just conversion, and lean on the add-on shelf.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping help page (checked November 3, 2026): "most orders are shipped within 3-5 business days"; Standard Ground (7-10 business days) is free on pre-tax orders over $100.00 and $8.00 on orders of $99.99 or less; Expedited Ground (2-4 business days) costs $15.00 and Express Air (1-3 business days) $25.00; orders ship by FedEx or UPS.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (500 products scanned November 3, 2026): prices run from $18.75 to $239.99 with a median of $42.99; lower-priced lines include Everyday Classics beanies at $18.75, 9FIFTY trucker hats at $21.99 and NFL 9SEVENTY stretch-snap hats at $26.24-$28.49; checkout takes PayPal, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay.Source
    • Competitor researchLids homepage (checked November 3, 2026): "FREE SHIPPING ON U.S. ORDERS OVER $34"; its "Headwear Brands" list starts with New Era, then '47, Nike, Mitchell & Ness, Fanatics, Jordan Brand, Adidas and Under Armour; the footer links to "Custom Embroidery" and a "Loyalty Program".Source
    • Competitor researchMitchell & Ness homepage: "Retro Sports Apparel & Vintage Jerseys", "Free Standard Shipping: US Orders $150+" and a "SIGN UP & SAVE 15%" offer.Source
  • 02

    The shipping page splits delivery into 3-5 business days of processing and then 7-10 business days of ground transit, so a standard order can take three weeks, but a shopper has to add the two up. The main BBB complaint theme is orders that missed the "stated delivery window", and Trustpilot reviews repeat slow and lost deliveries.

    High impactLow effort First result in 1 month Manager

    First action

    Write the date formula: processing days plus transit days by speed, skipping weekends and holidays.

    How to measure it

    Order-status contacts per 1,000 orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    -25%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Set the formula

      Processing plus transit for each speed, weekends and holidays excluded.

      Manager, Logistics (North America) 1 day

    2. 2

      Feed live processing time

      One setting the warehouse updates when backlog grows.

      Sr. Coordinator, Logistics 2 days

    3. 3

      Show it on product pages

      "Arrives by" under the add-to-bag button.

      Shopify Developer 3 days

    4. 4

      Show it in cart and checkout

      Dates next to each speed so shoppers can choose.

      Shopify Developer 2 days

    5. 5

      Carry it into messages

      Confirmation email and SMS repeat the date.

      CRM Manager 1 day

    6. 6

      Track

      Order-status contacts and expedited uptake.

      Customer Experience Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Developer time only
    Owner
    Manager, Logistics (North America)

    Smallest test

    Add a static "Usually arrives in X-Y business days" line to the top 20 product pages.

    Why it works

    Show one "Arrives by" date range on product pages, in the cart and at checkout, calculated from today's processing time plus each shipping speed, with a cut-off for faster options. Use the same date in the order confirmation email and SMS. When processing slows in peak season, the date moves automatically instead of the promise breaking.

    A clear date sets expectations before purchase, lifts uptake of paid expedited shipping when the date matters (gifts, game days), and cuts "where is my order" contacts.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Dates are missed anyway

      Use the slow end of each range and update the processing setting daily in peak season.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping help page (checked November 3, 2026): "most orders are shipped within 3-5 business days"; Standard Ground (7-10 business days) is free on pre-tax orders over $100.00 and $8.00 on orders of $99.99 or less; Expedited Ground (2-4 business days) costs $15.00 and Express Air (1-3 business days) $25.00; orders ship by FedEx or UPS.Source
    • ReviewsBetter Business Bureau profile for New Era Cap US Retail LLC: A+ rating, not accredited; 302 complaints in the last three years and 95 since December 1, 2024. The main theme is orders not delivered within the "stated delivery window", which the business attributed to a "system error" before cancelling and refunding.Source
    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
  • 03

    Search results still show older New Era help-centre articles saying free standard shipping applies "over $75, before tax", while the current help page sets the threshold at $100. A shopper who searches "New Era free shipping" can read one number and meet another at checkout, which feeds the "company doesn't follow its own policies" complaints.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Customer Experience Manager

    First action

    Search for New Era shipping and returns terms and list every result that shows an old figure.

    How to measure it

    Outdated policy pages in search

    Now
    –
    Target
    0
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      List old pages

      Every indexed help URL with shipping, returns or delivery terms.

      SEO Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Map replacements

      Each old article to its current help page.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      Redirect

      Permanent redirects or removal requests for retired URLs.

      Shopify Developer 2 days

    4. 4

      Request recrawl

      Search Console removal and recrawl.

      SEO Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      One source of truth

      Cart, app and banner read the same policy values.

      Director, E-commerce 1 week

    6. 6

      Check quarterly

      Repeat the search after every policy change.

      SEO Manager quarterly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Customer Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Fix the single most-visible old shipping article this week.

    Why it works

    List every indexed URL that states a shipping threshold, return window or delivery time, redirect the retired help articles to their current equivalents, and ask search engines to recrawl them. Then make the current help page the single source that the cart, app and announcement bar read from.

    Policy mismatches are a quiet cause of abandoned carts and angry tickets; one consistent number removes both.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Old URLs keep appearing for weeks

      Use removal requests as well as redirects.

    Evidence

    • Search listingSearch listing (November 3, 2026): older New Era help-centre articles still appear in search results stating free standard shipping on orders "over $75, before tax", while the current shipping help page sets the threshold at $100.Source
    • Your websiteShipping help page (checked November 3, 2026): "most orders are shipped within 3-5 business days"; Standard Ground (7-10 business days) is free on pre-tax orders over $100.00 and $8.00 on orders of $99.99 or less; Expedited Ground (2-4 business days) costs $15.00 and Express Air (1-3 business days) $25.00; orders ship by FedEx or UPS.Source
    • ReviewsBetter Business Bureau profile for New Era Cap US Retail LLC: A+ rating, not accredited; 302 complaints in the last three years and 95 since December 1, 2024. The main theme is orders not delivered within the "stated delivery window", which the business attributed to a "system error" before cancelling and refunding.Source
  • 04

    Google's real-visitor data for the homepage shows a layout shift score of 0.41, four times the 0.1 limit for "good", and responsiveness of 211 ms, just over the 200 ms limit, so the page fails Core Web Vitals. Loading itself passes for real visitors (LCP 1.9 s), so the problem is content moving after it appears, typically late banners, consent bars, review widgets and promo tiles without reserved space.

    High impactLow effort First result in 1 month Shopify Developer

    First action

    Run a performance trace on the homepage and list every element that shifts.

    How to measure it

    Field CLS (75th percentile)

    Now
    –
    Target
    Under 0.1
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Find the shifts

      Performance trace on a mid-range phone, homepage and top 5 collections.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    2. 2

      Reserve space

      Fixed heights for banners, hero tiles and review widgets.

      Shopify Developer 3 days

    3. 3

      Overlay the consent bar

      Show it above content instead of pushing it down.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    4. 4

      Defer extras

      Load chat, reviews and marketing pop-ups after first interaction.

      Shopify Developer 3 days

    5. 5

      Test with traffic

      Compare mobile bounce and add-to-bag rate before and after.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Confirm in field data

      Search Console Core Web Vitals after 28 days.

