Ultimate Cribbage is WildCard's flagship: 4.59 stars from 30,782 US ratings and 1M+ Play downloads. In the six weeks to November 2, all seven of its one- and two-star App Store reviews were about ads: "a commercial after every hand", "all of a sudden today ads started being shown between every hand", and ads that will not close. In the three months before that there was one low review. The writers are long-time players ("I was a long time loyal player") on a $9.99-a-month subscription they say they cannot afford. Every new install a growth team buys lands on a store page where the newest reviews say "download something else".
First action
Pull ad impressions per hand and 30-day retention for players before and after the October ad change.
How to measure it
30-day retention of 90+ day players
- Now
- –
- Target
- back to pre-change level
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Measure the change
Ads per hand, retention and reviews before and after October.
Data Analyst 2 days
Set three groups
Every hand, every second hand, every third hand for 90+ day players.
Monetization Lead 2 days
Fix unclosable ads
Block formats that cannot close within five seconds.
Monetization Lead 1 day
Run the test
Four weeks.
Monetization Lead 4 weeks
Compare
Ad revenue, retention, Club sales, low reviews.
Data Analyst 2 days
Ship and ask
Roll out the winner; prompt for reviews after wins.
Game Producer 1 week
Why it works
Split interstitial frequency by tenure and test it: players with 90+ days of play see an ad every third hand instead of every hand, and no ad that cannot be closed within five seconds. Run three groups for four weeks and compare ad revenue per user, sessions per day, 30-day retention, Club conversion and the share of low reviews. Ship the cap that keeps the most lifetime revenue, then ask happy long-time players for a review after a win.
For a game that older players open every day for decades, retention and rating carry more lifetime value than one extra ad per hand. A rating that slips also raises the cost of every install.
Ready to use
ChecklistAd load test plan
[ ] Baseline: ads per hand, D30 retention, low reviews (Aug vs Oct) [ ] Group A: current load [ ] Group B: every 2nd hand for 90+ day players [ ] Group C: every 3rd hand for 90+ day players [ ] Block ads that cannot close within 5 seconds [ ] Read: ad ARPDAU, sessions/day, D30, Club conversion, 1-2 star share [ ] Ship winner + review prompt after wins
Risks and how to handle them
Ad revenue drops
Judge on 90-day revenue per player, not daily ad revenue.
New players see more ads
Keep the cap tied to tenure so loyal players are protected first.
Evidence
- App Store reviewsThe 50 most recent US reviews of Ultimate Cribbage (September 27 to November 2, 2026): 42 are four or five stars; all 7 one- and two-star reviews complain about ads: "a commercial after every hand", "all of a sudden today ads started being shown between every hand", an ad that "forces you to interact with it before you can close it", and "Premium games are not in my budget". The previous 50 reviews (June 27 to September 27) had one low review. Five-star reviews mention playing for 40 years, memories of a father and grandfather, keeping "my mind active", and an 80-year-old player who wants slower crib counting.Source
- App StoreWildCard Games Inc on the US App Store: Ultimate Cribbage 4.59 stars from 30,782 ratings (updated October 26, 2026); Spades Fever 4.59 from 2,993 (October 28); Spades Pop 1,465; Spades For Seniors 1,038; Ultimate Hearts 4.73 from 801 (last updated March 2024); Classic Blackjack 773; Domino Fever 439 (October 22). WildCard Classics Inc publishes older titles: Backgammon (14,899 ratings), Spite & Malice (10,251 and 6,216), Cribbage Premium (8,444), Cribbage - Crib & Peg (7,869), Backgammon Premium (6,636), mostly last updated in 2023-2024.Source
- Google PlayGoogle Play: Ultimate Cribbage 1M+ downloads, 4.4 stars, 91.4K reviews; Spades Fever 1M+, 4.5 stars, 10.5K reviews; Classic Blackjack 21 100K+; Jigsolitaire 50K+ at 3.5 stars; Gin Rummy Pop 10K+.Source
- App Store listingUltimate Cribbage listing: Cribbage Club subscription at "$9.99" a month for no ads, Muggins and Shotgun modes, a 25% XP boost and faster challenges; English only; "Enjoy the classic card game that friends, family and grandpas have been enjoying for decades!"; a daily challenge with in-game rewards.Source
- Help centerWildCard's Zendesk help center has 137 articles, with repeated entries such as "There are too many ads! How do I get rid of them?", "I am unable to close an ad. What do I do?", "Can you stop showing the same ads?", "How can I report an inappropriate ad?" and "The scoring takes too long!".Source