The Sunny Afternoon puzzle by Patti Blau has the search title "Ordinary Habit - Poodle Society 1000 Piece Puzzle", so Google and link previews show the wrong puzzle, and someone searching for Sunny Afternoon or Patti Blau may not find it. The gift card is titled "Orinday Habit Digital Gift Card", heading into gift-card season. And 19 of your 44 puzzle titles leave out the piece count, which is the first thing puzzle shoppers filter on ("1000 piece puzzle", "100 piece mini puzzle").
First action
Correct the Sunny Afternoon and gift card titles in Shopify.
How to measure it
Product page clicks from Google
- Now
- –
- Target
- +20%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Fix the two errors
Sunny Afternoon and the gift card.
E-commerce Manager 15 minutes
Pick one pattern
Name, piece count, artist, brand.
E-commerce Manager 30 minutes
Export titles
All 57 products by CSV.
E-commerce Manager 30 minutes
Rewrite
Add piece counts and artists.
E-commerce Manager 2 hours
Import
Into the SEO title field.
E-commerce Manager 30 minutes
Recrawl
Submit the sitemap in Search Console.
E-commerce Manager 15 minutes
Measure
Clicks and impressions per product.
E-commerce Manager monthly
Why it works
Fix the two broken titles today, then give every product one consistent title: "[Name] [Pieces]-Piece Jigsaw Puzzle by [Artist] | Ordinary Habit" for puzzles, and plain names for cards, journals and gifts. Set them in each product's "Search engine listing" field (or in bulk by CSV), keep the visible headings as they are, and request a recrawl in Search Console.
Correct, specific titles are how a small catalogue gets found for "[artist] puzzle" and "1000 piece puzzle" searches, and the fix takes an afternoon.
Risks and how to handle them
Titles too long
Keep under 60 characters; drop the brand first if needed.
Evidence
- Your websiteProduct page titles (all 57 product pages checked October 20, 2026): the Sunny Afternoon puzzle by Patti Blau has the title tag "Ordinary Habit - Poodle Society 1000 Piece Puzzle", another product's name, although its heading says "Sunny Afternoon Puzzle"; the gift card's title is "Orinday Habit Digital Gift Card". Titles follow at least five patterns ("Ordinary Habit Puzzle - ...", "Ordinary Habit 100 Piece Puzzle - ...", "... – Ordinary Habit"), and 19 of 44 puzzle titles leave out the piece count (for example "Nap Time Puzzle – Ordinary Habit", "Enchanted Puzzle – Ordinary Habit").Source
- Your websiteCatalogue (products feed): 57 products; 100-piece puzzles at $20, 500-piece at $40, 1,000-piece at $48, bundles from $40 to $175, matching cards, a $99 Quotidian pillow and a tea towel. Sold out: both On the Go travel puzzles, all three versions of the For Now Journal, Disco Tea, Moonlight Potions and A Good Year. Newest: Wild Comfort (1,000) and Cake Angel (100) in March 2026, Christmas Eve (100) on August 31, 2026.Source
- Your websiteHomepage: "Our Latest Collection" (Wild Comfort $48 and Cake Angel $20, both rated 5.0), a Big and Little Bundle at $65 (was $68), "Pieces for the Senses" (soft-touch, glare-free pieces), "For Anytime, Anywhere", and footer links to Store Locator, Rewards Program, Wholesale and Corporate + Group Gifting.Source