      SEO Manager 28 days

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Developer time only
    Owner
    Shopify Developer

    Smallest test

    Fix the announcement and consent bars first and watch the field CLS trend.

    Why it works

    Record the homepage and top collection pages on a mid-range phone to find which elements move (announcement bar, consent banner, hero tiles such as the NHL All 32 Remix image, review stars, app banner). Reserve fixed space for each, load the consent banner as an overlay rather than pushing content, and defer non-essential scripts until after the first tap. Recheck in Search Console's Core Web Vitals report after 28 days.

    Layout shift causes mis-taps on mobile, the device most fans shop on, and Core Web Vitals feed into search ranking. Fixing reserved space is usually CSS work, not a redesign.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Marketing tiles need flexible heights

      Agree fixed aspect ratios for hero and promo images.

    Evidence

    • Google PageSpeedHomepage test, November 3, 2026: mobile performance 44/100 (desktop 74). Real Chrome visitors fail Core Web Vitals on layout shift (CLS 0.41; "good" is 0.1 or less) and responsiveness (INP 211 ms; "good" is 200 ms or less), while real-visitor loading (LCP 1.9 s) passes. In the lab the page weighs 4.3 MB over 349 requests, including 2.5 MB of JavaScript (974 KB unused) and 1.45 s of render-blocking requests; the largest element is the "Shop the NHL All 32 Remix Collection" image.Source
    • Google PageSpeedThird-party code on the homepage: 38 third-party hosts sending 2.3 MB. Google Tag Manager alone is 696 KB with 852 ms of main-thread blocking; two consent tools load (Osano, 489 ms of blocking, and Consentmo); Klaviyo makes 35 requests and Yotpo blocks for 275 ms; ad and analytics tags from Snapchat, The Trade Desk, Bing, X (Twitter), Google and Microsoft Clarity also load. The Optimizely testing tool was removed in the past year.Source
  • 05

    New Era's Trustpilot score is 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star, and Trustpilot itself notes the company has not invited customers to review, so the page holds only people who went looking for somewhere to complain. Meanwhile the iPhone app holds 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings, which shows the silent majority is happy.

    High impactLow effort First result in 1 month Customer Experience Manager

    First action

    Claim the Trustpilot business profile and connect it to the post-delivery email flow.

    How to measure it

    TrustScore

    Now
    –
    Target
    3.5 or higher
    By
    6 months

    Steps

    1. 1

      Claim the profile

      Verify ownership and set up replies.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Trigger on delivery

      Invite 3 days after carrier delivery, not at shipment.

      CRM Manager 2 days

    3. 3

      Catch problems first

      "Anything wrong?" link to support in the same email.

      Customer Experience Manager 2 days

    4. 4

      Reply to recent reviews

      Last 90 days, each with a concrete fix.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Tag the themes

      Shipping, sizing, quality, refunds, for the ops teams.

      Customer Experience Manager weekly

    6. 6

      Report

      Score, volume and theme trend.

      Director, E-commerce monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Trustpilot plan plus staff time
    Owner
    Customer Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Invite one week of delivered orders and compare their average rating with the current page.

    Why it works

    Claim the Trustpilot profile, and send an invitation to every US order a few days after the carrier marks it delivered, through the existing Klaviyo and Yotpo flows. Reply publicly to recent negative reviews with a fix, and route anyone who reports a problem in the invitation to support before they post. Keep product reviews in Yotpo; this is about the company-level score that appears in search.

    Company review scores appear next to the brand name in search and in shopping comparisons; a score built only from complaints misrepresents a brand whose app customers rate it 4.9.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Invitations reach customers with late orders

      Only invite after confirmed delivery and offer the support link first.

    • Review-platform rules

      Invite all buyers, never only happy ones, and offer no incentive.

    Evidence

    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
    • App StoreShop New Era for iPhone: 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings; version 7.6, updated October 16, 2026, and recent version notes repeat the same three lines (accounts, faster checkout, order tracking). Reviews mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text", purchases not earning rewards, a 20% coupon that disappeared from checkout, and a request for a size filter. The site also links an Android app on Google Play.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage title "New Era | New Era Hats & Apparel – New Era Cap"; meta description: "New Era is your online hat store for all MLB, NBA, NFL & NHL teams. Shop Fitted, Snapback, Knit & Adjustable Hats, today." The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email, Postscript SMS, Gorgias support chat, Yotpo reviews and a Rakuten affiliate programme, ships within the US only, and its top sellers include entertainment licences such as Batman and The Jetsons.Source
  • 06

    The catalogue already has low-priced items that fit next to a cap: Everyday Classics beanies at $18.75, 9FIFTY truckers at $21.99 and NFL 9SEVENTY stretch-snaps from $26.24. Whatever the threshold ends up being, a shopper a few dollars short of it needs an easy, relevant add-on rather than a search.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 3 weeks E commerce Merchandising Mana…

    First action

    Pick the top three add-ons per league from last season's attach data.

    How to measure it

    Average order value

    Now
    –
    Target
    +8%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Choose items

      Low-price, in-stock, broad-size items per league.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Set the rules

      Same team first, then season, then best-seller.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      Build the shelf

      Cart drawer and cart page, one-tap add.

      Shopify Developer 2 days

    4. 4

      Show the gap

      "Add $X for free shipping" above the shelf.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    5. 5

      Test

      Shelf vs no shelf on half of traffic.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 3 weeks

    6. 6

      Rotate

      Refresh items each season and drop.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager monthly

    First result
    3 weeks
    Cost
    Developer time only
    Owner
    E commerce Merchandising Manager

    Smallest test

    Show one same-team beanie in the cart for winter caps.

    Why it works

    Show three add-ons in the cart drawer chosen by what is in the cart: the same team in another style, a seasonal beanie, or a cap-care item. Show the gap to free shipping above them. Rotate by season (knits in winter, truckers in summer).

    Shoppers close to a threshold readily add a small item instead of paying for shipping, which lifts order value without a discount.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Distraction lowers checkout rate

      Keep it to three items below the checkout button.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCatalogue (500 products scanned November 3, 2026): prices run from $18.75 to $239.99 with a median of $42.99; lower-priced lines include Everyday Classics beanies at $18.75, 9FIFTY trucker hats at $21.99 and NFL 9SEVENTY stretch-snap hats at $26.24-$28.49; checkout takes PayPal, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay.Source
    • Your websiteShipping help page (checked November 3, 2026): "most orders are shipped within 3-5 business days"; Standard Ground (7-10 business days) is free on pre-tax orders over $100.00 and $8.00 on orders of $99.99 or less; Expedited Ground (2-4 business days) costs $15.00 and Express Air (1-3 business days) $25.00; orders ship by FedEx or UPS.Source

This quarter 11

The core plays for the next three months.

  • 07

    BBB complaints centre on orders that missed the stated delivery window, and Trustpilot reviewers describe automated, repetitive replies once they do ask. New Era already runs Postscript for SMS, Klaviyo for email and Gorgias for support, and is hiring a logistics manager, a senior logistics coordinator and a freight auditor, so the data and owners exist.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 6 weeks Customer Experience Manager

    First action

    Count last month's orders that shipped after day 5 or sat with no carrier scan for 3 days.

