The calculator opens on a $3,000 monthly budget, a $5,000 customer lifetime value and a 400% ROI, with a note that the budget is "an example, not H2 pricing". H2's managed outbound is $5,000-$8,000 a month. Put H2's own fee into the same example and the ROI falls to 200% at $5,000 and 87.5% at $8,000. The thing dragging it down is the $5,000 customer value: a published client's proposals run from $50,000 to $300,000. With a $50,000 customer value, the same model at $8,000 a month returns 1,775%. The tool's starting example argues for a cheaper vendor and a smaller customer than H2 actually serves.
First action
Change the starting budget to $5,000 and the starting customer value to $50,000, and check the result reads correctly.
How to measure it
Calculator-to-booking rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- 2x the current rate
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Agree the presets
Three fee presets from the pricing page and a customer value from published case studies.
Co-founder, Sales & Marketing 2 hours
Change the defaults
Budget $5,000, customer value $50,000, and reword the budget note to name H2's guide range.
Co-founder, Operations half a day
Unlock the rates
Reply, positive and meeting rates become inputs with conservative defaults.
Co-founder, Operations 1 day
Add payback and proof
Months to payback, a pricing link and the nearest case study under the result.
Co-founder, Operations 1 day
Carry numbers to the call
Pass the inputs into the booking form notes.
Co-founder, Operations half a day
Measure
Track preset clicks, edits and bookings from the page.
Co-founder, Sales & Marketing weekly
Why it works
Replace the single example with three presets that match the pricing page (managed outbound at $5,000 and $8,000, in-house partnership at $10,000) and a starting customer value in the range H2's case studies show. Make reply rate, positive share and meeting rate editable, with H2's default shown as a conservative figure. Add a payback line (months until the first deal covers the fee), a link to pricing and to the closest case study under the result, and a button that carries the visitor's numbers into the intro booking so the call starts from their forecast.
A buyer who models their own deal size at the real price sells themselves, and arrives on the call with the objection already answered. The current example makes a $5,000-$8,000 retainer look poor value for exactly the small-ticket buyer who should not hire an agency, while hiding how strong the case is for six-figure deals.
Ready to use
ChecklistCalculator presets (same model, 6,000 leads a month, 20% close, 3 months, 9 deals)
[ ] Today: $3,000 a month, $5,000 customer value -> $9,000 in, $45,000 out, 400% [ ] Same example at H2's $5,000 fee -> $15,000 in, $45,000 out, 200% [ ] Same example at H2's $8,000 fee -> $24,000 in, $45,000 out, 87.5% [ ] Preset A: $8,000 fee, $50,000 customer value -> $24,000 in, $450,000 out, 1,775% [ ] Conservative case: $8,000 fee, $50,000 value, 5% close -> 2.25 deals, $112,500 out, 369% [ ] Reply, positive and meeting rates editable [ ] Payback months shown [ ] Links to pricing and one case study under the result
Risks and how to handle them
Large ROI figures look like a promise
Keep the existing illustrative disclaimer and show the conservative case first.
Low-value buyers see a weak return
That is useful: point them to the $2,000 consultation instead.
Evidence
- Your websiteCold email ROI calculator (read November 18, 2026): starting values are 6,000 leads a month, a $3,000 monthly budget, $5,000 customer lifetime value, a 20% close rate and 3 months, giving $9,000 invested, 9 deals, $45,000 lifetime value and 400% ROI. The budget field says "The starting value is an example, not H2 pricing." Reply rate (2%), positive share (25%) and meeting rate (50%) are fixed and cannot be edited. A result cannot be saved, emailed or shared, and the body links to the CAC calculator and "Book an intro" but not to pricing or a case study.Source
- Your websitePricing page (USD): GTM consultation at $2,000 a month (four calls and Slack access); managed outbound at a guide range of "$5,000–$8,000" a month with data, software and mailboxes included; in-house GTM partnership at $7,000–$12,000; full growth partnership at $25,000–$50,000 covering positioning, website work, SEO, LinkedIn content, paid advertising and Reddit through specialist partners; system builds and workshops are quoted to scope. The page states no minimum term or guarantee and has no FAQ.Source
- Your websiteCIDT case study: a custom software consultancy whose new business came mostly from the founder's network; $2.7m pipeline, an estimated 20–30 additional proposals, and typical proposal values of $50,000 to $300,000; earlier outbound providers had missed meetings and communicated inconsistently. No timeframe is given.Source