The new Paid Social Media Manager will own organic, paid and influencer social for Policygenius and make sure messaging meets regulatory requirements. But every time someone shares policygenius.com, the preview text says "rated 4.8 out of 5 with over 3,950 reviews", while the homepage shows Trustpilot 4.7 from 5,775+ and Google 4.6 from 1,200+, and the reviews page description says "4.6 on Trustpilot". Four different claims on one brand's own pages make every ad and creator script slower to approve, and the old preview undersells the 5,775 reviews.
First action
Share policygenius.com in a test post and note the preview text.
How to measure it
Rating claims matching the source
- Now
- –
- Target
- 100%
- By
- 30 days
Steps
List claims
Every rating mention in pages, meta tags, ads and scripts.
Paid Social Media Manager 1 day
Pick the source
Platform, score, count and date for each.
Legal and Compliance 2 days
Fix meta tags
Homepage and reviews page descriptions.
Policygenius content lead 1 day
Automate
Weekly update from the review platforms.
Web engineer 1 week
Approved lines
One rating line per platform for ads and creators.
Legal and Compliance 2 days
Refresh previews
Re-scrape link previews on social platforms.
Paid Social Media Manager 1 hour
Audit monthly
Check pages and live ads.
Paid Social Media Manager monthly
Why it works
Keep one source of truth for ratings (platform, score, count, date), fed by the review platforms' own widgets or a weekly update. Rewrite the homepage and reviews page descriptions from it, and give paid social, influencers and the sales team the same approved line ("4.7 on Trustpilot from 5,775+ reviews, as of <date>").
Consistent, current proof is faster for legal to approve, stronger in ads (5,775 beats 3,950) and safer in a regulated category.
Ready to use
ChecklistRating claim audit
[ ] Homepage meta and og:description [ ] Reviews page description [ ] Homepage Trustpilot and Google blocks [ ] Live paid social ads [ ] Creator and influencer scripts [ ] Sales call scripts [ ] Each claim names platform, score, count and date
Risks and how to handle them
Ratings change
Always show the date and update weekly.
Different platforms, different scores
Name the platform with every number.
Evidence
- Your websitePolicygenius rating claims disagree across its own pages (checked October 21, 2026): the homepage meta and og:description, which search results and social link previews show, say "We're rated 4.8 out of 5 with over 3,950 reviews"; the homepage body shows Trustpilot 4.7 from 5,775+ reviews and Google 4.6 from 1,200+; the reviews page description says "rate Policygenius 4.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot", while its body shows a Trustpilot TrustScore of 4.7 from 5,775 reviews, Google "4.8 out of 5" and Consumers Advocate "4.6 out of 5".Source
- Your websitePolicygenius homepage: "30M+ people served", "$290B+ life insurance coverage in-force", "320k+ life insurance policies placed", "363 days a year of human support"; a Trustpilot block "4.7 out of 5 stars, 5,775+ reviews" and a Google block "4.6 out of 5 stars, 1,200+ reviews"; a refer-a-friend program paying a "$100 Amazon Gift Card for each friend who shops for insurance – up to $300 per calendar year", "not available in all states".Source
- HiringPaid Social Media Manager (Alpharetta or New York, posted October 13, 2026): will "take full ownership of Policygenius' social media presence across organic, paid, and influencer marketing channels"; "Conduct creative A/B tests and incrementality testing"; "Identify, recruit, negotiate, and manage influencer relationships"; measure "leads, customer acquisition, and ROAS"; "Ensure messaging aligns with broader marketing initiatives and regulatory requirements"; bonus for "scaling an influencer marketing program from the ground-up" and "legal/compliance creative and copy review".Source