    How to measure it

    Complaints per 100 late orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    -40%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Define late

      Not shipped by day 5, or no carrier scan for 3 days.

      Manager, Logistics (North America) 1 day

    2. 2

      Build the flag

      Daily list from order and carrier data.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Write the messages

      New date and three choices, by SMS and email.

      CRM Manager 3 days

    4. 4

      Connect to support

      Late flag visible in each Gorgias ticket.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Fund the upgrade

      Budget for free upgrades on late orders.

      Director, E-commerce 1 day

    6. 6

      Audit carriers

      Late-scan patterns by carrier and region.

      Logistics Freight Auditor monthly

    First result
    6 weeks
    Cost
    Upgrade costs on late orders plus build time
    Owner
    Customer Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Email last week's late orders a new date and a free-upgrade offer by hand.

    Why it works

    Flag any order that has not shipped by the end of the processing window, or has stalled with the carrier, and send a plain message with a new date and a choice: wait, upgrade shipping free, or cancel for an instant refund. Give support agents the same view so the first human reply already has the answer.

    A customer told early about a delay is far less likely to complain publicly than one who discovers it; proactive messages also cut ticket volume.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Too many messages in peak season

      One message per order, with a link to live status.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • ReviewsBetter Business Bureau profile for New Era Cap US Retail LLC: A+ rating, not accredited; 302 complaints in the last three years and 95 since December 1, 2024. The main theme is orders not delivered within the "stated delivery window", which the business attributed to a "system error" before cancelling and refunding.Source
    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
    • HiringCareers listing (24 open roles, newest posted October 30, 2026): 18 in Buffalo, 4 at the Opa-Locka, Florida site (Embroidery Machine Operator, Direct-to-Garment (DTG) Printer Machine Operator, Printing Department Floater, Production Administrator) and 2 seasonal store roles in New York. Supply chain: Global Demand Planner, Supply Chain Planner, Manager, Logistics (North America), Sr. Coordinator, Logistics and a temporary Logistics Freight Auditor. Brand and retail: Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation and a temporary Sales Associate for the HQ Flagship in Buffalo.Source
  • 08

    The 59FIFTY is sold in fitted sizes, and New Era's size guide asks shoppers to measure their head with a tape "about 1 inch above your eyebrows" and convert it with a chart. Few fans own a tape; most own a fitted. Trustpilot reviewers report caps that ran smaller than the stated size, and an app reviewer asked for a size filter.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Director

    First action

    Pull the return-for-size rate by style and size to see where advice is most needed.

    How to measure it

    Fitted returns for size

    Now
    –
    Target
    -20%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Measure the problem

      Size returns by style, size and channel.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Write the fit rules

      Style-to-style size mapping from product specs.

      Technical Design Specialist 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Design the finder

      Two questions, one answer, saved to the account.

      UX Designer 1 week

    4. 4

      Build it

      On fitted product pages and in the app.

      Shopify Developer 3 weeks

    5. 5

      Add the size filter

      Collections filter to in-stock caps in the saved size.

      Mobile App Product Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Tune

      Update rules from return reasons monthly.

      Technical Design Specialist monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Design and developer time; can replace the current size-chart widget
    Owner
    Director, E commerce

    Smallest test

    Add "Already own a 59FIFTY? Order the same size" copy with style exceptions to the top 50 fitted pages.

    Why it works

    Add a two-question fit finder to every fitted product: "Which New Era fitted fits you now, and how does it feel?" then recommend a size for this style, with style-specific notes where a crown or profile fits differently. Save the answer to the account so collections can filter to in-stock caps in the shopper's size, on the site and in the app. Use returns-for-size data to tune the advice.

    Starting from a cap the shopper owns is easier and more accurate than a tape measure, and filtering to in-stock sizes removes the most frustrating dead end in fitted shopping.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Advice is wrong for unusual styles

      Show confidence and fall back to the size chart where data is thin.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteSizing (as indexed in search): New Era's size guide tells shoppers to measure around the head "about 1 inch above your eyebrows" and convert the measurement to a fitted size with the chart at /pages/sizing-chart; the store also loads a third-party size-chart widget.Source
    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
    • App StoreShop New Era for iPhone: 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings; version 7.6, updated October 16, 2026, and recent version notes repeat the same three lines (accounts, faster checkout, order tracking). Reviews mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text", purchases not earning rewards, a 20% coupon that disappeared from checkout, and a request for a size filter. The site also links an Android app on Google Play.Source
  • 09

    Fitted caps are the one product where a correct order can still be wrong for the buyer, and reviewers report sizes that ran small and slow refunds. A wholesale retailer can match New Era on price, but only the brand can promise the right size from its own stock.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 6 weeks Customer Experience Manager

    First action

    Cost last year's size returns as exchanges instead of refunds.

    How to measure it

    Size returns kept as exchanges

    Now
    –
    Target
    60%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Cost it

      Return shipping and handling per exchange.

      E-commerce Finance Analyst 3 days

    2. 2

      Set the rule

      One free exchange per fitted order, same style.

      Director, E-commerce 1 day

    3. 3

      Ship on scan

      Release the replacement on the carrier's first scan.

      Manager, Logistics (North America) 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Update the returns flow

      Choose the new size in the returns portal.

      Customer Experience Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Promote it

      Line next to the size picker and in the cart.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 1 day

    6. 6

      Track

      Fitted conversion, exchange rate and abuse.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    6 weeks
    Cost
    Return shipping on exchanges
    Owner
    Customer Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Offer the free exchange on 59FIFTY only for a month.

    Why it works

    Offer one free size exchange per fitted order: the customer picks the new size online, the replacement ships when the return is scanned by the carrier, not when it reaches the warehouse. Say so on every fitted product page next to the size picker.

    Removing the fear of getting the size wrong raises conversion on fitted caps, and exchanges keep revenue that refunds lose.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Abuse of free exchanges

      One per order and replacement only once the return is scanned.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
    • Your websiteSizing (as indexed in search): New Era's size guide tells shoppers to measure around the head "about 1 inch above your eyebrows" and convert the measurement to a fitted size with the chart at /pages/sizing-chart; the store also loads a third-party size-chart widget.Source
  • 10

    New Era's rewards programme unlocks products by VIP tier, with a quarterly drop of exclusive product for VIP members and tier-locked caps such as a "Platinum Tier" 59FIFTY. That only works if fans trust their balance, yet an app reviewer reports purchases not earning rewards and another a coupon that vanished from checkout.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 6 weeks CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Run a reconciliation of last quarter's orders against points credited.

    How to measure it

    90-day repeat rate, members

    Now
    –
    Target
    +15%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Reconcile

      Orders vs points credited, app and web.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Fix the gaps

      Auto-credit misses and fix the cause.

      Shopify Developer 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Show the points

      Product page, cart and confirmation.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Show the next tier

      Progress in post-purchase emails and the app.

      CRM Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Arm support

      One-click re-credit in Gorgias.

      Customer Experience Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Publish the rules

      One clear earn, tier and expiry page.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 days

    First result
    6 weeks
    Cost
    Developer time; points liability already budgeted
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Email members their current balance and next tier and measure 30-day purchases.

