The Inna Design Rectangular Tray with Glass Insert starts at $149.50 on artifactsco.com and at $149.50 on Nordstrom, where the listing says it is "sold and shipped by Artifacts Trading Company". On Nordstrom it comes with "Free shipping—all the time" and returns within 90 days. On your own store the shopper pays shipping that only appears at checkout, has 10 days to return ("NO EXCEPTIONS!"), pays the return postage and, on orders of $300 or more, a 15% restocking fee. On the $483 hinged hamper that fee is about $72. You pack and ship both orders. The channel where you keep the full margin and the customer's email address is the one with the worst deal.
First action
Pull the last 12 months of orders: average shipping charged, share of orders over $150, and the number of returns and restocking fees actually collected.
How to measure it
Online store conversion rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- +20%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Pull the numbers
Shipping charged per order, order values, returns received and restocking fees collected in the last 12 months.
Owner 1 day
Compare channel margins
Net margin on a $150 tray sold on Nordstrom (fee, free shipping, 90-day returns) against the same tray on the store with free shipping.
Owner 1 day
Set the new terms
A return window of at least 30 days, no consumer restocking fee, one start date, and a free-shipping threshold.
Owner 2 days
Rewrite the policy pages
Plain sentences on the Shipping and Returns page and the refund policy; remove the capitalised warnings.
Customer Service Lead 1 day
Show the terms where people decide
Announcement bar, product page beside add to cart, and a cart progress message toward free shipping.
E-commerce Manager 2 days
Set the shipping rule
Create the free-shipping rate in Shopify for the contiguous US; keep wholesale orders on their own rates.
E-commerce Manager 1 hour
Measure for 60 days
Conversion, average order value, shipping cost and return rate against the same period before.
Owner 60 days
Why it works
Bring the store to parity in two moves. First, returns: replace the 10-day, no-exceptions wording with a 30-day window (or match 90), drop the restocking fee for consumer orders and keep it only for wholesale, and state one clear start date. Second, shipping: test free shipping over a threshold just above the median product price (for example $150), and show the rule in the announcement bar, on every product page and in the cart. Rewrite the Shipping and Returns page in plain sentences and put a three-line summary beside the add-to-cart button. Measure conversion and return rate for 60 days against the previous period.
A shopper comparing the same tray in two tabs chooses the safer deal. You already absorb free shipping and 90-day returns on marketplace orders, usually with a marketplace commission on top, so matching those terms on your own store costs less per order than losing the sale to the marketplace. Kouboo, which sells similar Burmese rattan, already leads its homepage with free shipping.
Ready to use
ChecklistTerms parity checklist
[ ] Return window of 30 days or more, counted from delivery [ ] No restocking fee on consumer orders [ ] Free shipping over a stated threshold, shown in the announcement bar [ ] Three-line shipping and returns summary on every product page [ ] Cart message: "$X away from free shipping" [ ] Shipping and Returns page and refund policy say the same thing [ ] Wholesale terms kept separate [ ] Conversion, order value and return rate tracked for 60 days
Risks and how to handle them
Free shipping on bulky hampers and chests erodes margin
Set the threshold above the median price and exclude oversized items or add a flat surcharge for them.
A longer window raises returns
Keep the new-condition rule, and track return rate monthly; marketplace orders already run on 90 days.
Evidence
- Marketplace listingNordstrom listings for the Inna Design Round Tray ($119.60 to $149.50) and the Inna Rattan Rectangular Tray with Glass Insert ($149.50 to $216.20) are "sold and shipped by Artifacts Trading Company", state "Free shipping—all the time", accept returns by mail or in a Nordstrom store within 90 days, and both show "No reviews yet".Source
- Your websiteShipping and returns pages (read November 16, 2026): orders ship by USPS, UPS or FedEx with costs shown at checkout and no free-shipping threshold stated; in-stock items usually ship within 1 to 2 days. Returns must come back within 10 days, "NO EXCEPTIONS!"; the customer pays return shipping unless the item is wrong or defective; orders of $300 or more carry a 15% restocking fee; the wording leaves it unclear whether the 10 days start at purchase or at receipt.Source
- Site researchCatalogue scan (November 16, 2026): 146 products on Shopify priced from $16.10 to $499.10, median $116.15; examples include the Inna Design Rectangular Tray with Glass Insert from $149.50, the Round Flat Tray with Glass Insert from $117.30, the Marble Rolling Pin at $41.40 and the Inna Design Rectangular Hamper with Hinged Lid at $483; checkout offers Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal; no live chat, no testimonials and no installment option were detected; the apps found were Wholesale Gorilla and Mailchimp.Source
- Competitor researchRivals' own homepages: Kouboo, "Family Owned online store since 2008", promises "Free shipping, that takes 2-5 days for most items" and shows "Excellent" with "738 reviews on Judge.me" plus a Trade Sales page; Memoire Design (formerly Mainly Baskets Home) says "Designed With the Trade in Mind" with "Preferred Pricing", "Personalized Support" and "Custom Possibilities"; Pigeon & Poodle sells wholesale by account application, runs a Hospitality program and states "90% Of Items In Stock Ready to Ship".Source