Every page promises "Free US Shipping on Orders Over $150". The catalogue has 22 products, the dearest is $39.95 and the median is $24.95. Six bottles at the median price total $149.70, thirty cents short, so a shopper needs seven typical bottles, or four of the most expensive product, to qualify. For almost every one-time order the promise at the top of the site is a reminder that postage is coming. The nearest benchmark, Global Healing, sets its bar at $100 with higher-priced products.
First action
Export 90 days of one-time orders and chart how many fall in each $10 band up to $150.
How to measure it
Average order value on one-time orders
- Now
- –
- Target
- +15% with profit per visitor flat or up
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Chart the baskets
Count one-time orders by $10 band and by number of bottles for the last 90 days. Note what share ever reached $150.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Cost the postage
Work out the real USPS cost for one, two, three and four bottle parcels, and the margin on each basket size.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Pick the test bar
Choose a threshold about 30% above the typical order, where the margin on the extra bottle covers the postage. Three typical bottles is $74.85.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Add the progress line
Show the amount left in the cart and offer gap-fillers from $4.99 to $19.95 using the existing upsell tool.
E-commerce Manager 2 days
Update every mention
Change the site-wide bar, shipping policy, emails and the press boilerplate so the number matches everywhere.
Creative Director 1 day
Run the split
Half of visitors see the new bar, half see $150, for four weeks. Keep sale weeks out of the comparison.
E-commerce Manager 4 weeks
Decide on profit
Compare order value, conversion and postage paid. Keep the bar that earns more per visitor and retest one step lower or higher.
E-commerce Manager 2 days
Why it works
Treat the threshold as a tool for lifting basket size, which only works when the next step is within reach. Pull the last 90 days of one-time orders and find the value where most orders sit (likely one or two bottles). Set the bar about 30% above the typical order, for example $65 to $75, which is three typical bottles. Show a progress line in the cart ("$12 away from free shipping") with one-click add-ons priced to close the gap: Lion's Mane, Turkey Tail and DMSO at $19.95, Hydrogen Peroxide at $9.95 and the Gua Sha tool at $4.99. Run it as a four-week test against the $150 bar and judge it on profit per visitor after postage, not conversion alone.
Shoppers add items to reach a free-shipping bar only when it is one item away. A bar that needs seven bottles changes nobody's basket, while one that needs a third bottle does. The low-priced items already in the range are natural gap-fillers, and the store already runs a cart upsell tool that can show the progress line.
Ready to use
ChecklistFree-shipping bar test
[ ] 90-day chart of one-time orders by $10 band [ ] Postage cost for 1, 2, 3 and 4 bottle parcels [ ] Test bar chosen (about 30% above the typical order) [ ] Cart progress line with gap-fillers at $4.99, $9.95 and $19.95 [ ] Site bar, shipping policy and emails show the same number [ ] 50/50 split for four weeks, outside sale weeks [ ] Decision on profit per visitor after postage
Risks and how to handle them
Postage on light orders eats the margin
Set the bar where the extra bottle's margin covers the parcel, and judge the test on profit per visitor.
Sale periods distort the result
Run the split outside sitewide discounts, or compare like with like inside the sale.
Wholesale buyers expect the same offer
Keep the current wording that the offer is for retail orders only.
Evidence
- Your websiteShipping policy: "Enjoy free shipping on retail orders over $150 shipped within the contiguous U.S."; no standard rate is listed for orders under $150; orders placed before 12 p.m. CST ship the same day by USPS; free US shipping also applies to Subscribe and Save on eight named products (15 Day Gut Cleanse, both Methylene Blue products, Lugol's Iodine, Vitamin B12, Liquid Chlorophyll, Lymphatic Detox and Magnesium Glycinate); international orders ship by USPS with duties paid by the customer.Source
- Company researchCatalogue scan (November 16, 2026): 22 products priced from $4.99 to $39.95 with a median of $24.95. The top price is $39.95 (Ultimate Methylene Blue liquid and capsules, Liquid Multivitamin); 15 Day Gut Cleanse, Lymphatic Detox and D-Ribose are $29.95; Wormwood, Black Walnut and Cloves, Beet Root, Inositol and Calcium D-Glucarate are $24.95; Turkey Tail, Lion's Mane and DMSO are $19.95; Hydrogen Peroxide is $9.95 and the Gua Sha tool $4.99. Six bottles at the median price total $149.70 and four at the top price total $159.80.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 16, 2026): the site-wide bar reads "Free US Shipping on Orders Over $150"; claims include over 100,000 customers served, 10+ years in business and "hundreds of 5 Star Reviews"; badges for Organic, Vegan-Friendly, Gluten-Free, Non-GMO, Made in USA and cGMP; three customer testimonials link to Liquid Chlorophyll, Magnesium Glycinate and Lugol's Iodine; the footer lists an Influencer Program, an Affiliate Program and a Wholesale Program, and the menus we read have no HSA/FSA link.Source
- Competitor researchOther supplement stores' homepages: Global Healing (whose affiliate network account hosts Earth Harmony's affiliate signup) says "Enjoy complimentary U.S. shipping on every order over $100", "Subscribe & Save 15%" and "Take a year to try any product", with "Over 50,000 5-Star Reviews" and a Bundles section; MaryRuth's says "Automatically save 10% on every delivery" and has a Bundle & Save collection; Troscriptions sells its methylene blue only through verified practitioner accounts.Source