ProgrammableMarketing/americangirl.com (opens in a new tab)
PDF

Views

  • Plan
  • Roadmap
  • Research

On this page

  • The brief
  • Start here
  • Idea portfolio
  • Effort vs impact
  • This week · 6
  • This quarter · 11
  • Big bets · 3
  • Wildcards · 2
  • How we can help
Generated Nov 9, 2026
  1. Programmable
  2. Playbooks
  3. American Girl
American Girl logo

growth playbook · Nov 9, 2026

americangirl.com (opens in a new tab)

American Girl growth playbook

Diagnosis

American Girl turned 40 in 2026 with a busy year: the Modern Era dolls, the first adult novel, KPop Demon Hunters dolls and Daisy Davenport, the 2027 Girl of the Year. The store is in good shape (real visitors load pages fast), and the company is hiring now, but only for its stores: 92 retail openings for salons, cafés, parties and seasonal staff.

The biggest quick gap is shipping. Standard delivery costs $19 on every order from $105.01 to $174.99 and nothing from $175, and a $135 doll lands right in the middle. This playbook starts with showing parents the net cost of reaching free shipping, one shipping table on every page, $175+ starter sets, faster taps, clearer Modern Era pages and Rewards value in the bag.

Next it ties the stores to the site (bookable parties, post-visit emails, experiences as gifts), links Girl of the Year to the historical line, and builds a path for grown-up fans. The big bets are a paid free-shipping membership, classroom history kits and smaller stores.

Growth Score

7/10

Biggest Opportunity

Make every order cheaper per item by crossing $175, and turn the stores' salons, cafés and parties into online customers who come back.

Biggest Risk

Value: Our Generation dolls sell at Target for around $35 and their clothes fit American Girl dolls, so every shipping fee and every design misstep (like the Modern Era backlash) pushes parents toward cheaper or secondhand options.

01

Start here

The three moves to make first. Each one is written up in full below.

  1. 1

    A $135 doll ships for $19, but the doll plus a $42 jacket ships free: show parents that math in the bag

    Count last quarter's orders between $105.01 and $174.99, and how many were within $45 of $175.

    High impact First result in 2 weeks
  2. 2

    Sell each new doll as a ready-made starter set priced just over $175

    List the top 20 dolls and whether each has a doll-included set.

    High impact First result in 3 weeks
  3. 3

    Give the holiday services page this year's dates and the same shipping table as the shipping page

    Open the holiday services page and compare its dates and rates with the shipping page.

    Medium impact First result in 1 week

02

Your idea portfolio

22 ideas, grouped by when to run them. Open any idea for how to run it: the steps, who to approach, copy you can use, and how to measure it.

  • 8 ideas are marked Unexpected: plays you are unlikely to have tried.

Every idea placed by the effort it takes against the impact it could have. Quick wins sit top left; select a number to open that idea. The filters below narrow the list by status, timing, category and what Programmable can build.

Effort vs impactEach number is an idea. Select one to open it.
Impact →
Quick wins · 2Big bets · 5Fill-ins · 5Reconsider · 10
Effort →

Showing 22 of 22 ideas

This week 6

Quick wins with a clear first action.

  • 01

    American Girl charges $19 for standard delivery on every order from $105.01 to $174.99, and nothing from $175. The most common first purchase, an 18-inch doll such as Daisy Davenport at $135, lands in the middle of that band: $154 delivered. Add Daisy's $42 Jean Jacket & Accessories and the order is $177 with free shipping, so the jacket costs the family only $23 more. Add the $34 S'mores PJs instead and the order is $169 plus $19, or $188 delivered: $11 more than the bigger order. A plain "you're $40 away from free shipping" bar shows neither fact.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Director

    First action

    Count last quarter's orders between $105.01 and $174.99, and how many were within $45 of $175.

    How to measure it

    Orders moved over $175

    Now
    –
    Target
    +20% of bags in the $19 band
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Size the band

      Orders, conversion and average value between $105.01 and $174.99, by the first item in the bag.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Build completer sets

      For each of the top 20 dolls, three matching items of $40 to $70.

      Merchandising Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Rewrite the message

      Net-cost wording in the bag and on doll pages.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 day

    4. 4

      Add the shelf

      A Shopify cart block showing the doll's completer set.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    5. 5

      Catch trap carts

      Suggest a swap when an add-on leaves the bag just under $175.

      Ecommerce Developer 3 days

    6. 6

      Test

      Optimizely split against the current bar through the holiday peak.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 4 weeks

    7. 7

      Extend to the $14 band

      Same message for bags between $65.01 and $105.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 week

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    Development time; no change to shipping prices
    Owner
    Director, Ecommerce

    Smallest test

    Show the net-cost message and a three-item shelf in bags containing the Daisy Davenport doll for two weeks.

    Why it works

    Change the bag and doll-page message from distance to net cost. When the bag is between $105.01 and $174.99, show "Add $X and shipping is free: it costs you only $X minus $19", with a shelf of three items that match the doll already in the bag and close the gap (for Daisy: the $42 jacket, the $44 Camp Party Outfit, or a book plus PJs), cheapest first. Catch the trap carts, like doll plus $34 PJs at $169, with a one-tap swap to a $42+ item. Do the same for the $14 band ($65.01 to $105), where the $82 median item sits. Test it in Optimizely against today's progress bar.

    Parents buying a doll usually plan to add an outfit; the only question is which one. Showing that the bigger order costs less delivered turns the shipping fee into a reason to add the right item instead of a reason to leave, and every item on the shelf is one the child will want with that doll.

    Ready to use

    ChecklistShipping-math bag message

    [ ] Bag $105.01-$174.99: "Add $[gap] and shipping is free. It costs you $[gap - 19]"
    [ ] Bag $65.01-$105: same message against the $14 fee
    [ ] Shelf: three items matched to the doll in the bag, cheapest first
    [ ] Swap prompt for add-ons that leave the bag just under $175
    [ ] Threshold read from the live shipping rule
    [ ] Optimizely test against today's progress bar
    [ ] Report: share of bags moved over $175, average order value, conversion

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Families feel pushed to spend more than planned

      Show the cheapest item that closes the gap first and keep checkout one tap away.

    • Promotional thresholds change the math

      Read the threshold from the live shipping rule so the message is always right.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
    • PressGood Morning America shop listing for the 2027 Girl of the Year (September 17, 2026): Daisy Davenport 18-inch Doll $135; Daisy Davenport Saves the Day book $7.99; S'mores PJs $34; Jean Jacket & Accessories $42; Camp Party Outfit $44; Party Table & Snacks $150; Campfire, Guitar & Matching PJs Bundle $200; Daisy Davenport's Camp Cabin $395.Source
    • ResearchAureate Labs review of americangirl.com (September 24, 2024): a free-shipping progress bar; several wish lists that can be shared by link, with one-click add-all-to-cart; reviews rated on age appropriateness, appearance, play value and quality; Quick Shop; a Create Your Own designer whose creations can be shared by link; a free gift message and gift wrap at checkout; and a cart note that items "are not reserved".Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
  • 02

    The holiday services page is where gift buyers check wrapping and delivery, but in search snapshots it still showed 2025 delivery dates and a $15 rate for the $105.01 to $174.99 tier, while the shipping information page charges $19. Holiday delivery is already the most common complaint theme.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 week Director

    First action

    Open the holiday services page and compare its dates and rates with the shipping page.

