ProgrammableMarketing/drinkiconic.com (opens in a new tab)
PDF

Views

  • Plan
  • Roadmap
  • Research

On this page

  • The brief
  • Start here
  • Idea portfolio
  • Effort vs impact
  • This week · 6
  • This quarter · 11
  • Big bets · 3
  • Wildcards · 3
  • How we can help
Generated Oct 21, 2026
  1. Programmable
  2. Playbooks
  3. ICONIC Protein
ICONIC Protein logo

growth playbook · Oct 21, 2026

drinkiconic.com (opens in a new tab)

ICONIC Protein growth playbook

Diagnosis

ICONIC has a loyal base (8,534 reviews averaging close to five stars), a clean grass-fed product and a new creatine line, and its store passes Core Web Vitals for real visitors.

The gaps are in the offer and the details: the Sample Pack meant for first-timers costs more than a regular 12-pack, an old locator still sends shoppers to grocery stores ICONIC left in 2023, the creatine landing page carries caffeine copy from a retired coffee product, and email is unauthenticated. This playbook fixes the trial offer and those pages first, then builds a creatine stack, a GLP-1 page, price clarity for loyal subscribers, Buy with Prime and professional referrals.

Growth Score

6/10

Biggest Opportunity

Make trying ICONIC cheap and easy, then move first-time buyers into a subscription and a protein-plus-creatine routine, especially for people eating less.

Biggest Risk

Premier Protein, fairlife Core Power and Slate sell protein shakes at lower prices in every grocery store, and loyal customers are already noticing the price per bottle.

01

Start here

The three moves to make first. Each one is written up in full below.

  1. 1

    Make the Sample Pack the cheapest way to try ICONIC, not the most expensive

    Change the Sample Pack price and add a free-shipping rule for first-time Sample Pack orders.

    High impact First result in 2 weeks
  2. 2

    Retire the store locator that still lists Whole Foods, Kroger and Walmart

    Redirect /pages/store-locator-2 to /pages/store-locator-1.

    Medium impact First result in 2 weeks
  3. 3

    Rewrite the creatine landing page that still carries the Immunity Coffee copy

    Delete the caffeine, MCT and weight-loss blocks from /pages/creatine.

    Medium impact First result in 1 week

02

Your idea portfolio

23 ideas, grouped by when to run them. Open any idea for how to run it: the steps, who to approach, copy you can use, and how to measure it.

  • 7 ideas are marked Unexpected: plays you are unlikely to have tried.

Every idea placed by the effort it takes against the impact it could have. Quick wins sit top left; select a number to open that idea. The filters below narrow the list by status, timing, category and what Programmable can build.

Effort vs impactEach number is an idea. Select one to open it.
Impact →
Quick wins · 2Big bets · 7Fill-ins · 9Reconsider · 5
Effort →

Showing 23 of 23 ideas

This week 6

Quick wins with a clear first action.

  • 01

    The homepage features the Sample Pack for shoppers with "commitment issues", but at $53.99 for 12 bottles it costs $4 more than any single-flavor 12-pack ($49.99). It also sits under the $100 free-shipping line, so a first-time buyer pays $59.98 with $5.99 shipping, while a loyal customer buying 36 bottles pays $3.89 a bottle and ships free.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks E commerce Manager

    First action

    Change the Sample Pack price and add a free-shipping rule for first-time Sample Pack orders.

    How to measure it

    Sample Pack buyers who subscribe within 30 days

    Now
    –
    Target
    25%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check the margin

      Landed cost of a mixed 12-pack with Amazon fulfillment at the new price.

      Founder 1 day

    2. 2

      Set the price

      Sample Pack at or below $49.99, per-bottle price on the card.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Free first shipping

      Shipping rule or discount for first-time Sample Pack orders.

      E-commerce Manager 2 hours

    4. 4

      Build the flavor email

      Day 5: "Which flavor won?" with four one-click answers.

      Email & Retention Marketer 2 days

    5. 5

      Pre-fill the cart

      Each answer opens a 24-pack subscription of that flavor at 20% off.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    6. 6

      Add a reminder

      Day 12 follow-up for non-clickers with the most-loved flavor.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 day

    7. 7

      Measure

      Sample Pack conversion, repeat rate and subscription starts against last quarter.

      Growth Marketer weekly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    Margin on the first order
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Run the new price for two weeks and compare Sample Pack conversion with the previous two weeks.

