The refill is the business: a $22 handle that needs a new head every month. But the refill page tells shoppers three different things. Its description and search snippet say "Subscribe for $10 a month", the subscription box on the same page says "$8 refills every month including shipping", and a one-off pack is $12.99. The product pages say one pack lasts a month while the FAQ says a head lasts "2-3 weeks". And the White refill is out of stock while the White handle is still on sale, so a new White customer cannot start a subscription in their color.
First action
Correct the $10 line in the refill description today so it matches the subscription box.
How to measure it
Subscription attach rate on first orders
- Now
- –
- Target
- +30%
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Decide the offer
One subscription price, one interval, what is included.
Co-founder, Marketing and Sales 1 day
Fix the copy
Refill description, Gumline Cleaner page, FAQ and meta descriptions.
Co-founder, Marketing and Sales 2 hours
Check the app
Make sure the Appstle plan charges exactly what the copy says.
Shopify Developer (contract) 1 hour
Solve White stock
Reorder White heads, or offer Black heads to White handle buyers.
Co-founder, Marketing and Sales 1 week
Add a waitlist
Back-in-stock email on the White refill until it returns.
Shopify Developer (contract) 2 hours
Update emails
Klaviyo welcome and reminder flows with the same price and interval.
Marketing Coordinator 2 hours
Measure
Attach rate and subscriber churn before and after.
Co-founder, Marketing and Sales monthly
Why it works
Pick the real subscription price and use it everywhere: refill description, Gumline Cleaner page, FAQ, Klaviyo emails and the search snippet. Pick one replacement interval (and, if heads really last 2-3 weeks, offer a 3-week plan rather than understating it). Restock White refills, or let White handle buyers choose Black heads with a note that they fit, and add a back-in-stock signup until then. Show the saving plainly: "$12.99 one-off, $8 a month on subscription, cancel anytime."
A shopper who sees $10 in Google and $8 on the page wonders which one checkout will charge, and one who reads "2-3 weeks" in the FAQ wonders whether the plan will leave them short. One clear offer removes both doubts at the moment they decide whether to subscribe, and every subscription turns a $22 order into a year of revenue.
Ready to use
ChecklistOne refill offer, everywhere
[ ] Refill description: one price [ ] Refill search snippet (meta description) [ ] Gumline Cleaner page subscription line [ ] FAQ: one replacement interval [ ] Appstle plan price matches the copy [ ] White refill restocked or Black-head option shown [ ] Back-in-stock signup on White refill [ ] Klaviyo flows updated
Risks and how to handle them
Lower price cuts margin
Model the yearly value of a subscriber at $8 against one-off buyers at $12.99 before choosing.
Heads wear out faster than the plan ships
Offer a 3-week interval option instead of promising a month.
Evidence
- Your websiteRefills page: $12.99 a pack, 4.9 stars from 18 reviews. The description (also the page's search snippet) says "Subscribe for $10 a month and never run out", while the subscription box on the same page says "$8 refills every month including shipping". The White / Large refill is out of stock; Black / Large is in stock, and the White handle is still sold.Source
- Your websiteGumline Cleaner page: $22 in White or Black, "Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars", 54 reviews; "Snap in a fresh head cartridge from a refill pack once a month. One pack = one month."; the subscription box offers "Monthly Refill Subscription $8 refills every month including shipping, Cancel anytime".Source
- Your websiteFAQ: "The Gumline Cleaner head cartridges should each last up to 2-3 weeks when used twice a day" (the product pages say one pack lasts a month); "gum disease affects approximately half of Americans over the age of 30"; how-to: hold it like a pencil, trace an "m" along the top gumline and a "u" along the bottom; it still calls the product a "Starter Set"; returns of unused orders are for "bäz credit".Source
- Your catalogueProduct feed (read October 20, 2026): six products. Gumline Cleaner $22, Couples Set (2 Gumline Cleaners) $35, Refills $12.99, Gift Card $10-$100, Route shipping protection, and "Extra Strength Dental Product Cleaning Tablets" at $19.99 for "toothbrushes, retainers, mouth guards / night guards, whitening trays, aligner trays, &/or dentures", which lives at the URL /products/mystery-product.Source