    How to measure it

    Delivery-date contacts

    Now
    –
    Target
    -15%
    By
    End of the holiday season

    Steps

    1. 1

      Compare pages

      Dates and rates on the holiday, shipping and FAQ pages.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 hour

    2. 2

      Set the dates

      This year's order-by dates by service level.

      Fulfillment Operations Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      One source

      Pull the rate table from one content block on every page.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 day

    4. 4

      Show in the bag

      Order-by date for Christmas delivery next to the shipping fee.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 day

    5. 5

      Brief service

      Same dates and rates for phone agents.

      Director, Consumer Services 1 day

    6. 6

      Review each year

      Calendar reminder before every holiday season.

      Director, Ecommerce yearly

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Director, Ecommerce

    Smallest test

    Fix the holiday page's table today.

    Why it works

    Check the live holiday services page; if it still shows last year's dates or a different rate, publish this year's order-by dates and pull the shipping table from one source so the two pages can never disagree. Add the order-by dates to the bag and confirmation email.

    A parent who sees $15 and pays $19 feels misled at the worst moment, and wrong dates cause both lost orders and late-delivery complaints.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Dates shift with carrier capacity

      Show dates as 'order by' with a short note and update weekly.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHoliday services page: gift wrap and a personal message can be added in the bag. In search snapshots on November 3, 2026, the page still showed 2025 delivery dates and $15 for the $105.01-$174.99 tier, against $19 on the shipping information page.Source
    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
    • ReviewsBetter Business Bureau: American Girl is not BBB accredited and shows 21 complaints in three years, including a holiday order whose carrier tracking stalled while the phone agent asked the customer to call back later; Trustpilot's Canadian page has only 4 reviews.Source
  • 03

    The historical characters already come as doll-and-dress bundles at $235, but a new doll bought alone, like Daisy Davenport at $135, pays $19 shipping. Daisy's own outfits ($34 to $44) and book ($7.99) can make a set just over $175 that ships free.

    High impactLow effort First result in 3 weeks Merchandising Manager

    First action

    List the top 20 dolls and whether each has a doll-included set.

    How to measure it

    Doll orders taken as sets

    Now
    –
    Target
    25%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Audit dolls

      Which top dolls already have bundles.

      Merchandising Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Design sets

      Doll, outfit and first book at $175 to $190.

      Merchandising Manager 3 days

    3. 3

      Check margin

      Set price against the shipping saved.

      Finance Manager, Direct-to-Consumer 2 days

    4. 4

      Create bundles

      Shopify bundle products with gift-ready photos.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    5. 5

      Lead with the set

      First option on each doll page and in email.

      Director, Ecommerce 2 days

    6. 6

      Measure

      Set share, order value and returns.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    3 weeks
    Cost
    Staff time; shipping cost absorbed on sets
    Owner
    Merchandising Manager

    Smallest test

    Launch one Daisy starter set and compare with doll-only orders for a month.

    Why it works

    Check which current dolls lack a doll-included set. For Daisy, Raquel Reyes, the KPop Demon Hunters dolls and the top Truly Me dolls, build one starter set (doll, one outfit, the first book) priced from $175 to $190, gift-ready, and make it the first option on the doll page.

    One choice replaces three, the set ships free, and a doll that arrives with a second outfit and her story gets played with more.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Sets eat into full-price add-on sales

      Price sets at the sum of parts and let free shipping be the saving.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
    • PressGood Morning America shop listing for the 2027 Girl of the Year (September 17, 2026): Daisy Davenport 18-inch Doll $135; Daisy Davenport Saves the Day book $7.99; S'mores PJs $34; Jean Jacket & Accessories $42; Camp Party Outfit $44; Party Table & Snacks $150; Campfire, Guitar & Matching PJs Bundle $200; Daisy Davenport's Camp Cabin $395.Source
    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
  • 04

    Google's real-visitor data shows americangirl.com loads well (LCP 1,983 ms, layout shift 0.05, both good) but responds slowly to taps: Interaction to Next Paint is 239 ms, above the 200 ms good line. On a store where parents tap swatches, Quick Shop and add-to-bag, that lag is felt on the pages that sell.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Ecommerce Developer

    First action

    List the top five interactions by delay from field data.

    How to measure it

    INP at the 75th percentile

    Now
    –
    Target
    Under 200 ms
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Measure

      INP by page type and interaction from real users.

      Ecommerce Developer 3 days

    2. 2

      Inventory tags

      Every tag and app on product and bag pages, with an owner.

      Ecommerce Developer 2 days

    3. 3

      Remove duplicates

      Tools doing the same job twice.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Defer the rest

      Non-essential tags load after the first interaction.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    5. 5

      Fix long tasks

      Split heavy theme scripts on add to bag and Quick Shop.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    6. 6

      Track

      INP and conversion each month.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Development time
    Owner
    Ecommerce Developer

    Smallest test

    Defer one non-essential tag on product pages and watch INP for two weeks.

    Why it works

    Find the slowest interactions (add to bag, Quick Shop, size and colour pickers, bag drawer) with real-user monitoring, then trim the work they trigger: defer non-essential tags until after the tap, remove duplicate tools in the tag manager, give each script an owner, and break up long tasks in the theme code.

    Responsiveness is the one Core Web Vital the site misses, and fixing it helps both conversion and search ranking.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Deferring tags loses marketing data

      Agree with each tag owner what can wait.

    • Peak-season code freeze

      Start with tag changes, which carry the least risk.

    Evidence

    • Google PageSpeedReal-visitor data (Chrome UX Report, 75th percentile): Largest Contentful Paint 1,983 ms and layout shift 0.05, both in the good range, but Interaction to Next Paint 239 ms, above the 200 ms good threshold; LCP trend steady (-6%).Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
  • 05

    The Modern Era dolls are 14.5 inches at $90, smaller than the 18-inch line, and fans said they looked cheap and dropped the history. Parents who grew up with Samantha or Molly need to see quickly what the new doll is, how big it is, and where the classic version is.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Brand Marketing Manager

    First action

    Shoot one size-comparison photo for each of the six dolls.

    How to measure it

    Modern Era add-to-bag rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    +15%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Shoot size photos

      Each 14.5-inch doll next to her 18-inch original.

      Creative Studio Manager 3 days

    2. 2

      Write the link

      Two lines from each character's story.

      Brand Marketing Manager, Historical Characters 2 days

    3. 3

      Cross-link

      Modern and classic pages point to each other.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 day

    4. 4

      Answer in reviews

      Reply to size and quality questions.

      Consumer Services Lead ongoing

    5. 5

      Share on social

      The side-by-side photos.

      Social Media Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Conversion and returns on both lines.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Photography and staff time
    Owner
    Brand Marketing Manager, Historical Characters

    Smallest test

    Add the size photo to the Samantha modern page first.

    Why it works

    On each Modern Era page add a size photo next to an 18-inch doll, two lines on how the modern look comes from the character's original story, and a link to the classic doll. On each classic page, link the modern version for younger girls.

    Most of the criticism came from confusion and fear of losing the history; showing both answers it without pulling the line.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Reopens the backlash

      Lead with the classic line still being available.