    Why it works

    Price the Sample Pack at or below a single-flavor 12-pack (for example $47.99) and ship the first Sample Pack free. Show the per-bottle price on the card. Then follow up: a Klaviyo email on day 5 asks which flavor won and offers that flavor as a 24-pack subscription with the existing 20% first-order discount, linked straight to a pre-filled cart.

    A trial offer only works if it feels like the low-risk choice. Removing the $4 premium and the shipping fee lowers the cost of a first try to under $50, and the flavor-pick email turns a one-off sampler into the subscription where the margin is.

    Ready to use

    ChecklistSample Pack trial setup

    [ ] Sample Pack price at or below a single-flavor 12-pack
    [ ] Per-bottle price on the card and product page
    [ ] Free shipping on first Sample Pack orders
    [ ] Day 5 "Which flavor won?" email with four buttons
    [ ] Each button opens a pre-filled 24-pack subscription at 20% off
    [ ] Day 12 reminder for non-clickers
    [ ] Track sample-to-subscription rate weekly

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Lower first-order margin

      Judge on 90-day value per Sample Pack buyer, not first-order profit.

    • Repeat buyers use the trial price

      Limit free shipping and the trial price to first orders.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
    • Your websiteShipping policy: "fast, flat rate ($5.99) shipping, with FREE shipping offered on orders over $100." "Orders are fulfilled by Amazon" and "may be delivered in Amazon-branded packaging." "We do not ship internationally."Source
    • Your websiteProduct pages offer "Subscribe & Save 20% Off Your First Order", "10% off all subsequent subscriptions", delivery every 15, 30, 45 or 60 days, flavor swaps and "Cancel at any time". The creatine page shows a cost per serving ($0.37 one-time, $0.33 subscribed); drink and powder pages do not.Source
  • 02

    ICONIC left retail in 2023, and one locator page says so. A second locator page is still live and tells shoppers to look for ICONIC at Sprouts, H-E-B, Walmart, Kroger, Wegmans and Whole Foods "Nationwide". A shopper who finds it goes to a store, comes back empty-handed and may not return.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks E commerce Manager

    First action

    Redirect /pages/store-locator-2 to /pages/store-locator-1.

    How to measure it

    Locator-to-order rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    5%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick one page

      Keep one "Where to buy" URL.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    2. 2

      Rewrite it

      Online only, shipped by Amazon fulfillment, delivery times.

      E-commerce Manager 2 hours

    3. 3

      Add an offer

      Link the Sample Pack trial.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    4. 4

      Redirect

      Both locator URLs to the new page.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    5. 5

      Update the sitemap

      Drop the retired page.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Check search

      Search Console queries with store names.

      Growth Marketer 2 weeks

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Redirect the old page today and watch locator traffic for two weeks.

    Why it works

    Redirect both locator pages to one "Where to buy" page that says ICONIC is sold online and shipped fast by Amazon fulfillment, with a first-order offer. Remove the old page from the sitemap and check any links pointing to it.

    Correcting the page stops sending buyers on wasted trips, and it catches people who search for ICONIC by store name.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Some shoppers want stores

      Explain why online is fresher and cheaper for them.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteTwo store locator pages are live: /pages/store-locator-1 says ICONIC "has made the decision to pull out of our retail partners"; /pages/store-locator-2 still says "Keep an eye out for us in your favorite stores" and lists Sprouts, H-E-B, Walmart, Kroger, Wegman's and Whole Foods as "Nationwide". The FAQ says "In 2023 we made the decision to pull out of retail".Source
    • Your websiteShipping policy: "fast, flat rate ($5.99) shipping, with FREE shipping offered on orders over $100." "Orders are fulfilled by Amazon" and "may be delivered in Amazon-branded packaging." "We do not ship internationally."Source
    • Your websiteSitemap (323 URLs, checked October 20, 2026): 35 pages including /pages/test, /pages/kalumi-collagen-bars and /pages/kalumi-bfcm (a partner's bars ICONIC no longer sells), two Immunity Coffee pages, two store locators, an early-bird opt-in for a "gold launch", /pages/quiz ("Find the right product!") and SMS sign-up pages; 158 blog posts, with three news posts in July 2026 and none between June 2024 and then.Source
  • 03

    The new creatine is the homepage headline, but the /pages/creatine landing page (in the sitemap) still has blocks from the retired Immunity Coffee page: "200mg Caffeine" from Colombian coffee, "Keto Friendly ... MCT oil" and "Keep Your Muscle. Lose The Weight." Creatine is a single unflavored ingredient with no caffeine, so the page contradicts the product.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 week E commerce Manager

    First action

    Delete the caffeine, MCT and weight-loss blocks from /pages/creatine.

