Pilgrim sells its best products as many separate listings, and the reviews are split with them. The Australian Tea Tree anti-dandruff shampoo is six products in the sitemap (standard, 400 ml, 650 ml, Cool Menthol, Cool Menthol 400 ml and a combo): its main pages show 781 verified reviews, but the standard 200 ml listing shows 24, Cool Menthol 21, the combo 15 and Cool Menthol 400 ml just 2. The hair growth serum's main page shows 4.7 from 7,645 reviews, while a "concern-specific" listing of the same serum shows 23. A shopper who lands from an ad or a search on a thin listing sees what looks like a new, unproven product, not the brand's most-reviewed one, and search engines split ranking signals across near-identical pages.
First action
Export every product with its review count and group the listings that share a formula.
How to measure it
Product-page conversion, merged lines
- Now
- –
- Target
- +10%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Map duplicates
Group product URLs by formula, with sizes, scents, packs, review counts and ad links for each.
Shopify Lead Developer 2 days
Choose the main page
For each line keep the URL with the most reviews and links.
Head of D2C 1 day
Build variants
Size and scent variants on the main product, with price per 100 ml in the picker.
Shopify Lead Developer 1 week
Pool reviews
Judge.me Product Groups so every version of the same formula shows the combined count.
Shopify Lead Developer 1 day
Update links first
Point ads, emails, influencer links and internal links at the main page before redirecting.
Performance Marketing Manager 2 days
Redirect
301 each old URL to its matching variant; give off-sitemap versions (concern-specific, for men) the same treatment.
SEO Manager 2 days
Measure
Conversion, add-to-cart and organic clicks for merged lines against the previous 30 days.
Data Analyst, D2C 4 weeks
Why it works
For each hero line, keep one product page and make size, scent and pack into variants (200, 400 and 650 ml; regular and Cool Menthol). Redirect the old URLs (301) to the matching variant, and use Judge.me Product Groups so every version shows the combined review count. Show price per 100 ml in the size picker and preselect the size the shopper came for. Start with the Tea Tree shampoo and the hair growth serum, then the Patuá keratin, Spanish Rosemary, Korean Rice Water, Redensyl and argan shampoos and the Korean Rice Water Hydra Glow moisturiser. Merge only listings with an identical formula; keep different formulas (such as the dandruff-prone-scalp serum) as separate products with their own reviews, linked from the main page.
Review volume is one of the strongest signals on a beauty product page, and Pilgrim already has it; it is just spread out. One URL per product also gathers links and rankings in one place, lets ads land on the best-proven page, and makes the catalogue easier for search engines and shopping agents to read.
Ready to use
ChecklistListing merge checklist
[ ] One row per product URL: formula, size, scent, pack, reviews, ad links [ ] Main URL chosen for each formula [ ] Size and scent variants built, price per 100 ml shown [ ] Judge.me Product Group per formula [ ] Ads, emails and creator links updated [ ] 301 from every old URL to its variant [ ] Off-sitemap duplicates merged or redirected [ ] Before/after conversion report
Risks and how to handle them
Redirected pages lose ranking for a few weeks
Redirect to the exact variant and keep page titles close to the old ones.
Live ads or creator links break
Update final URLs before the redirects go live.
Pooling reviews across different formulas misleads shoppers
Pool only identical formulas; keep other versions separate.
Evidence
- Your websiteProduct sitemap (167 product URLs, read November 3, 2026): the Australian Tea Tree anti-dandruff shampoo is six separate products (standard, 400 ml, 650 ml, Cool Menthol, Cool Menthol 400 ml and a shampoo-conditioner combo); the Redensyl + Anagain hair growth serum has five product URLs (including 50 ml, 100 ml, dandruff-prone-scalp and roll-on versions); the Korean Rice Water Hydra Glow moisturiser has three; the Patuá keratin, Spanish Rosemary, Korean Rice Water, Redensyl and argan shampoos each have a separate 400 ml listing.Source
- Search resultsPilgrim's own product pages as indexed in search (November 3, 2026): the Tea Tree anti-dandruff shampoo's main and 400 ml pages show "781 Verified Reviews", while the standard 200 ml listing shows 24, Cool Menthol 21, Cool Menthol 400 ml 2 and the combo 15, and a separate "for men" listing sits outside the sitemap. The main hair growth serum page shows 4.7 from 7,645 verified reviews; a "concern-specific" listing of the same serum shows 23. One indexed product link carries an ad click tag (gad_source), so paid traffic lands on product pages.Source
- Vendor docsJudge.me help centre: Product Groups (Awesome plan) share reviews across related products such as variants, and carry existing reviews over when separate listings are merged into one product.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (read November 3, 2026): navigation for Bestsellers, Skin Care, Hair Care, Makeup, Combos and Salon Professional, plus a Store Locator; several offers at once: buy-one-get-one, "Buy 2 Pay For 1", Buy 2 Get 2 and Buy 3 Get 3, a Makeup Fest with 30% off plus BOGO, a free vanity bag above ₹699, and vote or share mechanics that promise a lower price; product ratings of 4.4-4.9 from about 12 to 7,700 reviews; claims such as "Glowing, Brighter Skin in 5 Days*", "New Hair Growth in 28 Days" and dandruff "UP TO 100% REDUCTION"; no loyalty programme or app link visible.Source