Babylist is hiring a Staff PM to make Wishlist "the next chapter" that keeps families beyond the newborn phase, and the homepage headline already says "The baby registry that grows with your family". Yet the homepage never says wishlist, birthday or holiday, the menu and footer link to Money and Early Investor but not to Wishlist, and the Wishlist landing page is in none of the eight sitemaps. About 60,000 wishlists were created by people who found the feature on their own; the product is being discovered by accident.
First action
Add /page/wishlist to the pages sitemap and a Wishlist link to the Registry menu.
How to measure it
Wishlists created per week
- Now
- –
- Target
- 2x the current rate
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Baseline
Wishlists created per week and where each started.
Senior Manager, Data Analytics 2 days
Menu and footer
Wishlist under Registry, next to "Find a Babylist".
Staff Product Manager, Wishlist 2 days
Sitemap and share image
Add the page and an og:image built for group chats.
SEO lead 1 day
Homepage module
Birthday and holiday Wishlist block for returning parents.
Staff Product Designer (AI Builder) 1 week
Wishlist-first sign-up
Landing page button opens Wishlist creation, not the registry flow.
Staff Product Manager, Wishlist 1 week
Prompt existing families
Email and app message to registrants with babies 9-36 months old.
Lifecycle marketing lead 1 week
Read the numbers
Creation and first-gift rates by entry point.
Senior Manager, Data Analytics weekly
Why it works
Give Wishlist the same placement as Money: a homepage module ("Their first birthday is coming: start a Wishlist"), a Registry menu item, a footer link, and /page/wishlist in the pages sitemap with its own share image. Make every sign-up from the Wishlist page land in Wishlist creation rather than the registry flow, and send existing registrants whose baby is 9 to 36 months old an email and app prompt.
Families who already trust the registry are the cheapest Wishlist users to win, and every visible entry point turns the headline promise into a product. It gives the new PM a clean baseline: traffic and sign-ups by entry point from week one.
Ready to use
ChecklistWishlist visibility list
[ ] /page/wishlist in pages sitemap [ ] og:image and description for link previews [ ] Registry menu item and footer link [ ] Homepage module for parents past their due date [ ] Landing button opens Wishlist creation [ ] Email + app prompt at 9, 12, 24 and 36 months [ ] Creation and first-gift tracking by entry point
Risks and how to handle them
Registry sign-ups dip on the homepage
Show the Wishlist module only to logged-in parents past their due date at first.
Wishlists with no gifts
Track gifts per Wishlist, not only creations.
Evidence
- HiringStaff Product Manager, Wishlist (open now): "Wishlist is the next chapter — a product that keeps families connected to Babylist well beyond the newborn phase, giving parents of young children a simple, intelligent way to guide gift-giving for birthdays, holidays, and everything in between." It sits in "Babylist's consumer growth and LTV organization"; the PM should "build engagement and growth loops" around "the push/pull triggers that bring users back around moments that matter". Babylist "serves nearly a million expectant parents every year".Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked October 21, 2026): H1 "The baby registry that grows with your family"; sections for the registry, the Shop, guides, Babylist Health ("Order your free breast pump through insurance") and Babylist Money. The words "wishlist", "birthday" and "holiday" do not appear anywhere on the homepage, and the top menu (Registry, Shop, Guides, Money, Health) and footer have no Wishlist link, while Money and "Early Investor Funds" appear in both.Source
- Your websiteWishlist landing page at /page/wishlist: "Make their wishlist come true", "Create a wishlist to gather gift ideas for birthdays, holidays or just because", items from "Amazon, Target, Etsy, or a local store", sizes and requests such as "no glitter, please", price-drop alerts and an education fund. The page's header Sign Up link goes to the registry flow (/registry/new/choose?refer_location=Wishlist+Landing). The page is in none of the site's eight sitemaps (the pages sitemap lists 19 URLs).Source
- Babylist help center and pressBabylist's help center says a Babylist baby registry is required before a Birthday or Holiday Wishlist can be created, and that Wishlists are not eligible for the 15% registry discount. Modern Retail reported that the Wishlist soft-launched in 2023 and that about 60,000 wishlists had been created by users who found the feature on their own.Source