    Evidence

    • Press40th anniversary Modern Era Collection (February 2026): Felicity, Addy, Molly, Kirsten, Samantha and Josefina reimagined as 14.5-inch dolls in contemporary outfits at $90 each, smaller than the 18-inch line. Fans on social media said the dolls looked cheap and undercut the historical focus, and urged the brand to listen to millennial customers buying for their daughters.Source
    • PressSamantha: The Next Chapter by Fiona Davis, the first American Girl novel for adults, published by American Girl Publishing on October 13, 2026, follows Samantha at 25 in 1920 New York. The author writes that grown-up fans loved the stories most, that the books "pulled no punches", and that in-house historians and outside experts review them.Source
  • 06

    AG Rewards pays $10 for every 200 points at 1 point per dollar, about 5% back, plus birthday rewards and early access. A $177 order earns 177 points, close to a $10 reward, but that value is easy to miss at checkout.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 3 weeks CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Check the share of orders placed by guests rather than members.

    How to measure it

    Checkout Rewards joins

    Now
    –
    Target
    +25%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Get the baseline

      Member share of orders and repeat rate.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Write the lines

      Member and guest versions.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      Build

      Points estimate in the bag.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Add to email

      Points earned and distance to the next reward.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 days

    5. 5

      Test

      Optimizely split on guest bags.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 3 weeks

    6. 6

      Review

      Repeat purchases from new members.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager quarterly

    First result
    3 weeks
    Cost
    Development time
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Add the line to the confirmation email first.

    Why it works

    In the bag show "This order earns 177 points: you'll be 23 points from $10 off" for members and "Join free and earn about $9 on this order" for guests, with the birthday reward as the second reason. Repeat it in the confirmation email.

    A visible reward makes the bigger order feel better and gives a reason to come back, and joining is free.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Point estimates confuse with discounts

      Show points and their dollar value together.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteAG Rewards: free to join; 1 point per $1 spent and $10 in rewards for every 200 points, redeemable online or in stores; members-only sales, birthday rewards and early access; tiers add benefits as status rises, with a Berry member gift at the top.Source
    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source

This quarter 11

The core plays for the next three months.

  • 07

    Daisy, the 2027 Girl of the Year, goes to Camp Gowonagin, the same camp Molly attended in 1944. Raquel Reyes was already written as Samantha's descendant. The brand keeps building bridges between new and historical characters, but each doll is still sold on her own.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 6 weeks Brand Marketing Manager

    First action

    Count how many Daisy buyers already own a historical doll.

    How to measure it

    Cross-line orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +30%
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      Find overlap

      Customers who bought both lines before.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Build the page

      Both dolls, books and camp sets.

      Brand Marketing Manager, Girl of the Year 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Create the set

      A two-doll camp gift set.

      Merchandising Manager 3 weeks

    4. 4

      Write the read-along

      Camp in 1944 and today, checked by the historians.

      Publishing Editor 3 weeks

    5. 5

      Email both ways

      Girl of the Year buyers to Molly, Molly fans to Daisy.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Repeat the pattern

      Samantha and Raquel next.

      Brand Marketing Manager, Girl of the Year next quarter

    First result
    6 weeks
    Cost
    Content and a gift-set run
    Owner
    Brand Marketing Manager, Girl of the Year

    Smallest test

    Send one email to Daisy buyers featuring Molly and her camp set.

    Why it works

    Build a "Camp Gowonagin" collection page with both dolls, both camp stories and the camp sets, a two-doll gift set, and a short read-along comparing camp in 1944 and today. Use it in Girl of the Year email to introduce families to the historical line, and in historical email to bring grown-up Molly fans to Daisy.

    Girl of the Year buyers get a reason to try a historical doll, and nostalgic parents get a reason to buy this year's doll for their daughter.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Two-doll sets are expensive

      Offer a doll-plus-book version for the second character.

    Evidence

    • Press2027 Girl of the Year Daisy Davenport (announced September 17, 2026): a 10-year-old from Madison, the first doll whose story is set in Wisconsin. She goes to Camp Gowonagin, the same camp Molly McIntire attended in 1944; her cabin has an outdoor sink so a cabin mate who uses a power chair can reach it, and American Girl consulted spinal muscular atrophy experts. The line includes two books, outfits, a cabin, a party table and a pet.Source
    • PressGood Morning America shop listing for the 2027 Girl of the Year (September 17, 2026): Daisy Davenport 18-inch Doll $135; Daisy Davenport Saves the Day book $7.99; S'mores PJs $34; Jean Jacket & Accessories $42; Camp Party Outfit $44; Party Table & Snacks $150; Campfire, Guitar & Matching PJs Bundle $200; Daisy Davenport's Camp Cabin $395.Source
    • Press2026 Girl of the Year Raquel Reyes, an 18-inch doll, is written as a descendant of Samantha Parkington, with a gingham top and skirt that nod to Samantha's plaid style; her debut marked the 25th year of Girl of the Year.Source
  • 08

    Samantha: The Next Chapter is the brand's first novel for adults, written for people who grew up with the stories. The Modern Era backlash showed how strongly those grown-up fans care, and they are also the parents and aunts buying for the next generation.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Publishing Marketing Manager

    First action

    Write the book club kit from the historians' research notes.

    How to measure it

    Adult fan list size

    Now
    –
    Target
    50,000
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Make the kit

      Questions, history and a timeline.

      Publishing Marketing Manager 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Create the list

      A Klaviyo segment with its own sign-up form.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Plan events

      Evening readings in three stores.

      Retail Experience Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Reach readers

      Bookstores and book clubs get the kit.

      Publishing Marketing Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Send the series

      Three emails on the characters, collector items and history.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 month

    6. 6

      Measure

      List growth and purchases by the segment.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Content and event costs
    Owner
    Publishing Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Publish the kit and track sign-ups for a month.

    Why it works

    Publish a free book club kit (questions, the historical background, a Samantha timeline), host reading events in the stores, and invite readers to a grown-up fans email list with collector releases, author news and the historical line. Ask on sign-up whether they are buying for themselves, a child or both.

    Readers who reconnect with the brand through the novel become buyers of collector items and gifts, and their passion becomes advocacy instead of backlash.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Adult emails reach children

      Keep the list adult-only by sign-up and age confirmation.

    Evidence

    • PressSamantha: The Next Chapter by Fiona Davis, the first American Girl novel for adults, published by American Girl Publishing on October 13, 2026, follows Samantha at 25 in 1920 New York. The author writes that grown-up fans loved the stories most, that the books "pulled no punches", and that in-house historians and outside experts review them.Source
    • Press40th anniversary Modern Era Collection (February 2026): Felicity, Addy, Molly, Kirsten, Samantha and Josefina reimagined as 14.5-inch dolls in contemporary outfits at $90 each, smaller than the 18-inch line. Fans on social media said the dolls looked cheap and undercut the historical focus, and urged the brand to listen to millennial customers buying for their daughters.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
  • 09

    American Girl parties are a full product: the Franklin party planner runs games, crafts, doll hair styling and doll skin care, upsells dessert and to-go orders and has sales goals. Chicago's holiday events range from about $13 to $105 per guest with a $50 deposit and every guest booked. Prices and booking rules vary by store and event.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 2 months Retail Experience Manager

    First action

    List how each store takes party bookings today and which parts happen by phone.