    Why it works

    Show "You'll earn X points" on product pages and in the cart, the new balance on the confirmation page, and the distance to the next tier in every post-purchase email. Reconcile points against orders nightly, auto-credit any misses, and give support agents a one-click re-credit. Publish the earn and tier rules on one page.

    A visible, reliable balance makes the tier ladder motivating; missing points turn the most loyal fans into the most vocal critics.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Back-crediting raises points liability

      Credit only verified misses and track liability monthly.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteRewards (as indexed in search): the "Exclusive offers" page says members earn points and rewards, products unlock by VIP tier and VIP members get a quarterly drop of exclusive product; the catalogue includes tier-locked styles such as the "Black Platinum Tier Chrome White Knit 59FIFTY Fitted Hat".Source
    • App StoreShop New Era for iPhone: 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings; version 7.6, updated October 16, 2026, and recent version notes repeat the same three lines (accounts, faster checkout, order tracking). Reviews mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text", purchases not earning rewards, a 20% coupon that disappeared from checkout, and a request for a size filter. The site also links an Android app on Google Play.Source
  • 11

    VIP members get a quarterly drop of exclusive product, and the app is rated 4.9 by about 22,000 people, but the app's own description never mentions drops, early access or rewards. Drops are the reason collectors install brand apps.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in Next quarterly drop Mobile App Product Manager

    First action

    Add drops and tier access to the app store descriptions.

    How to measure it

    App share of drop revenue

    Now
    –
    Target
    50%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Rewrite store listings

      Lead with drops, tiers and early access.

      Mobile App Product Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Build countdown pages

      One per drop, in-app.

      Mobile App Product Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Add notify-me

      Saves team and size to the profile.

      Mobile App Product Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Segment pushes

      By tier, team and size.

      CRM Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Add the app bonus

      Extra points for app purchases on drop day.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      App share, sell-through and installs per drop.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager per drop

    First result
    Next quarterly drop
    Cost
    App platform work plus points bonus
    Owner
    Mobile App Product Manager

    Smallest test

    Send one push for the next tier drop to app users with a saved team.

    Why it works

    Give every tier drop a countdown page in the app, a notify-me button that saves team and size, and a push at release to members in that tier. Members who buy in the app earn a small points bonus. Mention drops and tier access in the App Store and Google Play descriptions.

    Push alerts with saved sizes turn a quarterly drop into a habit and move the most valuable fans onto a channel with no ad cost.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Drop-day load slows the app

      Load-test before release; reviewers already report slow pages.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteRewards (as indexed in search): the "Exclusive offers" page says members earn points and rewards, products unlock by VIP tier and VIP members get a quarterly drop of exclusive product; the catalogue includes tier-locked styles such as the "Black Platinum Tier Chrome White Knit 59FIFTY Fitted Hat".Source
    • App StoreShop New Era for iPhone: 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings; version 7.6, updated October 16, 2026, and recent version notes repeat the same three lines (accounts, faster checkout, order tracking). Reviews mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text", purchases not earning rewards, a 20% coupon that disappeared from checkout, and a request for a size filter. The site also links an Android app on Google Play.Source
  • 12

    The homepage loads two consent managers (Osano, with 489 ms of main-thread blocking, and Consentmo), Google Tag Manager at 696 KB and 852 ms of blocking, and ad and analytics tags from six networks, 38 third-party hosts in all. Real visitors fail Core Web Vitals on responsiveness (INP 211 ms), which is exactly what main-thread blocking hurts. The testing tool was removed last year, so there is no experiment running that needs all of this.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Director

    First action

    Decide which consent manager stays, based on which one the legal team configured.

    How to measure it

    Field INP (75th percentile)

    Now
    –
    Target
    Under 200 ms
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick one consent tool

      Keep the one that matches current legal settings.

      Asst. Manager, Legal Operations & Contract Management 1 week

    2. 2

      Inventory tags

      Every Tag Manager and theme tag, with owner and purpose.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Remove orphans

      Tags with no owner or unused data.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Defer the rest

      After consent and first interaction.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    5. 5

      Check attribution

      Confirm paid channels still report correctly.

      Performance Marketing Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Review quarterly

      Owners re-confirm each tag.

      Director, E-commerce quarterly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time; one consent subscription saved
    Owner
    Director, E commerce

    Smallest test

    Remove the duplicate consent tool on a test theme and measure blocking time.

    Why it works

    Keep one consent manager and remove the other. List every tag in Tag Manager and on the theme with an owner, a purpose and the last time its data was used; remove what nobody claims, and load the rest after consent and first interaction. Publish the list internally and review it each quarter.

    Duplicate tools cost speed and money without adding data, and a named owner per tag stops the list from regrowing.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Breaking ad attribution

      Remove tags one at a time and watch channel reports for a week.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Google PageSpeedThird-party code on the homepage: 38 third-party hosts sending 2.3 MB. Google Tag Manager alone is 696 KB with 852 ms of main-thread blocking; two consent tools load (Osano, 489 ms of blocking, and Consentmo); Klaviyo makes 35 requests and Yotpo blocks for 275 ms; ad and analytics tags from Snapchat, The Trade Desk, Bing, X (Twitter), Google and Microsoft Clarity also load. The Optimizely testing tool was removed in the past year.Source
    • Google PageSpeedHomepage test, November 3, 2026: mobile performance 44/100 (desktop 74). Real Chrome visitors fail Core Web Vitals on layout shift (CLS 0.41; "good" is 0.1 or less) and responsiveness (INP 211 ms; "good" is 200 ms or less), while real-visitor loading (LCP 1.9 s) passes. In the lab the page weighs 4.3 MB over 349 requests, including 2.5 MB of JavaScript (974 KB unused) and 1.45 s of render-blocking requests; the largest element is the "Shop the NHL All 32 Remix Collection" image.Source
  • 13

    New Era's SoHo flagship opened on April 27, 2026 with a customization station, a 17x20-foot street-facing screen showing the latest drops and campaigns, and a "digitally-led, immersive shopping journey". It promises "international exclusives you can't get anywhere else". New Era is also hiring seasonal store staff in New York and a sales associate for the Buffalo HQ flagship.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Coordinator

    First action

    Add pick-up-in-store as a shipping option for the two flagships on Shopify.

    How to measure it

    Flagship-attributed online orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    1,000 a quarter
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Enable pick-up

      Shopify local pick-up for SoHo and Buffalo.

      Director, E-commerce 1 week

    2. 2

      Build flagship pages

      Exclusives, hours and booking.

      Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Add booking

      Time slots for the customization station.

      Retail Store Manager, NYC Flagship 1 week

    4. 4

      QR on the screen

      Each campaign links to the drop in the app.

      Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation ongoing

    5. 5

      Sign up in store

      Rewards sign-up at the till with a points bonus.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Pick-ups, bookings and in-store sign-ups.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time and booking tool
    Owner
    Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation

    Smallest test

    Offer SoHo pick-up for one weekend drop and count orders.

    Why it works

    Give each flagship a page with live exclusives, opening hours and a booking slot for the customization station. Offer buy online, pick up in store for New York and Buffalo shoppers, which also sidesteps the three-week ground delivery. Put a QR code on the street screen's content that opens the featured drop in the app, and capture flagship visitors' emails with in-store sign-up for rewards.

