The new Retention & Loyalty lead is hired to revamp subscription and loyalty "as integrated levers". Today they barely touch: Rewards gives 15 points for the first subscription renewal and nothing for the next ones, which at 100 points per $5 is worth about 75 cents. Both programmes also promise the same perk, early access to new products and limited editions, so a subscriber gets nothing extra from Rewards and a Rewards member has no reason to subscribe.
First action
Model the cost of 50 points per renewal against current churn.
How to measure it
Subscribers active after 4 shipments
- Now
- –
- Target
- +10%
- By
- 2 quarters
Steps
Map today
Where subscription and Rewards overlap and conflict.
Associate Director, Retention & Loyalty 1 week
Model
Points per renewal, tier rules and cost.
Associate Director, Retention & Loyalty 1 week
Decide perks
Early access as the subscriber benefit; drop window.
Associate Director, Retention & Loyalty 1 week
Build
Rules in the loyalty and subscription platforms.
Digital Product team 1 month
Show it
Points and tier in the portal, emails and SMS.
Lifecycle marketing team 2 weeks
Test
Half of new subscribers for one quarter.
Associate Director, Retention & Loyalty 1 quarter
Read
Retention, LTV and margin against control.
Associate Director, Retention & Loyalty monthly
Why it works
Design one membership. Each renewal earns points (for example 50), subscribers enter at the Legend tier and move to Champion after a set number of renewals, and early access to drops becomes the subscriber-only perk with a 48-hour window. Show points and next tier in the subscription portal and in every renewal email and SMS. Test it against the current set-up on a share of new subscribers.
Subscribers are the most valuable customers, and rewards that grow with each renewal give a reason to stay through the third and fourth shipment, where most cancellations happen. One clear promise also simplifies the homepage and product pages.
Ready to use
ChecklistOne-membership launch list
[ ] Points on every renewal, not only the first [ ] Subscribers enter at Legend tier [ ] Early access window for subscribers only [ ] Points and next tier in portal and renewal emails [ ] 50/50 test on new subscribers [ ] Monthly read: retention, LTV, margin
Risks and how to handle them
Points cost erodes margin
Cap points per renewal and fund them from lower churn.
Existing Legends feel downgraded
Keep current tiers for one-time buyers and add, not remove.
Evidence
- Your websiteRewards page: 30 points to join, 1 point per $1, 15 points for the "First subscription renewal" (and nothing for later renewals), 30 and 60 points for 3 and 4 purchases; 100 points = "$5 off orders $15+"; VIP tiers Squatch Man ($20 spend), Squatch Legend ($75, adds "Early access to new products") and Squatch Champion ($150, 2 points per $1).Source
- Your websiteSubscription offer: "Subscribe & Save", "Ships Every 3 Months", free delivery and "subscriber-only benefits. Enjoy early access to new products and limited edition releases!"; custom bundles save 14-15% on subscription (Bar Soap 6-Pack $36 vs $42). Product pages repeat "First dibs on new products" and say some individual limited-edition soaps are "available to subscribers only" as add-ons.Source
- HiringAssociate Director, Retention & Loyalty (posted August 12, 2026, updated October 2): owns "subscription, loyalty, and lifecycle marketing as integrated levers to drive retention, LTV, and long-term revenue"; will "Lead the ongoing revamp of our subscription and loyalty programs — defining the experience, value proposition, and roadmap"; oversees lifecycle "across email, SMS, and direct mail"; owns "the retention P&L"; team of five; platforms "Klaviyo, Postscript, Recharge, Postpilot".Source
- Your websiteLimited Editions collection tabs: One Piece, Parks Project, PBR, Tajín, Sonic, FIFA, Toy Story 5, Friday Beers, Dragon Ball Z, The Terminator, Harry Potter. On the homepage the custom bundles carry a "Subscribe, Save 14-15%, Shipped every 3 months" option, while the limited-edition bundles (Pirates' Treasure Trove $71.25, Parks Project 4-Pack, Mango Tango 3-Pack, Triple Threat Set) show none.Source