    How to measure it

    Online party bookings

    Now
    –
    Target
    50% of parties
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Map today

      Packages, prices and booking method per store.

      Retail Experience Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Standardise packages

      Three tiers per store with clear inclusions.

      Retail Experience Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Build pages

      One page per store with photos and dates.

      Director, Ecommerce 3 weeks

    4. 4

      Add booking

      Online date choice and deposit payment.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 month

    5. 5

      Invitations

      Digital invites with a matching-outfit link.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Brief planners

      Pre-event contact uses the online booking.

      Retail Department Manager 1 week

    7. 7

      Measure

      Bookings, party value and guest sign-ups.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    2 months
    Cost
    Booking tool and development
    Owner
    Retail Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Put one store's party packages online with deposit booking.

    Why it works

    For each store with a bistro or party room, publish one page with the packages, per-guest prices, what the child gets, photos, available dates and add-ons, and let parents book and pay the deposit online. Send the guest list a digital invitation that links to a matching outfit.

    Parents plan birthdays weeks ahead and compare options online; clear prices and instant booking win the date, and invitations bring new families to the site.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Double bookings

      Sync availability with the store's own calendar.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHoliday events at the Chicago store: per-guest prices from about $13 to $105, a $50 deposit at booking, and every adult and child in the party must be booked.Source
    • HiringParty Planner, Franklin, TN (part-time): runs each party from "pre-event customer communication" to cleanup, with games, crafts, doll hair styling and doll skin care tied to the American Girl Bistro; upsells desserts and to-go orders and must "meet sales goals" to "create a magical event".Source
    • HiringMattel careers lists 92 American Girl Retail openings (checked November 3, 2026), most dated late October 2026: in the New York City store, sales clerks, a retail department manager, café hosts and a seasonal server, a salon stylist, merchandise handlers and asset protection; in Franklin, Tennessee, a party planner and a holiday seasonal doll hair stylist.Source
  • 10

    The stores create the brand's strongest moments: ear piercing for dolls and girls, doll hairstyles, café meals and parties built for "smiles and lasting memories". Staff are even asked to share event news at the table. But a family that visits without buying at the till may leave no record the site can follow up.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 month CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Count how many salon and party guests leave an email today.

    How to measure it

    Visit-to-online orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +20%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Get the baseline

      Store visitors with an email on file.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Set up capture

      Tablet sign-up for the photo with clear consent.

      Retail Department Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Train staff

      Salon stylists, hosts and party planners offer the photo.

      Retail Department Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Build the flow

      Klaviyo next-day email with photo, outfit and points.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Guest follow-up

      Party guests' parents get a thank-you.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Opens, orders and repeat visits.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Tablets and staff time
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Run the photo offer at one store's salon for a month.

    Why it works

    Offer a free photo of the child and doll at the salon chair or party table, sent by email or text. The next-day email carries the photo, the outfit the doll wore, points earned in AG Rewards and the next store event; parties add a thank-you to each guest's parent. Track visits that become online orders.

    The photo is something families want, so they share contact details gladly, and the follow-up arrives while the memory is fresh.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Children's privacy

      Collect only a parent's contact, with clear consent, and follow children's privacy rules.

    Evidence

    • HiringSalon Stylist, New York City store: ear piercing "for dolls and girls", hair styling and manicures, delivering a "high level premium experience" focused on "smiles and lasting memories". The NYC café Server role asks staff to "share store and restaurant event news" and to upsell.Source
    • HiringParty Planner, Franklin, TN (part-time): runs each party from "pre-event customer communication" to cleanup, with games, crafts, doll hair styling and doll skin care tied to the American Girl Bistro; upsells desserts and to-go orders and must "meet sales goals" to "create a magical event".Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
    • Your websiteAG Rewards: free to join; 1 point per $1 spent and $10 in rewards for every 200 points, redeemable online or in stores; members-only sales, birthday rewards and early access; tiers add benefits as status rises, with a Berry member gift at the top.Source
  • 11

    Even the smaller Tysons store kept the doll salon, customization stations, a care center and personal-guide appointments, and the New York salon pierces ears for dolls and girls. The site's gift content (the 2026 holiday guide, "meaningful gifts at every budget") sells products, not these experiences.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Retail Experience Manager

    First action

    Price four voucher types with store managers.

    How to measure it

    Vouchers sold

    Now
    –
    Target
    5,000
    By
    End of the holiday season

    Steps

    1. 1

      Choose experiences

      Salon, piercing, personal guide, party seat.

      Retail Experience Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Set rules

      Validity, booking and which stores.

      Retail Experience Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Build vouchers

      Digital and printable gift cards.

      Ecommerce Developer 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Add to guides

      Holiday guide and gifts by budget.

      Content Marketing Manager 3 days

    5. 5

      Prepare stores

      Redemption and January staffing.

      Retail Department Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Sales, redemptions and spend on the visit.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Development and printing
    Owner
    Retail Experience Manager

    Smallest test

    Sell salon vouchers for one store this season.

    Why it works

    Create gift vouchers for a salon visit, ear piercing, a personal-guide shopping appointment and a party seat, redeemable at any store, with a printable card for the stocking. Add them to the holiday guide and the gifts-by-budget page, and offer them to relatives who don't know which doll to buy.

    Experience gifts don't duplicate toys the child already has, fill stores in quiet weeks after the holidays, and bring families in who then buy.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Voucher holders far from a store

      Show the store finder before purchase and allow use as online credit.

    Evidence

    • HiringSalon Stylist, New York City store: ear piercing "for dolls and girls", hair styling and manicures, delivering a "high level premium experience" focused on "smiles and lasting memories". The NYC café Server role asks staff to "share store and restaurant event news" and to upsell.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (November 2026): headline "New for the holidays" (a year earlier, "Holiday Gifts, Dolls, & Accessories"); title "American Girl®: Shop 18” Dolls, Clothing, Playsets & More". Blog posts include The Ultimate 2026 Holiday Shopping Guide, Personalize Her American Girl Doll, Why Daisy Davenport matters, Meaningful gifts at every budget (pictured with Samantha Parkington and Raquel Reyes) and The lasting value of American Girl. Six homepage images have no alt text.Source
    • PressTysons Corner Center store (reopened January 17, 2026): a smaller first-floor store replacing a two-story shop, still offering a doll styling salon, customization stations, a care center for repairs and appointments to shop with a personal guide, but no bistro for tea times.Source
    • HiringMattel careers lists 92 American Girl Retail openings (checked November 3, 2026), most dated late October 2026: in the New York City store, sales clerks, a retail department manager, café hosts and a seasonal server, a salon stylist, merchandise handlers and asset protection; in Franklin, Tennessee, a party planner and a holiday seasonal doll hair stylist.Source
  • 12

    Buying guides tell parents that Our Generation dolls cost around $35 at Target and that its clothes fit American Girl dolls, while American Girl wins on vinyl, hair and clothing quality (stitched faux-suede shoes against molded plastic). Parents are deciding where to buy the next outfit, and the comparison is being written by others.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 months Content Marketing Manager

    First action

    Pull review quality ratings for the top 30 outfits.

    How to measure it

    Repeat outfit orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Gather proof

      Review quality ratings and product specs.

      Content Marketing Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Write the guide

      Fabric, stitching, shoes and fit.