    Flagships create local demand and footfall that today ends at the door; linking them to the site and app turns a visit into a customer record and a repeat buyer.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Store stock does not match online

      Limit pick-up to items with live store inventory.

    Evidence

    • PressFashionUnited, April 2026: New Era's SoHo flagship at Houston and Lafayette Streets opened April 27 with a customization station, a 17x20-foot street-facing screen showing the brand's latest drops and campaigns, a wall of up to 50 caps including original wooden hat forms, and a "digitally-led, immersive shopping journey" modelled on the Buffalo flagship.Source
    • PressMR Magazine: the NYC flagship is meant to "offer products, collaborations, and international exclusives you can't get anywhere else", and New Era is "commemorating 59FIFTY Day with a collection created with iconic filmmaker Spike Lee".Source
    • HiringCareers listing (24 open roles, newest posted October 30, 2026): 18 in Buffalo, 4 at the Opa-Locka, Florida site (Embroidery Machine Operator, Direct-to-Garment (DTG) Printer Machine Operator, Printing Department Floater, Production Administrator) and 2 seasonal store roles in New York. Supply chain: Global Demand Planner, Supply Chain Planner, Manager, Logistics (North America), Sr. Coordinator, Logistics and a temporary Logistics Freight Auditor. Brand and retail: Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation and a temporary Sales Associate for the HQ Flagship in Buffalo.Source
  • 14

    New Era's team page says "dealers and coaches can now customize a New Era Cap at the click of a button", but the cap builder is only reached by contacting a current team dealer. A youth coach or company that finds the page has no next step, while Lids advertises custom embroidery in its footer.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Team Sports Sales Manager

    First action

    Count monthly visits to the team page and the dealer contacts that follow today.

    How to measure it

    Routed team requests

    Now
    –
    Target
    200 a month
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Agree routing

      Dealer territories and a one-day response rule.

      Team Sports Sales Manager 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Build the form

      Five fields on the team page.

      Shopify Developer 3 days

    3. 3

      Add proof

      Gallery of real team caps and timelines.

      Associate Artist, Graphic Operations 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Route leads

      Automatic hand-off to the dealer with New Era copied.

      Sales Operations 1 week

    5. 5

      Promote

      Search and coach-focused social before each season.

      Performance Marketing Manager seasonal

    6. 6

      Review dealers

      Response time and conversion by dealer.

      Team Sports Sales Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Staff time and a light form build
    Owner
    Team Sports Sales Manager

    Smallest test

    Add a request form and route manually for one month.

    Why it works

    Add a short request form to the team page (organisation type, number of caps, style, deadline) and route each request to the nearest team dealer within one business day, with New Era copied. Show a gallery of real team caps and a sample timeline. Track which dealers convert and how fast.

    Teams order every season and in volume; capturing the request keeps the dealer model intact while making sure no lead is lost.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Dealers respond slowly

      Re-route after one business day.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteTeam page (as indexed in search): "dealers and coaches can now customize a New Era Cap at the click of a button", but the cap builder is reached by contacting one of New Era's current team dealers.Source
    • Competitor researchLids homepage (checked November 3, 2026): "FREE SHIPPING ON U.S. ORDERS OVER $34"; its "Headwear Brands" list starts with New Era, then '47, Nike, Mitchell & Ness, Fanatics, Jordan Brand, Adidas and Under Armour; the footer links to "Custom Embroidery" and a "Loyalty Program".Source
  • 15

    Lids lists New Era first among its headwear brands and ships from $34, so for standard team caps the direct store competes on convenience and loses. What New Era alone has is tier-locked rewards caps, flagship and "international exclusives you can't get anywhere else", and collaborations.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month E commerce Merchandising Mana…

    First action

    List which current products are exclusive to direct channels.

    How to measure it

    Exclusive share of DTC revenue

    Now
    –
    Target
    +5 points
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      List exclusives

      Direct-only styles, tier caps and collaborations.

      Associate, Product Line 1 week

    2. 2

      Tag products

      Badge and product tag in Shopify.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 2 days

    3. 3

      Build the collection

      "Only at New Era" page and filter.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 2 days

    4. 4

      Lead campaigns

      Email and paid social feature exclusives.

      CRM Manager ongoing

    5. 5

      Plan more

      A direct-only colourway in each major collection.

      Associate, Product Line seasonal

    6. 6

      Measure

      Exclusive revenue share and new customers.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time
    Owner
    E commerce Merchandising Manager

    Smallest test

    Badge the current exclusives and compare their conversion for two weeks.

    Why it works

    Tag every product that is exclusive to New Era's own channels with an "Only at New Era" badge, give them a collection page and a filter, and lead email and paid social with them. For standard wholesale styles, compete on fit help, delivery dates and rewards rather than price.

    Exclusivity is the strongest reason for a fan to choose the brand's store over a multi-brand retailer, and today it is not signposted.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Wholesale partners object

      Keep exclusives to colourways and collaborations, not core team caps.

    Evidence

    • Competitor researchLids homepage (checked November 3, 2026): "FREE SHIPPING ON U.S. ORDERS OVER $34"; its "Headwear Brands" list starts with New Era, then '47, Nike, Mitchell & Ness, Fanatics, Jordan Brand, Adidas and Under Armour; the footer links to "Custom Embroidery" and a "Loyalty Program".Source
    • Your websiteRewards (as indexed in search): the "Exclusive offers" page says members earn points and rewards, products unlock by VIP tier and VIP members get a quarterly drop of exclusive product; the catalogue includes tier-locked styles such as the "Black Platinum Tier Chrome White Knit 59FIFTY Fitted Hat".Source
    • PressMR Magazine: the NYC flagship is meant to "offer products, collaborations, and international exclusives you can't get anywhere else", and New Era is "commemorating 59FIFTY Day with a collection created with iconic filmmaker Spike Lee".Source
  • 16

    New Era already marks 59FIFTY Day, this year with a Spike Lee collection, and the 59FIFTY dates back to 1954. Unlike league moments, it is a date the brand owns outright and no wholesaler can claim.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in Next 59FIFTY Day Coordinator

    First action

    Fix the date and the collaboration for next year's 59FIFTY Day.

    How to measure it

    59FIFTY Day week DTC revenue

    Now
    –
    Target
    +30% year on year
    By
    next 59FIFTY Day

    Steps

    1. 1

      Fix the date

      Same date every year, announced early.

      Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation 1 week

    2. 2

      Plan the drop

      One collaboration, members first in the app.

      Associate, Product Line 1 quarter

    3. 3

      Set the rewards

      Double points on fitted caps that week.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Plan flagship events

      Buffalo and SoHo, with customization.

      Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation 1 month

    5. 5

      Build the story page

      History of the 59FIFTY and fan photos.

      Content Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Revenue, new members and social reach.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager after the event

    First result
    Next 59FIFTY Day
    Cost
    Collaboration and event budget
    Owner
    Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation

    Smallest test

    Run double points on fitted caps for 59FIFTY Day week only.