    How to measure it

    Creatine page add-to-cart rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    +20%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Audit

      List every block on the creatine and coffee pages.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    2. 2

      Remove

      Caffeine, MCT and weight-loss blocks.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Replace

      Product story and FAQ from the product page.

      Content Creator 2 hours

    4. 4

      Redirect

      Immunity Coffee pages to the right product.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    5. 5

      Check ads

      Any ads or emails linking to the old pages.

      Growth Marketer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      Add-to-cart rate on the landing page.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Fix the page copy today.

    Why it works

    Replace the old blocks with the creatine product story (one ingredient, 5g a day, third-party tested, stacks with protein) and the creatine FAQ, or redirect the page to the product page. Redirect the Immunity Coffee pages to creatine or to a coffee-flavored drink.

    A launch page that mentions caffeine on a caffeine-free product undermines trust at the moment a buyer is deciding, and it can attract the wrong searches.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Ads pointing to old URLs

      Keep redirects in place permanently.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteThe landing page /pages/creatine (listed in the sitemap) opens with creatine but keeps blocks from the old Immunity Coffee page: "200mg Caffeine ... sourced from Fair Trade Colombian Coffee beans", "Keto Friendly ... MCT oil" and "Keep Your Muscle. Lose The Weight." /pages/immunity-coffee now shows the same creatine content under the title "Immunity Coffee".Source
    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
  • 04

    The homepage best-seller row shows "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" and then "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" with no format, because the drinks and powders share names. A shopper sees two prices for the same name and has to click to learn one is a 12-pack and the other a half-pound bag.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 week Shopify Developer

    First action

    Rename the powder products and add a size line on cards.

    How to measure it

    Card click-through to the right product

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      List names

      All drink and powder titles.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    2. 2

      Rename

      Format and size in each title.

      E-commerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Add per-serving price

      On cards and product pages.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    4. 4

      Check feeds

      Google and Meta product feeds use the new titles.

      Growth Marketer 2 hours

    5. 5

      Check emails

      Klaviyo product blocks.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      Support tickets about wrong format.

      Customer Experience Lead monthly

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Shopify Developer

    Smallest test

    Rename the two powders on the homepage first.

    Why it works

    Add the format and size to every card and title ("Chocolate Truffle Protein Drink, 12 bottles", "Chocolate Truffle Protein Powder, 0.5 lb") and show the per-serving price, as the creatine page already does.

    Clear labels stop accidental orders and make price comparisons easy, which matters when buyers already watch the price per bottle.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Ad feed disruption

      Update titles in a quiet week and watch spend.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
    • Your websiteProduct pages offer "Subscribe & Save 20% Off Your First Order", "10% off all subsequent subscriptions", delivery every 15, 30, 45 or 60 days, flavor swaps and "Cancel at any time". The creatine page shows a cost per serving ($0.37 one-time, $0.33 subscribed); drink and powder pages do not.Source
    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
  • 05

    Email is ICONIC's main channel after leaving retail ("our emails only contain the good stuff"), and the Klaviyo side is already set up on a branded sending subdomain. The gap is the main domain: drinkiconic.com, used for Google Workspace mail such as customer-service replies, publishes no SPF record and no Google DKIM key, and DMARC is "p=none" with nowhere to send reports, so ICONIC cannot see who sends mail in its name. Gmail and Yahoo expect senders to authenticate, and unauthenticated replies to customers are more likely to land in spam.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Email & Retention Marketer

    First action

    Add the Google Workspace SPF record.

    How to measure it

    Legitimate mail passing DMARC

    Now
    –
    Target
    100%
    By
    30 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check records

      Current SPF, DKIM and DMARC.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    2. 2

      Add SPF

      Google Workspace on the main domain.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    3. 3

      Add DKIM

      Google Workspace signing key.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    4. 4

      Collect reports

      DMARC reports for two weeks.

      Shopify Developer 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Tighten

      Move DMARC to quarantine.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      Open rates and spam placement.

      Email & Retention Marketer weekly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Email & Retention Marketer

    Smallest test

    Add the SPF record and a DMARC reporting address this week.