      Content Marketing Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Build the edit

      Outfits and accessories under $45.

      Merchandising Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Shoot close-ups

      Seams, shoes and closures.

      Creative Studio Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Publish and place

      Blog, doll pages and post-purchase email.

      Content Marketing Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Search traffic and repeat outfit orders.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    2 months
    Cost
    Content and photography
    Owner
    Content Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Publish the under-$45 edit and link it from three doll pages.

    Why it works

    Publish a guide on what makes an American Girl outfit last (fabric, stitching, shoes, sizing for the 18-inch body), using the quality ratings customers already leave in reviews, and pair it with an edit of outfits and accessories under $45. Show it on doll pages and in post-purchase email.

    It meets parents at the moment they look for cheaper clothes and gives them a reason, and a price, to stay with the brand.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Naming rivals invites comparison

      Talk about what to look for, not about other brands.

    Evidence

    • Competitor researchAG vs Our Generation buying guide (updated April 18, 2026): American Girl dolls cost about $115 to $180 and collector dolls up to $300; Our Generation dolls sell at Target for around $35, and Our Generation clothing and some shoes fit American Girl dolls. American Girl wins on vinyl, hair and clothing quality (stitched faux-suede shoes against molded plastic). Secondhand American Girl dolls sell for about $25 to $55.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
    • ResearchAureate Labs review of americangirl.com (September 24, 2024): a free-shipping progress bar; several wish lists that can be shared by link, with one-click add-all-to-cart; reviews rated on age appropriateness, appearance, play value and quality; Quick Shop; a Create Your Own designer whose creations can be shared by link; a free gift message and gift wrap at checkout; and a cart note that items "are not reserved".Source
  • 13

    The KPop Demon Hunters 18-inch dolls, $65 outfits and plush are among the store's top products, and a licensed hit is the kind of launch that brings families who have never bought from American Girl. Preorders are now arriving, which is when a welcome either happens or doesn't.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Count first-time buyers among the collaboration orders.

    How to measure it

    90-day repeat rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    +5 points
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Flag orders

      First orders containing a collaboration item.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Write the series

      Care, Rewards, outfits and characters.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Time to delivery

      Trigger on delivery, not on order.

      Ecommerce Developer 3 days

    4. 4

      Add a care card

      A printed hair-care card in the box.

      Fulfillment Operations Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Launch

      Klaviyo flow for all collaboration first buyers.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 day

    6. 6

      Compare

      Repeat rate against other first buyers.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager quarterly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time and printing
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Send the care email to one week's collaboration deliveries.

    Why it works

    Flag first orders that contain a collaboration item. Send a short series after delivery: how to care for the doll's hair, an invitation to join AG Rewards, the matching outfits, and one introduction to the brand's own characters. Compare their second-order rate with other first-time buyers.

    A licensed doll gets them in; care tips and the brand's own stories turn a one-off fan purchase into a second order.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Fans only want the collaboration

      Lead with matching collaboration outfits before the brand's own lines.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
    • Your websiteAG Rewards: free to join; 1 point per $1 spent and $10 in rewards for every 200 points, redeemable online or in stores; members-only sales, birthday rewards and early access; tiers add benefits as status rises, with a Berry member gift at the top.Source
  • 14

    The YouTube icon on americangirl.com opens @MattelImagine, a shared Mattel channel with 12,890 videos across brands. A parent looking for doll hairstyles, Daisy's camp story or care tips lands among other Mattel brands. American Girl already has its own Instagram and TikTok, and store salon stylists do doll hairstyles every day.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Social Media Manager

    First action

    Change the footer link to an American Girl playlist.

    How to measure it

    Sessions from video

    Now
    –
    Target
    +30%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Fix the link

      Footer and social icons point to American Girl video.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 hour

    2. 2

      Plan series

      Hairstyles, outfits, care and stories.

      Social Media Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Film in stores

      Salon stylists show hairstyles.

      Retail Experience Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Edit for each platform

      YouTube Shorts, TikTok, Instagram.

      Social Media Manager weekly

    5. 5

      Link products

      Each video to the items shown.

      Social Media Manager weekly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Views, saves and product visits.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Filming time
    Owner
    Social Media Manager

    Smallest test

    Post five salon hairstyle clips and track product clicks.

    Why it works

    Point the site's video link to an American Girl playlist or channel, and fill it with short, useful videos: doll hairstyles by store salon stylists, outfit pairings, care and repair tips, and character stories. Post the same clips on TikTok and Instagram, and link each to the products shown.

    How-to videos are searched for long after they are posted, and they show the quality and care that set the brand apart.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Children in videos

      Film hands and dolls only, or with signed parental consent.

    Evidence

    • SocialThe site's YouTube link goes to Mattel's shared @MattelImagine channel (3.42 million subscribers, 12,890 videos across Mattel brands), not to an American Girl channel; American Girl's own accounts are Instagram @americangirlbrand, TikTok @americangirl, Facebook and X @American_Girl.Source
    • HiringSalon Stylist, New York City store: ear piercing "for dolls and girls", hair styling and manicures, delivering a "high level premium experience" focused on "smiles and lasting memories". The NYC café Server role asks staff to "share store and restaurant event news" and to upsell.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (November 2026): headline "New for the holidays" (a year earlier, "Holiday Gifts, Dolls, & Accessories"); title "American Girl®: Shop 18” Dolls, Clothing, Playsets & More". Blog posts include The Ultimate 2026 Holiday Shopping Guide, Personalize Her American Girl Doll, Why Daisy Davenport matters, Meaningful gifts at every budget (pictured with Samantha Parkington and Raquel Reyes) and The lasting value of American Girl. Six homepage images have no alt text.Source
  • 15

    The pattern in public complaints is holiday delivery: carrier tracking that stalls while the customer is told to call back. Rush delivery costs extra even on free-shipping orders, so a late gift feels doubly expensive.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 weeks Director

    First action

    Define 'stalled' (for example no scan for 48 hours) and count last season's cases.

    How to measure it

    Holiday delivery complaints

    Now
    –
    Target
    -25%
    By
    End of the holiday season

    Steps

    1. 1

      Define stalls

      No scan in 48 hours, or past the promised date.

      Fulfillment Operations Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Set alerts

      Daily list of stalled shipments.

      Fulfillment Operations Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Write messages

      Delay, new date and options.

      Director, Consumer Services 2 days

    4. 4

      Empower agents

      Reship or upgrade without escalation.

      Director, Consumer Services 1 week

    5. 5

      Printable gift note

      "Your gift is on its way" card for late orders.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 3 days

    6. 6

      Review

      Complaints and reviews after the season.

      Director, Consumer Services January

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    Staff time and reship costs
    Owner
    Director, Consumer Services

    Smallest test

    Send proactive delay emails for one week's stalled shipments.

    Why it works

    Watch every holiday shipment for stalled tracking and act first: an email or text explaining the delay, the new date, and an option (reship, gift-card note for the tree, or upgraded shipping) before the parent calls. Give phone agents the same view and authority.