    Why it works

    Turn 59FIFTY Day into a yearly event with a fixed date: a members-first collaboration drop in the app, double points on fitted caps, flagship events in Buffalo and New York, a "show your oldest 59FIFTY" social call-out and a story page about the cap's history. Plan it a year ahead so wholesale partners get the halo but the direct channels get the exclusives.

    An owned annual moment builds anticipation and gives email, SMS and the app a guaranteed peak outside the sports calendar.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Drop sells out and frustrates fans

      Members-first windows and a raffle for limited items.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • PressMR Magazine: the NYC flagship is meant to "offer products, collaborations, and international exclusives you can't get anywhere else", and New Era is "commemorating 59FIFTY Day with a collection created with iconic filmmaker Spike Lee".Source
    • WikipediaNew Era Cap Company: founded in Buffalo in 1920; "over 500 different licenses"; exclusive MLB on-field cap since 1993, NFL sideline rights from 2012, NBA authentic headwear since 2016, official NHL hat from July 2024 and UFL partner from February 2026; the 59FIFTY fitted dates to 1954.Source
  • 17

    New Era is the on-field cap of MLB, the sideline cap of the NFL and the official hat of the NBA and NHL, so every clinch, championship and draft creates a search spike for that team's cap. Pages built on the day compete with every retailer; pages that already rank collect the spike.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter SEO Manager

    First action

    List the moments with the biggest past sales spikes and their current landing pages.

    How to measure it

    Moment-page organic revenue

    Now
    –
    Target
    +25% year on year
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick moments

      Top ten by past revenue spike.

      SEO Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Fix URLs

      One evergreen URL per team and moment.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    3. 3

      Add history

      Previous years' caps and stories.

      Content Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Add notify-me

      Email and SMS sign-up per team.

      CRM Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Switch to live

      Playbook for the hour after a result.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager per moment

    6. 6

      Measure

      Rank, sign-ups and revenue per moment.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager per moment

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Content and developer time
    Owner
    SEO Manager

    Smallest test

    Build pages for one league's championship before its next postseason.

    Why it works

    Create an evergreen page per team and moment type (division champions, conference champions, champions, draft) with the URL fixed in advance, past years' caps, and a notify-me for this year's. Switch the page to live product the moment the result is in, and send the notify-me list first.

    Search engines rank pages that already exist and have history; a notify-me list turns the spike into owned demand before stock even lands.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • League rules on pre-announcing products

      Keep pre-moment pages to history and notify-me, with no unreleased product.

    Evidence

    • WikipediaNew Era Cap Company: founded in Buffalo in 1920; "over 500 different licenses"; exclusive MLB on-field cap since 1993, NFL sideline rights from 2012, NBA authentic headwear since 2016, official NHL hat from July 2024 and UFL partner from February 2026; the 59FIFTY fitted dates to 1954.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage title "New Era | New Era Hats & Apparel – New Era Cap"; meta description: "New Era is your online hat store for all MLB, NBA, NFL & NHL teams. Shop Fitted, Snapback, Knit & Adjustable Hats, today." The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email, Postscript SMS, Gorgias support chat, Yotpo reviews and a Rakuten affiliate programme, ships within the US only, and its top sellers include entertainment licences such as Batman and The Jetsons.Source

Big bets 3

Larger plays that can change the trajectory.

  • 18

    The SoHo flagship has a customization station, and New Era is hiring embroidery, direct-to-garment and print operators plus a production administrator at its Opa-Locka, Florida site. The decoration capacity exists, but personalization on neweracap.com is limited to team dealers' cap builder.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 2 quarters Production Administrator

    First action

    Ask Opa-Locka for spare decoration capacity and per-unit cost for a side patch on a 59FIFTY.

    How to measure it

    Custom cap revenue

    Now
    –
    Target
    3% of DTC revenue
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Size capacity

      Spare embroidery and print capacity and unit cost.

      Production Administrator 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Clear licences

      Which patches are allowed on which caps.

      Manager, Assistant/Associate Corporate Counsel 1 month

    3. 3

      Curate the library

      30 patches and pins to start.

      Associate Artist, Graphic Operations 1 month

    4. 4

      Build the customizer

      Preview, price and make date on product pages.

      Shopify Developer 6 weeks

    5. 5

      Connect production

      Orders flow to Opa-Locka with work tickets.

      Production Administrator 1 month

    6. 6

      Pilot

      Members only, five base caps.

      Director, E-commerce 6 weeks

    7. 7

      Scale

      Add caps, leagues and gift messaging.

      Director, E-commerce ongoing

    First result
    2 quarters
    Cost
    Build plus decoration labour; priced as a premium
    Owner
    Production Administrator

    Smallest test

    Sell one New Era-branded side patch on three 59FIFTY blanks to members for a month.

    Why it works

    Launch a simple online customizer for a small set of best-selling blanks and licensed caps: choose a side patch or pin set from a curated library (no free text at first, to stay within licence rules), preview it, and have it made to order at Opa-Locka with a clear make-and-ship date. Start with New Era-branded patches and heritage marks, add licensed patches league by league as approvals allow.

    Personalized caps command a higher price, cannot be bought at a wholesaler, and turn the flagship experience into something every online fan can use.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Licence restrictions on modifying league caps

      Start with New Era-owned patches and add licensed ones only with written approval.

    • Quality complaints

      Photo check before shipping each custom cap.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • PressFashionUnited, April 2026: New Era's SoHo flagship at Houston and Lafayette Streets opened April 27 with a customization station, a 17x20-foot street-facing screen showing the brand's latest drops and campaigns, a wall of up to 50 caps including original wooden hat forms, and a "digitally-led, immersive shopping journey" modelled on the Buffalo flagship.Source
    • HiringCareers listing (24 open roles, newest posted October 30, 2026): 18 in Buffalo, 4 at the Opa-Locka, Florida site (Embroidery Machine Operator, Direct-to-Garment (DTG) Printer Machine Operator, Printing Department Floater, Production Administrator) and 2 seasonal store roles in New York. Supply chain: Global Demand Planner, Supply Chain Planner, Manager, Logistics (North America), Sr. Coordinator, Logistics and a temporary Logistics Freight Auditor. Brand and retail: Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation and a temporary Sales Associate for the HQ Flagship in Buffalo.Source
    • Your websiteTeam page (as indexed in search): "dealers and coaches can now customize a New Era Cap at the click of a button", but the cap builder is reached by contacting one of New Era's current team dealers.Source
  • 19

    New Era is hiring a Global Demand Planner and a Supply Chain Planner while its store sells hundreds of team, style and size combinations. The website sees demand that sales data cannot: views of sold-out sizes, notify-me requests, size-filter use and searches for caps that do not exist.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 1 season Global Demand Planner

    First action

    Export last season's sold-out product views by size and compare them with reorder quantities.

    How to measure it

    Sold-out views on top 100 styles

    Now
    –
    Target
    -20%
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Define signals

      Sold-out views, notify-me, zero-result searches, size-filter use.

      Global Demand Planner 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Capture them

      Events in analytics for each signal.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 month

    3. 3

      Build the weekly file

      By team, style and size.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Pilot in planning

      One league's fitted caps for a season.