    Why it works

    Add an SPF record for Google Workspace on drinkiconic.com, turn on DKIM signing in the Google Workspace admin console, add a reporting address to DMARC and read the reports for two weeks, then move to quarantine once every legitimate sender passes. Check placement with a seed test.

    Every customer conversation in this playbook depends on emails arriving; authentication is the cheapest deliverability fix there is, and the reports show any tool sending mail that was missed.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Blocking real mail

      Review DMARC reports before tightening.

    Evidence

    • Site checkUpkeep and email checks: 7 homepage images have no alt text and one homepage link (a Yahoo article) returns 404. The domain sends mail through Google Workspace and Klaviyo, checked October 20, 2026: Klaviyo already sends from a branded subdomain (send.drinkiconic.com) with its own SPF and DKIM, but drinkiconic.com itself, whose mail goes through Google Workspace, publishes no SPF record and no Google DKIM key under the default selector, and DMARC is "p=none" with no reporting address.Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
  • 06

    Google's test names the LoyaltyLion notice ("Did you know you can earn points...") as the element that shifts the homepage layout, and the LoyaltyLion script adds 338 KB. The rewards program matters, but a shifting notice on the first screen interrupts the Sample Pack offer.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Shopify Developer

    First action

    Delay the LoyaltyLion script until after the first interaction.

    How to measure it

    First-visit add-to-cart rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    +5%
    By
    30 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check settings

      LoyaltyLion display rules.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    2. 2

      Limit audience

      Returning and signed-in customers.

      Shopify Developer 2 hours

    3. 3

      Delay the script

      Load after interaction.

      Shopify Developer 2 hours

    4. 4

      Add to cart page

      Points earned on this order.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    5. 5

      Retest

      PageSpeed layout shift.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      First-visit add-to-cart.

      Growth Marketer weekly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Shopify Developer

    Smallest test

    Turn off the notice for new visitors for a week.

    Why it works

    Show the rewards notice only to signed-in or returning customers, load the script after the page settles, and put points in the cart and account pages where they influence the order.

    Points motivate repeat buyers, not first-time visitors; moving them protects first-visit conversion without losing loyalty.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Fewer rewards sign-ups

      Ask after the first order instead.

    Evidence

    • Google PageSpeedMobile lab test of the homepage: performance 35, main content after 18.3s (target 2.5s), 1,003ms of blocking time, 6 MB over 373 requests and 25 third-party services (Google Tag Manager alone 530 KB and 836ms of blocking). Real visitors still pass Core Web Vitals (Chrome UX Report: LCP 1.7s, INP 163ms, CLS 0.06). Biggest fixes: unused JavaScript (about 1.7s, 890 KB) and image delivery (1 MB). The layout-shift element is the LoyaltyLion notice "Did you know you can earn points for signing up...".Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source

This quarter 11

The core plays for the next three months.

  • 07

    ICONIC launched creatine and says it "stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", but creatine has one review and no bundle. A reviewer already adds "my 5g of creatine" to every Vanilla Bean shake, which is the stack ICONIC describes.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 month E commerce Manager

    First action

    Build the stack bundle with existing products.

    How to measure it

    Orders with creatine

    Now
    –
    Target
    15%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Price the stack

      Bundle saving that protects margin.

      Founder 1 day

    2. 2

      Build bundles

      Drink stack and powder stack.

      E-commerce Manager 2 days

    3. 3

      Cart add-on

      One-click creatine in cart.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Subscription add-on

      Add creatine to existing subscriptions.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    5. 5

      Email subscribers

      The stack story.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    6. 6

      Collect reviews

      Ask first 100 creatine buyers.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 month

    7. 7

      Measure

      Attach rate and order value.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time only
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Email subscribers a creatine add-on offer.

    Why it works

    Create a stack bundle (24 drinks or 2 lb powder plus 1 lb creatine) at a small saving, offer creatine as a one-click add-on in the cart and on subscriptions, and ask the first 100 creatine buyers for reviews.

    Adding a low-cost, daily item to an existing subscription raises order value without a new customer, and reviews remove the "one review" doubt.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Discounting creatine buyers who would pay full price

      Keep the stack saving small.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
    • Your websiteBundles page: 11 bundles; the six two-flavor 24-bottle bundles cost $95.99 against $99.98 (4% off) and have between 0 and 4 reviews each; the Best Sellers Bundle is $139.99 (was $149.97) and the Ultimate Bundle $169.99 (was $199.96).Source
  • 08

    Customers are already buying ICONIC for this: a Cacao + Greens reviewer calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", and the creatine page argues for preserving muscle "in the GLP-1 era". ICONIC has 20g of protein, zero sugar and 140 calories per bottle.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Growth Marketer

    First action

    Collect five customer stories about eating less.