    A delay handled before the customer notices keeps the gift and the relationship; public reviews praise exactly this kind of recovery.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Too many alerts

      Start with orders for Christmas delivery only.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • ReviewsBetter Business Bureau: American Girl is not BBB accredited and shows 21 complaints in three years, including a holiday order whose carrier tracking stalled while the phone agent asked the customer to call back later; Trustpilot's Canadian page has only 4 reviews.Source
    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
    • Your websiteHoliday services page: gift wrap and a personal message can be added in the bag. In search snapshots on November 3, 2026, the page still showed 2025 delivery dates and $15 for the $105.01-$174.99 tier, against $19 on the shipping information page.Source
  • 16

    Wish lists can already be shared by link and added to the bag in one click, and checkout offers free gift messages and wrap. But when several relatives buy from one list, each pays shipping on a small order and two may buy the same outfit.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 months Director

    First action

    Measure how many wish-list shares turn into orders today.

    How to measure it

    Wish-list orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +25%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Baseline

      Shares, visits and orders from lists.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Design claiming

      Hidden claims and what's left.

      Product Designer 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Build

      Claims and a combined family order.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 month

    4. 4

      Shipping rule

      Combined order counts toward $175.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 week

    5. 5

      Reminders

      Before birthdays and the holidays.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Orders, duplicates and new visitors.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    2 months
    Cost
    Development time
    Owner
    Director, Ecommerce

    Smallest test

    Add item claiming to shared lists before building combined orders.

    Why it works

    Let relatives claim items on a shared list (hidden from the child), see what's left, and choose to join one combined order that ships to the family; when the combined order passes $175, everyone's share ships free. Send the list owner a gentle reminder before birthdays and holidays.

    No duplicate gifts, fewer small orders paying $9 to $19 each, and every relative who opens the list is a new visitor.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Combined orders delay some gifts

      Let each relative choose to ship alone.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • ResearchAureate Labs review of americangirl.com (September 24, 2024): a free-shipping progress bar; several wish lists that can be shared by link, with one-click add-all-to-cart; reviews rated on age appropriateness, appearance, play value and quality; Quick Shop; a Create Your Own designer whose creations can be shared by link; a free gift message and gift wrap at checkout; and a cart note that items "are not reserved".Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (November 2026): headline "New for the holidays" (a year earlier, "Holiday Gifts, Dolls, & Accessories"); title "American Girl®: Shop 18” Dolls, Clothing, Playsets & More". Blog posts include The Ultimate 2026 Holiday Shopping Guide, Personalize Her American Girl Doll, Why Daisy Davenport matters, Meaningful gifts at every budget (pictured with Samantha Parkington and Raquel Reyes) and The lasting value of American Girl. Six homepage images have no alt text.Source
    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
  • 17

    Create Your Own lets a child choose eyes, hair, skin tone and face and share the design by link, and the site promotes personalised dolls for the holidays. Today the share link shows the design; it could also be the checkout for the grandparent who wants to give it.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 months Director

    First action

    Count Create Your Own shares and how many lead to an order.

    How to measure it

    Gift orders via share links

    Now
    –
    Target
    15% of Create Your Own orders
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Baseline

      Shares and orders today.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Design the gift link

      Design, wrap, message and date.

      Product Designer 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Build

      Gift checkout from the share link.

      Ecommerce Developer 3 weeks

    4. 4

      Keep the surprise

      Hide gift orders from the designer's account.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    5. 5

      Promote

      Personalisation blog and email.

      Content Marketing Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Shares, gift orders and new customers.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager monthly

    First result
    2 months
    Cost
    Development time
    Owner
    Director, Ecommerce

    Smallest test

    Add a gift message and wrap preset to the existing share link.

    Why it works

    Add a "Send to someone to gift" option on Create Your Own: the link opens the exact design with gift wrap, a message from the giver and the order-by date, and keeps the surprise by hiding price and delivery details from the child's account.

    The child does the choosing, the relative does the buying, and every share brings a new, high-intent visitor.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Build-to-order lead times

      Show the order-by date on the gift link.

    Evidence

    • ResearchAureate Labs review of americangirl.com (September 24, 2024): a free-shipping progress bar; several wish lists that can be shared by link, with one-click add-all-to-cart; reviews rated on age appropriateness, appearance, play value and quality; Quick Shop; a Create Your Own designer whose creations can be shared by link; a free gift message and gift wrap at checkout; and a cart note that items "are not reserved".Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (November 2026): headline "New for the holidays" (a year earlier, "Holiday Gifts, Dolls, & Accessories"); title "American Girl®: Shop 18” Dolls, Clothing, Playsets & More". Blog posts include The Ultimate 2026 Holiday Shopping Guide, Personalize Her American Girl Doll, Why Daisy Davenport matters, Meaningful gifts at every budget (pictured with Samantha Parkington and Raquel Reyes) and The lasting value of American Girl. Six homepage images have no alt text.Source

Big bets 3

Larger plays that can change the trajectory.

  • 18

    With a median item price of $82, a typical single add-on order pays $14 shipping, and anything from $105.01 to $174.99 pays $19. AG Rewards already has tiers, birthday rewards and early access, but no way to remove shipping for the families who buy outfits through the year.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 1 quarter CRM & Loyalty Manager

    First action

    Model last year's shipping paid by repeat members.

    How to measure it

    Member order frequency

    Now
    –
    Target
    +1 order a year
    By
    1 year

    Steps

    1. 1

      Model

      Shipping paid and order count by member.

      Finance Manager, Direct-to-Consumer 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Set the offer

      Price and benefits.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Legal terms

      Auto-renewal and cancellation rules.

      Legal 3 weeks

    4. 4

      Build

      Membership product and shipping rule.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 month

    5. 5

      Pilot

      Invite frequent small-order members.

      CRM & Loyalty Manager 1 quarter

    6. 6

      Decide

      Frequency and margin against a control group.

      Finance Manager, Direct-to-Consumer after pilot

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Shipping subsidy plus development
    Owner
    CRM & Loyalty Manager

    Smallest test

    Offer the membership to 5,000 frequent members.

    Why it works

    Test a paid Rewards upgrade (for example $29 a year) with free standard shipping on every order, early access to Girl of the Year and a member event in stores. Pilot it with members who placed two or more orders under $175 last year and measure order frequency and margin.

    The families who buy most often pay the most shipping; a membership turns that cost into loyalty and more frequent small orders.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Members who would have crossed $175 anyway

      Target members whose orders are mostly under $175.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping information page (US): standard delivery costs $9.00 for orders up to $65, $14.00 for $65.01-$105, $19.00 for $105.01-$174.99, and is free at $175 or more; oversize orders ship at a flat $25.00, and rush delivery still carries a surcharge.Source
    • Your websiteAG Rewards: free to join; 1 point per $1 spent and $10 in rewards for every 200 points, redeemable online or in stores; members-only sales, birthday rewards and early access; tiers add benefits as status rises, with a Berry member gift at the top.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue scan (November 3, 2026): 250 products from $5.99 to $404, median price $82; books from $5.99 to $19.99; historical doll-and-dress bundles at $235; American Girl x KPop Demon Hunters outfits at $65 and a Derpy plush set at $50; an AG Sisters bundle at $76. The store runs on Shopify with Klaviyo email and Optimizely testing, and checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and Venmo.Source
  • 19

    American Girl's historical books are written at about a fourth-grade reading level and reviewed by in-house historians and outside experts, covering hard history such as Addy's escape during the Civil War. Teachers already teach these periods; few toy brands have this depth of reviewed material.

