The homepage is where a DTC founder decides whether to keep reading. In the page as served, it shows “0%” average client growth, “0x” CTR improvement, “0K+” CRO resolutions and “0+” years of expertise. Visitors who scroll down may see the counters animate, but search engines, AI assistants, link previews and anyone who stops early read zeros. The page text also names no client and no result. The Success Stories library, meanwhile, holds 44 write-ups with hard numbers: The Mixologer, revenue up 132.6% to $3.28 million; KeraFactor, conversion from 1.44% to 3.08%; Bully Sticks Direct, cost per conversion down 71%.
First action
Pick the six strongest figures from the stories and confirm each one with the client team.
How to measure it
Homepage → /contact click-through
- Now
- –
- Target
- +25%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Audit the counters
Record what each counter shows with JavaScript off and what it animates to, and note which figures have a source.
Web Developer 2 hours
Choose the proof
Six results across CRO, retention, paid media and replatforming, for example The Mixologer, KeraFactor, Bully Sticks Direct and Metal FX Offroad.
Founder & CEO 1 day
Clear the names
Confirm each client is happy to be named on the homepage.
Client Success Manager 3 days
Write the strip
Client, service, before → after, timeframe and a link for each result.
Content Lead 1 day
Build it static
Real numbers in the HTML. Animation can sit on top but should never start from zero.
Web Developer 1 day
Link the library
A “See all 44 success stories” link under the strip.
Web Developer 1 hour
Measure
GA4 clicks from the homepage to /contact and to the stories, before and after.
Head of Growth monthly
Why it works
Put the real figures into the page HTML instead of counting up from zero, and link each figure to the story it comes from. Replace the generic captions (“Our designs engage millions globally”) with a strip of four to six named results, each giving the client, the service, the before and after number, the timeframe and a link to the story. Use only figures you can source. Drop any counter you can't define in one sentence, or define it.
Agency buyers make their shortlist on proof, and specific, named, dated numbers beat round claims. With the numbers in the served HTML, Google snippets, AI answers and shared links carry the proof too. The numbers already exist, so this is a layout change, not new work.
Ready to use
CopyHomepage result strip (draft)
The Mixologer: revenue +132.6% to $3.28M in six months after a Shopify rebuild → read the story KeraFactor: conversion 1.44% → 3.08% inside a year → read the story Bully Sticks Direct: paid search cost per conversion −71% → read the story Metal FX Offroad: $224,000 in sales on $7,039 of spend → read the story English Factory: $351,000 of net new revenue from Nosto recommendations → read the story [See all 44 success stories]
Risks and how to handle them
A client declines to be named
Describe them by category (“a premium cocktail-kit brand”) and keep the number.
Hand-picked results look too good
Show the baseline and the timeframe for each one.
Evidence
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 19, 2026): H1 “Atelier represents the path to profitability in a rapidly evolving world”. In the page as served, the four stat counters read “0x” Average CTR Improvement, “0K+” Autonomous CRO Resolutions, “0%” Average client growth YOY and “0+” Years of expertise. The page text names no client, shows no client result and has no client testimonial (the only quote is the founder’s), and every CTA (“Let’s talk”, “Schedule a consultation”, “Contact us”) goes to /contact.Source
- Your websiteSuccess Stories page: 44 stories, no filters by service or industry, one “Contact us” CTA. Results include The Mixologer “revenue climbed 132.6% to $3.28 million”, KeraFactor conversion “from 1.44% to 3.08%”, Metal FX Offroad “$224,000 on $7,039 of spend”, Bully Sticks Direct “Cost per conversion down 71%”, Alicia Adams Alpaca ROAS “from roughly 1.85 times to 4.15 times” and “One Lifecycle Program Where Three Agencies Used to Be” (“revenue rose 78 percent” in 90 days), English Factory “$351,000 of net new revenue” and UTV Source “site wide session conversion lifted 332%”.Source
- Your websiteThe Mixologer story (Shopify rebuild, six months before versus six months after): load time from 19.3 seconds to under 2 seconds and PageSpeed grade F to A; conversion 2.49% to 3.39%; revenue up 132.6% to $3,277,614; returning-customer revenue up 149% to $891,993. The only quote is from Atelier’s founder, not from the client.Source
- Your websiteKeraFactor story: conversion rate from 1.44% to 3.08% “inside a year”, orders up 176%, revenue up 78%, plus a Shopify Plus B2B wholesale storefront built from scratch and an ongoing CRO retainer. No one from KeraFactor is quoted.Source