    How to measure it

    GLP-1 page orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    300 a month
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Gather stories

      Five customers with permission.

      Customer Experience Lead 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Write the page

      Nutrition facts and serving tips.

      Content Creator 1 week

    3. 3

      Review wording

      No disease or drug claims.

      Founder 2 days

    4. 4

      Build a bundle

      Starter pack and creatine.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      Run ads

      Search and social.

      Growth Marketer 1 month

    6. 6

      Add an email flow

      Two-week starter tips.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    7. 7

      Measure

      Orders and repeat rate.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Ad test budget
    Owner
    Growth Marketer

    Smallest test

    Launch the page with one ad set.

    Why it works

    Build one page for people on GLP-1 medication or eating less: why protein and muscle matter, how to fit 20g in when appetite is low, a starter bundle, and customer stories. Keep the wording to nutrition facts, not medical claims, and run search and social ads to it.

    This is one of the fastest-growing groups looking for protein drinks, and they need small, easy servings like ICONIC's.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Health claims

      Stick to nutrition facts and customer quotes.

    Evidence

    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
  • 09

    A long-time customer reviewed that the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about $125 a month) as bottles got smaller, and left. A 36-pack on subscription already costs much less per bottle, but the store never shows the per-bottle price for drinks.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Email & Retention Marketer

    First action

    Add per-bottle prices to the drink product pages.

    How to measure it

    Monthly subscriber churn

    Now
    –
    Target
    -20%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Calculate

      Per-bottle prices by size and plan.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Show them

      On product pages and cart.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    3. 3

      Find heavy buyers

      Customers buying 12-packs often.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 day

    4. 4

      Email them

      Their best price.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    5. 5

      Cancel flow

      Offers in Recharge before cancel.

      Email & Retention Marketer 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Churn and saves.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Discount on saved subscriptions
    Owner
    Email & Retention Marketer

    Smallest test

    Email 100 frequent 12-pack buyers about the 36-pack subscription.

    Why it works

    Show per-bottle prices on every size and plan, email heavy buyers a "your best price" note with the 36-pack subscription, and add a cancel flow that offers a larger pack, a skip or a flavor swap before cancelling.

    Many cancellations are about price per use; showing the cheapest path keeps the customer and the order size grows.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Margin loss

      Offer larger packs, not deeper discounts.

    Evidence

    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
    • Your websiteProduct pages offer "Subscribe & Save 20% Off Your First Order", "10% off all subsequent subscriptions", delivery every 15, 30, 45 or 60 days, flavor swaps and "Cancel at any time". The creatine page shows a cost per serving ($0.37 one-time, $0.33 subscribed); drink and powder pages do not.Source
  • 10

    Every ICONIC order is fulfilled by Amazon and may arrive in an Amazon box, and some customers have bought ICONIC on Amazon for years. Amazon's Buy with Prime lets Prime members check out on a brand's own site with Prime delivery when the brand uses Amazon fulfillment.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Founder

    First action

    Check eligibility in Amazon's Buy with Prime program.

    How to measure it

    Product page conversion

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check eligibility

      Program terms and fees.

      Operations Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Install

      The Shopify app.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    3. 3

      Pick products

      Drinks and Sample Pack.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    4. 4

      Test

      A/B or a two-month trial.

      Growth Marketer 2 months

    5. 5

      Compare

      Conversion and returns.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    6. 6

      Decide

      Keep or remove.

      Founder 1 day

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Program fees
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Run Buy with Prime on the Sample Pack for a month.

    Why it works

    Test Buy with Prime on drink and Sample Pack pages, measure conversion for Prime members against the regular checkout, and keep subscriptions on Recharge for retention.

    Prime members trust Prime checkout and delivery, and ICONIC already pays for the fulfillment behind it.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Owning customer data

      Ask for email at checkout and keep subscriptions on site.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping policy: "fast, flat rate ($5.99) shipping, with FREE shipping offered on orders over $100." "Orders are fulfilled by Amazon" and "may be delivered in Amazon-branded packaging." "We do not ship internationally."Source
    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
  • 11

    Real visitors pass Core Web Vitals, but Google's phone test shows a 6 MB page with 25 third-party services, 18 seconds to the main content and 1,003ms of blocking, mostly from Google Tag Manager (836ms). The margin will shrink with every new tag.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Shopify Developer

    First action

    Export the list of Tag Manager tags and owners.