    Medium impactHigh effort First result in 1 school term Publishing Director

    First action

    Draft one kit (Molly, 1944) and test it with five teachers.

    How to measure it

    Active classrooms

    Now
    –
    Target
    2,000
    By
    1 school year

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick characters

      Three periods most taught in grades 3 to 5.

      Publishing Director 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Write kits

      Timeline, sources and questions.

      Senior Historian 2 months

    3. 3

      Teacher test

      Five classrooms try the first kit.

      Publishing Marketing Manager 1 month

    4. 4

      Price class sets

      Books at an education price.

      Publishing Director 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Distribute

      Teacher networks and libraries.

      Publishing Marketing Manager 1 quarter

    6. 6

      Measure

      Classrooms, book sets and family visits.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager per term

    First result
    1 school term
    Cost
    Writing, design and book discounts
    Owner
    Publishing Director

    Smallest test

    One kit, five classrooms, one term.

    Why it works

    Package the historical stories into free classroom kits for grades 3 to 5: a period timeline, primary-source activities and discussion questions for each character, with class sets of books at an education price. Offer them through teacher networks and libraries, and invite classes to store events.

    Teachers bring the characters to children who have never owned a doll, and the brand's history becomes its reputation again, which answers the Modern Era criticism directly.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Schools wary of brand marketing

      Keep kits free of product promotion.

    Evidence

    • PressSamantha: The Next Chapter by Fiona Davis, the first American Girl novel for adults, published by American Girl Publishing on October 13, 2026, follows Samantha at 25 in 1920 New York. The author writes that grown-up fans loved the stories most, that the books "pulled no punches", and that in-house historians and outside experts review them.Source
    • Press40th anniversary Modern Era Collection (February 2026): Felicity, Addy, Molly, Kirsten, Samantha and Josefina reimagined as 14.5-inch dolls in contemporary outfits at $90 each, smaller than the 18-inch line. Fans on social media said the dolls looked cheap and undercut the historical focus, and urged the brand to listen to millennial customers buying for their daughters.Source
    • Press2026 Girl of the Year Raquel Reyes, an 18-inch doll, is written as a descendant of Samantha Parkington, with a gingham top and skirt that nod to Samantha's plaid style; her debut marked the 25th year of Girl of the Year.Source
  • 20

    The Tysons store moved from two floors to a smaller first-floor space without the bistro but kept the doll salon, customization stations, care center and personal-guide appointments. That is a format that could open where a full flagship never would, and the brand is already hiring store staff for salon, café and seasonal roles.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 1 holiday season VP

    First action

    Map online order density against the current store locations.

    How to measure it

    First-time customers from pop-ups

    Now
    –
    Target
    5,000 per pop-up season
    By
    1 year

    Steps

    1. 1

      Define the format

      Salon, care, personal guide and a small range.

      VP, Retail 1 month

    2. 2

      Pick cities

      Dense online orders, no store nearby.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Secure space

      Short holiday leases in malls.

      Real Estate Manager 1 quarter

    4. 4

      Staff

      Seasonal stylists and associates.

      Retail Department Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Connect online

      Appointments, ship-from-site and email capture.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 month

    6. 6

      Evaluate

      New customers, sales and cost per visitor.

      VP, Retail after season

    First result
    1 holiday season
    Cost
    Lease, fit-out and staffing per pop-up
    Owner
    VP, Retail

    Smallest test

    One pop-up in one city for one holiday season.

    Why it works

    Turn the Tysons layout into a repeatable small format and test it as holiday pop-ups in two or three cities without a store, chosen from where online orders are dense. Each pop-up runs salon and care appointments booked online, ships orders from the site and captures every visitor for email.

    Experiences are what the stores have that the site and rivals don't; a small format brings them to more families at lower cost.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Pop-ups dilute the premium feel

      Keep salon and care services at full standard.

    Builds on

    Evidence

    • PressTysons Corner Center store (reopened January 17, 2026): a smaller first-floor store replacing a two-story shop, still offering a doll styling salon, customization stations, a care center for repairs and appointments to shop with a personal guide, but no bistro for tea times.Source
    • HiringMattel careers lists 92 American Girl Retail openings (checked November 3, 2026), most dated late October 2026: in the New York City store, sales clerks, a retail department manager, café hosts and a seasonal server, a salon stylist, merchandise handlers and asset protection; in Franklin, Tennessee, a party planner and a holiday seasonal doll hair stylist.Source
    • HiringSalon Stylist, New York City store: ear piercing "for dolls and girls", hair styling and manicures, delivering a "high level premium experience" focused on "smiles and lasting memories". The NYC café Server role asks staff to "share store and restaurant event news" and to upsell.Source

Wildcards 2

Unexpected experiments, each with a cheap way to test it.

  • 21

    For Daisy's cabin mate who uses a power chair, American Girl consulted spinal muscular atrophy experts and gave the cabin an accessible sink. Yet six images on the homepage alone have no alt text, so a parent using a screen reader can't tell which doll or outfit is shown.

    Low impactLow effort First result in 1 week Content Designer

    First action

    Fix the six homepage images.

    How to measure it

    Alt text coverage

    Now
    –
    Target
    100% of top 500 images
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      Fix the homepage

      Six images first.

      Content Designer 1 hour

    2. 2

      Audit templates

      Collections and product pages.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    3. 3

      Write a style

      Character, outfit and contents in one line.

      Content Designer 2 days

    4. 4

      Fill the backlog

      Top 500 images by traffic.

      Content Designer 1 month

    5. 5

      Build it in

      Alt text required in the photo upload step.

      Ecommerce Developer 1 week

    6. 6

      Check quarterly

      Automated scan of top templates.

      Ecommerce Developer quarterly

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    Writing time
    Owner
    Content Designer

    Smallest test

    Fix the homepage images today.

    Why it works

    Write alt text for every homepage, collection and product image (character, outfit, what's in the set), add it to the product-photo workflow so new launches ship with it, and check the top templates each quarter.

    It helps customers who rely on screen readers, improves image search, and keeps the site in step with the brand's inclusive storytelling.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Generic descriptions

      Use the style guide and review samples.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (November 2026): headline "New for the holidays" (a year earlier, "Holiday Gifts, Dolls, & Accessories"); title "American Girl®: Shop 18” Dolls, Clothing, Playsets & More". Blog posts include The Ultimate 2026 Holiday Shopping Guide, Personalize Her American Girl Doll, Why Daisy Davenport matters, Meaningful gifts at every budget (pictured with Samantha Parkington and Raquel Reyes) and The lasting value of American Girl. Six homepage images have no alt text.Source
    • Press2027 Girl of the Year Daisy Davenport (announced September 17, 2026): a 10-year-old from Madison, the first doll whose story is set in Wisconsin. She goes to Camp Gowonagin, the same camp Molly McIntire attended in 1944; her cabin has an outdoor sink so a cabin mate who uses a power chair can reach it, and American Girl consulted spinal muscular atrophy experts. The line includes two books, outfits, a cabin, a party table and a pet.Source
  • 22

    Secondhand American Girl dolls sell for about $25 to $55 on eBay, Facebook Marketplace and thrift shops, with no care, warranty or new clothes. The stores already run care centers for repairs, and AG Rewards credit can be spent online or in stores.

    Medium impactHigh effort First result in 1 quarter Director

    First action

    Ask two care centers how many dolls a week they could refresh.

