A shopper looking at the $99.95 Santa blazer is told free shipping starts at $75 next to the add-to-cart button, at $99 in the Shipping & Returns tab a few lines down, and at $99 again in "Why shop with us"; the theme also carries a $100 version, and the shipping policy page names no threshold at all. In peak season, a shopper deciding whether to add a second item gets three different answers on one page.
First action
Search the theme and pages for "$75", "$99" and "$100" and list every place a threshold appears.
How to measure it
Average order value
- Now
- –
- Target
- +6%
- By
- 45 days
Steps
Decide the number
Confirm the threshold the checkout actually applies.
Head of E-commerce 1 hour
Find every mention
Theme files, tabs, cart, help, policy and email footers.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Make it one setting
Render the value from a single theme setting.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Update the policy
State the threshold and the lower-48 rule first.
Customer Experience Lead 1 hour
Add the gap message
Cart and product page show the amount left.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Pair an add-on
Rebuy suggests one item that closes the gap.
Merchandising Manager 1 day
Brief support
Chat macros use the same wording.
Customer Experience Lead 1 hour
Measure
Orders just above vs below the threshold.
Head of E-commerce weekly
Why it works
Pick the real threshold, put it in one theme setting, and render that value everywhere: the add-to-cart line, the Shipping & Returns tab, the "Why shop with us" block, the cart progress bar, the help page and a new first line on the shipping policy ("Free standard shipping on US orders over $X to the lower 48"). Then show the gap in the cart and on the product page ("$X away from free shipping") with one add-on suggestion from Rebuy in the right price band.
A clear, consistent threshold is one of the strongest levers on order value, and mixed numbers make shoppers doubt the rest of the promises (guaranteed delivery, no-stress returns). Matching couples and family bundles sit near the threshold, so a single honest number nudges a second item into the cart.
Ready to use
ChecklistFree-shipping message audit
[ ] Add-to-cart line [ ] Shipping & Returns tab [ ] "Why shop with us" block [ ] Theme fallback shipping tab [ ] Cart drawer headline and progress bar [ ] Shipping policy first line [ ] Help / FAQ answers [ ] Email and SMS footers [ ] Announcement bar [ ] Zendesk chat macros
Risks and how to handle them
Changing the number moves margin
Model shipping cost per order before choosing $75 or $99.
Hard-coded copy reappears
Add a check to the theme release list.
Evidence
- Your websiteMen's Furry Santa Blazer with Tie product page ($99.95, checked October 20, 2026): next to the add-to-cart button it says "Free Shipping on orders $75+"; the Shipping & Returns tab on the same page says "Free shipping on orders over $99"; the "Why shop with us" text says "orders of $99+ ship for free!"; the cart drawer headline reads "FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS $75+", and the theme's fallback shipping tab says "Free shipping on orders over $100 + Orders placed before 12 noon PST = SHIP SAME DAY!".Source
- Your websiteThe shipping policy page promises "a guaranteed delivery date" for every order to the 48 contiguous states, with Economy (7 day), Standard (5), Priority (3), Express (2) and Expedited (1 day) transit, and international delivery with an optional all-inclusive duties option, but it never states a free-shipping threshold. Free shipping is only for the lower 48 states.Source
- Store technologyThe store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email, Attentive and Postscript text messaging code, Rebuy, Yotpo reviews, Rivo loyalty (rewards, referrals, VIP tiers, membership gifts), Loop returns, Route, Afterpay ("Minimum order value of $35.00"), Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Venmo, Zendesk chat and an Awin affiliate program. It publishes an agents.md file and a Universal Commerce Protocol profile for AI shopping agents.Source
- Your product feedThe public product feed (October 20, 2026) lists 2,477 products and 12,949 variants, all under the Tipsy Elves brand; median price $49.95. 870 products (35%) have no size available, including 373 tagged Christmas, and 982 more are missing some sizes; 362 products have only one photo. Largest types: jumpsuits 461, sweaters 336, golf polos 179, pajamas 152, bundles 148, snow suits 109, ski suits 70, Hawaiian shirts 59.Source