    How to measure it

    Mobile performance score

    Now
    –
    Target
    60+
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      List tags

      Owner and use of each.

      Growth Marketer 1 day

    2. 2

      Remove unused

      Tags no one reads.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    3. 3

      Delay the rest

      Load after interaction.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Compress images

      Hero and product images.

      Shopify Developer 2 days

    5. 5

      Set a budget

      One in, one out.

      Founder 1 hour

    6. 6

      Retest

      PageSpeed and field data.

      Shopify Developer monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Developer time
    Owner
    Shopify Developer

    Smallest test

    Remove three unused tags this week.

    Why it works

    Audit the tags in Tag Manager, remove ones no one reads, delay chat, rewards and social pixels until interaction, compress images (1 MB to save) and set a budget of no new script without removing one.

    Speed headroom protects mobile conversion on paid traffic, where visitors are least patient.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Losing ad tracking

      Move pixels to server-side where needed.

    Evidence

    • Google PageSpeedMobile lab test of the homepage: performance 35, main content after 18.3s (target 2.5s), 1,003ms of blocking time, 6 MB over 373 requests and 25 third-party services (Google Tag Manager alone 530 KB and 836ms of blocking). Real visitors still pass Core Web Vitals (Chrome UX Report: LCP 1.7s, INP 163ms, CLS 0.06). Biggest fixes: unused JavaScript (about 1.7s, 890 KB) and image delivery (1 MB). The layout-shift element is the LoyaltyLion notice "Did you know you can earn points for signing up...".Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
  • 12

    The homepage shows blog posts from 2022 to 2024, and the news blog skipped two years until July 2026. Buyers now ask about protein when eating less, creatine for women and grass-fed versus regular whey, all questions ICONIC's product pages already answer.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Content Creator

    First action

    Pick ten questions from customer emails and reviews.

    How to measure it

    Blog sessions

    Now
    –
    Target
    +50%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      List questions

      From reviews and support.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 week

    2. 2

      Plan

      Two posts a month.

      Content Creator 1 day

    3. 3

      Write

      With product links.

      Content Creator monthly

    4. 4

      Update homepage

      Newest posts.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    5. 5

      Share

      Email and social.

      Email & Retention Marketer monthly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Sessions and orders.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Writing time
    Owner
    Content Creator

    Smallest test

    Publish the creatine-for-women post.

    Why it works

    Publish two posts a month on current questions (GLP-1 and protein, creatine for women, grass-fed milk protein, protein for travel), each linked to a product, and replace the homepage blog row with the newest posts.

    Fresh answers rank and get cited by AI assistants, and dated posts on the homepage make an active brand look quiet.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Thin content

      One useful answer per post.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
    • Your websiteSitemap (323 URLs, checked October 20, 2026): 35 pages including /pages/test, /pages/kalumi-collagen-bars and /pages/kalumi-bfcm (a partner's bars ICONIC no longer sells), two Immunity Coffee pages, two store locators, an early-bird opt-in for a "gold launch", /pages/quiz ("Find the right product!") and SMS sign-up pages; 158 blog posts, with three news posts in July 2026 and none between June 2024 and then.Source
    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
  • 13

    ICONIC runs affiliates through Refersion and has a Wholesale link, but no page invites professionals. Dietitians and trainers recommend protein every day, especially to clients eating less.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Founder

    First action

    List 50 dietitians and trainers who post about protein.

    How to measure it

    Professional-referred orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    200 a month
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Design terms

      Commission and client discount.

      Founder 1 week

    2. 2

      Build the page

      Sign-up and samples.

      E-commerce Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Recruit

      First 50 professionals.

      Growth Marketer 1 month

    4. 4

      Send samples

      Office cases.

      Operations Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Share materials

      Nutrition sheets.

      Content Creator 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Pay and review

      Monthly payouts.

      Founder monthly

    7. 7

      Measure

      Orders per professional.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Samples and commissions
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Invite ten dietitians.

    Why it works

    Create a professional program: a page for dietitians and trainers, a client discount code, a commission through Refersion and a sample case for their office. Start with 50 professionals.

    Professional recommendations carry trust that ads do not, and their clients buy repeatedly.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Low activity

      Keep the 20 most active and recruit more.