      Global Demand Planner 1 season

    5. 5

      Rebalance stock

      Shift between direct and wholesale on signal.

      Supply Chain Planner weekly

    6. 6

      Review

      Stock-outs and markdowns vs the prior season.

      Manager, PMO end of season

    First result
    1 season
    Cost
    Analytics and planning time
    Owner
    Global Demand Planner

    Smallest test

    Send the planner last month's top 50 sold-out sizes by views.

    Why it works

    Feed a weekly signal file from the site and app into planning: lost demand by team, style and size (sold-out views times conversion), notify-me counts, and zero-result searches. Use it to rebalance stock between direct and wholesale, size the next run of a style, and decide which collaboration to reissue.

    Planning on sales alone hides demand that was never met; the direct store is the only channel where New Era sees that demand at size level in real time.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Online signals over-represent collectors

      Weight signals by channel share and test on one league first.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • HiringCareers listing (24 open roles, newest posted October 30, 2026): 18 in Buffalo, 4 at the Opa-Locka, Florida site (Embroidery Machine Operator, Direct-to-Garment (DTG) Printer Machine Operator, Printing Department Floater, Production Administrator) and 2 seasonal store roles in New York. Supply chain: Global Demand Planner, Supply Chain Planner, Manager, Logistics (North America), Sr. Coordinator, Logistics and a temporary Logistics Freight Auditor. Brand and retail: Coordinator, Retail & Brand Activation and a temporary Sales Associate for the HQ Flagship in Buffalo.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (500 products scanned November 3, 2026): prices run from $18.75 to $239.99 with a median of $42.99; lower-priced lines include Everyday Classics beanies at $18.75, 9FIFTY trucker hats at $21.99 and NFL 9SEVENTY stretch-snap hats at $26.24-$28.49; checkout takes PayPal, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay.Source
  • 20

    New Era has sold the 59FIFTY fitted since 1954 and is the on-field cap of four major leagues, so it holds more fitted-size data than anyone. Sizing is also the top product complaint in reviews. A yearly, anonymised report on sizes (most common size by city, by team fan base, how sizes have changed) is a story only New Era can tell.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Content Manager

    First action

    Check that size data can be aggregated by region with no personal details.

    How to measure it

    Referring domains to the report

    Now
    –
    Target
    50
    By
    90 days after launch

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check privacy

      Only regional aggregates, minimum group sizes.

      Manager, Assistant/Associate Corporate Counsel 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Pull the data

      Five years of direct fitted orders.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Find the stories

      Five surprising findings.

      Content Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Design

      Shareable charts and a report page.

      Graphic Designer 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Pitch

      Sports and style media exclusive.

      PR Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Link to fit

      Each finding links to the fit finder.

      Content Manager 1 day

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Analyst and design time
    Owner
    Content Manager

    Smallest test

    Post one chart (most common fitted size by state) on social.

    Why it works

    Aggregate anonymised direct-order sizes into a short annual report with a few shareable charts, release it around 59FIFTY Day, and link each finding to the fit finder. Offer the data to sports and style media as an exclusive.

    Original data earns press links and social shares that product launches do not, and every story ends with "find your size".

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Findings feel trivial

      Test headlines with the social team before publishing.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • WikipediaNew Era Cap Company: founded in Buffalo in 1920; "over 500 different licenses"; exclusive MLB on-field cap since 1993, NFL sideline rights from 2012, NBA authentic headwear since 2016, official NHL hat from July 2024 and UFL partner from February 2026; the 59FIFTY fitted dates to 1954.Source
    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
    • Your websiteSizing (as indexed in search): New Era's size guide tells shoppers to measure around the head "about 1 inch above your eyebrows" and convert the measurement to a fitted size with the chart at /pages/sizing-chart; the store also loads a third-party size-chart widget.Source

Wildcards 3

Unexpected experiments, each with a cheap way to test it.

  • 21

    The Shop New Era app is updated often (version 7.6 on October 16, 2026), but recent version notes repeat the same three lines about accounts, checkout and order tracking. Reviewers mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text" and ask for a size filter. Fans who read the notes see nothing new, even when there is.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Mobile App Product Manager

    First action

    Replace the next release note with a specific changelog.

    How to measure it

    Monthly active app buyers

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Find slow pages

      App performance by screen.

      Mobile App Product Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Fix blank text

      Font and content loading on slow connections.

      Mobile App Product Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Ship the size filter

      Uses the saved size from the fit finder.

      Mobile App Product Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Write real notes

      Specific changes in every release.

      Mobile App Product Manager each release

    5. 5

      Ask at the right time

      Rating prompt after a delivered order.

      CRM Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Reply to reviews

      Answer feature requests in the store.

      Customer Experience Manager weekly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time
    Owner
    Mobile App Product Manager

    Smallest test

    Rewrite the next release note and compare update-day opens.

    Why it works

    Write each release note as a short, specific changelog ("Size filter on every collection", "Rewards balance on the home screen") and use the update to prompt a rating from active buyers after a successful order. Fix the slow and blank-text pages first and say so in the notes.

    Specific notes give lapsed users a reason to reopen the app and show reviewers their requests were heard.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Promising features that slip

      Only describe what has shipped.

    Evidence

    • App StoreShop New Era for iPhone: 4.9 stars from about 22,000 ratings; version 7.6, updated October 16, 2026, and recent version notes repeat the same three lines (accounts, faster checkout, order tracking). Reviews mention pages that "load super slow or load and there is no text", purchases not earning rewards, a 20% coupon that disappeared from checkout, and a request for a size filter. The site also links an Android app on Google Play.Source
  • 22

    The homepage description calls neweracap.com the online hat store "for all MLB, NBA, NFL & NHL teams", yet New Era holds over 500 licences and its top sellers include entertainment caps such as Batman and The Jetsons. Fans of films, cartoons and brands search for those caps without ever typing a league name.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 months SEO Manager

    First action

    List the top 20 non-sports licences by revenue and check whether each has an indexed collection page.

    How to measure it

    Non-sports organic sessions

    Now
    –
    Target
    +40%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      List licences

      Top 20 non-sports by revenue.

      SEO Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Check demand

      Search volume per licence plus "hat" or "cap".

      SEO Manager 3 days

    3. 3

      Build pages

      Title, description and intro per licence.

      Content Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Add to menu

      A "Collabs & entertainment" menu group.

      E-commerce Merchandising Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      Update the homepage description

      Mention entertainment and style, not only leagues.

      SEO Manager 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      Rank and sessions per licence.

      SEO Manager monthly

    First result
    2 months
    Cost
    Content time
    Owner
    SEO Manager

    Smallest test

    Build and optimise one entertainment collection page and track it for a month.

    Why it works

    Build collection pages per major entertainment and lifestyle licence with their own titles, descriptions and short intros, link them from the menu, and widen the homepage description beyond the four leagues. Track which licences already rank and which have demand but no page.