    How to measure it

    Certified pre-loved sales

    Now
    –
    Target
    2,000 dolls
    By
    1 year

    Steps

    1. 1

      Size capacity

      Refresh time and cost per doll.

      Care Center Manager 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Set credit

      Trade-in credit by doll and condition.

      Finance Manager, Direct-to-Consumer 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Pilot trade-ins

      Two stores accept dolls.

      Retail Department Manager 1 quarter

    4. 4

      Refresh standard

      Cleaning, hair and a new outfit.

      Care Center Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Sell online

      A certified pre-loved collection.

      Director, Ecommerce 1 month

    6. 6

      Measure

      Margin, new members and outfit add-ons.

      Ecommerce Analytics Manager quarterly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Care-center labour and credit
    Owner
    Director, Ecommerce

    Smallest test

    Accept trade-ins at one store for a month.

    Why it works

    Let families trade in an outgrown doll at a store for Rewards credit. The care center cleans and restyles it, and the site sells it as "certified pre-loved" with a new outfit and a care card, at a price between the secondhand market and a new doll. Every buyer becomes a Rewards member and a customer for new outfits.

    It brings the secondhand market's buyers into the brand, turns trade-ins into store visits, and gives older dolls a second life with the brand's quality promise.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Cannibalises new doll sales

      Limit to retired characters and price above the secondhand market.

    Evidence

    • Competitor researchAG vs Our Generation buying guide (updated April 18, 2026): American Girl dolls cost about $115 to $180 and collector dolls up to $300; Our Generation dolls sell at Target for around $35, and Our Generation clothing and some shoes fit American Girl dolls. American Girl wins on vinyl, hair and clothing quality (stitched faux-suede shoes against molded plastic). Secondhand American Girl dolls sell for about $25 to $55.Source
    • PressTysons Corner Center store (reopened January 17, 2026): a smaller first-floor store replacing a two-story shop, still offering a doll styling salon, customization stations, a care center for repairs and appointments to shop with a personal guide, but no bistro for tea times.Source
    • Your websiteAG Rewards: free to join; 1 point per $1 spent and $10 in rewards for every 200 points, redeemable online or in stores; members-only sales, birthday rewards and early access; tiers add benefits as status rises, with a Berry member gift at the top.Source

03

How Programmable can help

Where an idea in this playbook is something Programmable builds or runs, it's listed here with what we'd do. Everything else is yours to run.

ProgrammableDigital

Show it, don't just describe it

These ideas need something to show: a demo, a video, an animation, graphics or a deck. Digital turns screenshots or the site into all of them, in the company's own brand.

Make a demo (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
Website review of americangirl.com More example playbooks and reviews

More growth playbooks

Other companies we have researched, each read from what they are hiring for.

  • ProductWind growth strategyA creator marketing platform that mobilizes retail-native creators to drive shopper demand, reviews, organic rank and ad efficiency for…22 growth ideas
  • Foundation Industries growth strategyA domestic CNC machining partner for hard-tech companies: approved customers upload parts to a portal, get quotes, pay and track…22 growth ideas
  • Pylon growth strategyAn agentic support platform for B2B companies: one inbox for Slack, Teams, email, chat, Discord, WhatsApp and phone, with AI agents that…21 growth ideas
  • Beacon growth strategyA permanent holding company that acquires, operates and grows vertical market software businesses, adding product, engineering, applied…21 growth ideas
  • The Beachwaver Co. growth strategyMaker of the patented Beachwaver rotating curling iron (B1, B1.25 and Pro) and vegan haircare such as Great Barrier heat protectant, with…21 growth ideas
  • Honor growth strategyHonor Technology runs a home care platform and owns Home Instead, the global in-home senior care franchisor; it operates company-owned…21 growth ideas
  • Semble growth strategyAI software for building-system integrators: takeoffs and device counts from PDF and DWG plan sets, device layout with the integrator's…22 growth ideas
  • DuckDuckGo growth strategyThe online protection company: a private search engine, browsers for every platform, Duck.ai for private AI chats, Email Protection, and a…22 growth ideas

See every playbook and website review

Independent research. Programmable wrote this playbook from public sources, as they stood on November 9, 2026, and cites them throughout. American Girl did not commission, review or endorse it, and Programmable is not affiliated with American Girl. Company and product names are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. The ideas are suggestions and opinion, not professional, legal or financial advice, and not statements about how American Girl runs its business.

Something wrong, or do you represent American Girl? Email [email protected] and we will correct it or take it down.

30/60/90 roadmap

What to focus on in each month, and the ideas that carry it.

  1. Days 1 to 306 ideas

    Shipping-band math in the bag, one shipping table across pages, $175+ starter sets, faster taps, clearer Modern Era pages and Rewards value at checkout.

  2. Days 31 to 6011 ideas

    Link the stores to the site and the line to itself: Daisy and Molly, grown-up fans, bookable parties, post-visit email, experience gifts, the quality guide, collab welcome, video, delivery updates, family gift plans and shared Create Your Own designs.

  3. Days 61 to 905 ideas

    Decide on the big bets (shipping membership, classroom kits, smaller stores) and run the wildcards: alt text and certified pre-loved dolls.

The research behind the plan

3 research areas, each summarised in a few lines. Open any of them for the full detail.

Customers

What customers say

Customers value the stories and historical characters. The most cited problem: high prices and shipping fees.

  • Quality: hair, vinyl and well-made clothes
  • Holiday delivery delays
  • In their words: “18-inch doll”

Market

Competitive landscape

3 competitors compared: Our Generation (Battat), The secondhand American Girl market and Third-party 18-inch doll clothing.

  • Gap to exploit: Products and stories for grown-up fans
  • Our Generation (Battat): Rooted hair and molded plastic shoes
  • The secondhand American Girl market: No warranty, care or new clothes

Hiring signals

American Girl's open roles are all in its stores, ahead of the holidays: 92 retail openings on Mattel's careers site, mostly dated late October 2026.

  • American Girl NYC - Licensed Cosmetologist (salon stylist): Ear piercing for dolls and girls, styling and a premium salon experience. Ideas 10, 11…
  • American Girl Franklin Location Party Planner - Part Time: Parties with sales goals, upsells and pre-event contact. Ideas 9, 10.
  • American Girl NYC - Server (Seasonal): Café staff share store and event news with guests. Idea 10.

From the team that wrote this playbook

All products
  • ProgrammableAgencyWorking AI systems in days, not quarters (opens programmable.agency in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableInfoAn agent that finds, researches and asks firstNew accounts get 100,000 free enrichment credits with code BETA100K (opens programmable.info in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableDigitalScreenshots in, an animated product demo out (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableWatchKnow the day a supplier falls out of compliance (opens programmable.watch in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableTalkGet registrants for your events, and know who’s coming (opens programmable.talk in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableMediaAn AI note taker, interpreter and webinar host for your calls (opens programmable.media in a new tab)
  • ProgrammablePageText what you need, your customer gets a page that works (opens programmable.page in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableCommunityForums with labelled AI members, never empty (opens programmable.community in a new tab)
ProgrammableMarketing
ExamplesLeaderboardsProductsTermsPrivacyCookiesDPALegalContact

© 2026 AI-Powered Growth Intelligence