    Non-sports fans are a new audience with less retailer competition in search, and they shop all year rather than around a season.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Licensor rules on naming and imagery

      Use approved copy and assets from each licence's style guide.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage title "New Era | New Era Hats & Apparel – New Era Cap"; meta description: "New Era is your online hat store for all MLB, NBA, NFL & NHL teams. Shop Fitted, Snapback, Knit & Adjustable Hats, today." The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email, Postscript SMS, Gorgias support chat, Yotpo reviews and a Rakuten affiliate programme, ships within the US only, and its top sellers include entertainment licences such as Batman and The Jetsons.Source
    • WikipediaNew Era Cap Company: founded in Buffalo in 1920; "over 500 different licenses"; exclusive MLB on-field cap since 1993, NFL sideline rights from 2012, NBA authentic headwear since 2016, official NHL hat from July 2024 and UFL partner from February 2026; the 59FIFTY fitted dates to 1954.Source
  • 23

    A fitted cap is a classic gift for a sports fan, but the size guide asks for a head measurement the gift-giver cannot take, and reviewers report caps that ran small. Gift buyers either guess, pick a snapback instead, or buy elsewhere.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in Next gifting season CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Measure gift-order share and size returns on fitted caps in last year's holiday season.

    How to measure it

    Gift fitted orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +25% year on year
    By
    next holiday season

    Steps

    1. 1

      Size the gift market

      Gift orders and size returns last season.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Design the flow

      Buyer pays, recipient confirms size.

      UX Designer 1 week

    3. 3

      Build it

      Gift option on fitted product pages.

      Shopify Developer 3 weeks

    4. 4

      Write the messages

      Branded gift email and SMS to the recipient.

      CRM Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Hold stock

      Reserve stock until the size is chosen, with a deadline.

      Manager, Logistics (North America) 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Gift orders, recipient sign-ups and returns.

      E-commerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    Next gifting season
    Cost
    Build time
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Offer a "size-free" digital gift card for fitted caps with the fit finder link.

    Why it works

    Add a "Gift it, they pick the size" option on fitted products: the buyer pays for the cap, the recipient gets a branded message with a link to confirm their size (using the fit finder), and the cap ships then. Pair it with free size exchange for gifts and a digital gift card fallback.

    It removes the biggest barrier to gifting the brand's signature product and brings the recipient into the store and rewards programme.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Recipients never confirm

      Reminder after 3 days, then convert to a gift card.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteSizing (as indexed in search): New Era's size guide tells shoppers to measure around the head "about 1 inch above your eyebrows" and convert the measurement to a fitted size with the chart at /pages/sizing-chart; the store also loads a third-party size-chart widget.Source
    • ReviewsTrustpilot: TrustScore 1.2 from 374 reviews, 87% one-star; Trustpilot notes New Era has not invited customers to review. Recurring complaints: automated support replies, slow, lost or misdelivered orders, slow refunds, caps that ran smaller than the stated size, crooked logos and hats crushed in transit.Source
Website review of neweracap.com More example playbooks and reviews

More growth playbooks

Other companies we have researched, each read from what they are hiring for.

  • Collectively growth strategyAn award-winning influencer and creator marketing agency: strategy, creative, creator casting, production, affiliate and paid creator…22 growth ideas
  • Neo4j growth strategyThe graph intelligence platform: graph database (AuraDB cloud and self-managed), graph analytics and data science, GraphRAG and AI…21 growth ideas
  • ContactMonkey growth strategyInternal communications software for Outlook and Gmail: communicators design, check, send and measure employee emails and newsletters…21 growth ideas
  • Avalere Health growth strategyA global strategic partner for the healthcare industry: Advisory (policy, market access, evidence and value), Medical (medical…21 growth ideas
  • Primitive growth strategyEmail infrastructure for AI agents: managed *.primitive.email addresses, a one-call send-and-wait-for-reply verb (primitive chat), hosted…23 growth ideas
  • Parry Soap Co growth strategyHand-made colostrum and Manuka honey soaps, moisturising balms and, since April 2026, roll-on and bottled fragrances, made on a family…21 growth ideas
  • Gratwick growth strategyAn independent studio and creator platform: productions surrounded by live interactive shows, audience casting, trivia, podcasts, a…21 growth ideas
  • Vervaunt growth strategyA London and New York eCommerce consultancy and performance marketing agency for luxury and premium brands: replatforming and platform…23 growth ideas

See every playbook and website review

Independent research. Programmable wrote this playbook from public sources, as they stood on November 9, 2026, and cites them throughout. New Era Cap did not commission, review or endorse it, and Programmable is not affiliated with New Era Cap. Company and product names are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. The ideas are suggestions and opinion, not professional, legal or financial advice, and not statements about how New Era Cap runs its business.

Something wrong, or do you represent New Era Cap? Email [email protected] and we will correct it or take it down.

30/60/90 roadmap

What to focus on in each month, and the ideas that carry it.

  1. Days 1 to 306 ideas

    Shipping threshold test, delivery dates, the stale $75 help pages, the homepage layout shift, post-delivery review invitations and the add-on shelf.

  2. Days 31 to 6013 ideas

    Late-order messages, fit finder and free size exchange, rewards that credit reliably, tier drops in the app, tag clean-up, flagship links, the team path, 'only at New Era' exclusives, 59FIFTY Day, league-moment pages, app release notes and non-sports licence search.

  3. Days 61 to 904 ideas

    Commit to the big bets: online patch-and-pin customization, demand signals for the planners and the annual fit report; launch gifting without a size.

The research behind the plan

3 research areas, each summarised in a few lines. Open any of them for the full detail.

Customers

What customers say

Customers value the authentic on-field cap of their team. The most cited problem: paying for shipping and waiting up to three weeks for one cap.

  • A wide choice of teams, collections and styles in one place
  • Fitted caps that arrive the wrong size
  • In their words: “fitted”

Market

Competitive landscape

5 competitors compared: Lids, Mitchell & Ness, Fanatics, Nike and 1 more.

  • Gap to exploit: Getting fitted sizes right online without trying caps on
  • Lids: Sells every brand, so no exclusives of its own make
  • Mitchell & Ness: Free shipping only from $150

Hiring signals

New Era's 24 open roles are mostly operational, and they point at the same problems customers report.

  • Global Demand Planner: Planning across hundreds of team, style and size combinations. Idea 19.
  • Manager, Logistics (North America): Delivery reliability, alongside a Sr. Coordinator, Logistics and a Freight Auditor. Ideas 2, 7.
  • Embroidery Machine Operator (Opa-Locka, FL): Decoration capacity with DTG and print operators. Idea 18.

From the team that wrote this playbook

All products
  • ProgrammableAgencyWorking AI systems in days, not quarters (opens programmable.agency in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableInfoAn agent that finds, researches and asks firstNew accounts get 100,000 free enrichment credits with code BETA100K (opens programmable.info in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableDigitalScreenshots in, an animated product demo out (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableWatchKnow the day a supplier falls out of compliance (opens programmable.watch in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableTalkGet registrants for your events, and know who’s coming (opens programmable.talk in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableMediaAn AI note taker, interpreter and webinar host for your calls (opens programmable.media in a new tab)
  • ProgrammablePageText what you need, your customer gets a page that works (opens programmable.page in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableCommunityForums with labelled AI members, never empty (opens programmable.community in a new tab)
ProgrammableMarketing
ExamplesLeaderboardsProductsTermsPrivacyCookiesDPALegalContact

© 2026 AI-Powered Growth Intelligence