    Evidence

    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
  • 14

    ICONIC already has a quiz ("Find the right product!") for people choosing between powder and drinks, but it is not in the main menu. New buyers face 19 products and 11 bundles.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month E commerce Manager

    First action

    Add the quiz to the menu.

    How to measure it

    Quiz-to-order rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    10%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Test the quiz

      Every path works.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Add to menu

      And homepage.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    3. 3

      Update results

      Product plus Sample Pack.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    4. 4

      Sync answers

      To Klaviyo.

      Email & Retention Marketer 2 days

    5. 5

      Follow up

      Emails by answer.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Completions and orders.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Put the quiz in the menu for a month.

    Why it works

    Add "Find your protein" to the menu and homepage, end every quiz result with a recommended product and the Sample Pack, and save the answers in Klaviyo for follow-up emails.

    A guided choice reduces decision fatigue and gives email flows a reason to be personal.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Quiz abandonment

      Keep it to five questions.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteSitemap (323 URLs, checked October 20, 2026): 35 pages including /pages/test, /pages/kalumi-collagen-bars and /pages/kalumi-bfcm (a partner's bars ICONIC no longer sells), two Immunity Coffee pages, two store locators, an early-bird opt-in for a "gold launch", /pages/quiz ("Find the right product!") and SMS sign-up pages; 158 blog posts, with three news posts in July 2026 and none between June 2024 and then.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
    • Your websiteBundles page: 11 bundles; the six two-flavor 24-bottle bundles cost $95.99 against $99.98 (4% off) and have between 0 and 4 reviews each; the Best Sellers Bundle is $139.99 (was $149.97) and the Ultimate Bundle $169.99 (was $199.96).Source
  • 15

    ICONIC has a large recipe library (protein muffins, smoothie bowls, frozen lattes) and TikTok and Meta ad tags already on the site, but the recipes live as blog posts.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Growth Marketer

    First action

    Pick 12 recipes that look good on video.

    How to measure it

    Social cost per first order

    Now
    –
    Target
    -20%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick recipes

      Twelve visual ones.

      Content Creator 1 day

    2. 2

      Film

      Batch shoot.

      Content Creator 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Post

      Three a week.

      Content Creator weekly

    4. 4

      Invite creators

      Credited recipe makers.

      Growth Marketer 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Promote winners

      As ads to the Sample Pack.

      Growth Marketer weekly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Cost per first order.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Production and ad budget
    Owner
    Growth Marketer

    Smallest test

    Film three recipes this month.

    Why it works

    Film 12 recipes as 30-second vertical videos, post three a week, and run the best as ads to the Sample Pack. Invite the creators already credited in recipes to make more.

    Recipes show taste and use, the two things a protein drink buyer worries about, and creators already know the brand.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Low reach

      Use creators with their own audiences.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteSocial links: Instagram, Facebook, X and a YouTube channel (youtube.com/c/ICONICProtein); recipes live under /blogs/recipes (for example protein muffins and smoothie bowls credited to Instagram creators).Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
  • 16

    The six two-flavor bundles (24 bottles) cost $95.99 against $99.98, a 4% saving, the same price as a single-flavor 24-pack, and have between 0 and 4 reviews each. They add choices without adding value.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month E commerce Manager

    First action

    Check sales of each two-flavor bundle over the last year.

    How to measure it

    Bundle page conversion

    Now
    –
    Target
    +15%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pull sales

      Per bundle.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Decide

      Keep, cut or replace.

      Founder 1 day

    3. 3

      Build mix pack

      Choose two or more flavors.

      Shopify Developer 1 week

    4. 4

      Redirect

      Cut bundles to the mix pack.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    5. 5

      Show reviews

      From base products.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    6. 6

      Measure

      Conversion.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Developer time
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Hide the three lowest-selling bundles.

    Why it works

    Cut the six bundles to two or three, or replace them with a "build your 24" mix-and-match pack at the 24-pack price, and move the reviews from the base products onto bundle pages.

    Fewer, clearer choices convert better, and a flexible pack covers every pairing.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Losing bundle search traffic

      Redirect each URL.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteBundles page: 11 bundles; the six two-flavor 24-bottle bundles cost $95.99 against $99.98 (4% off) and have between 0 and 4 reviews each; the Best Sellers Bundle is $139.99 (was $149.97) and the Ultimate Bundle $169.99 (was $199.96).Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
  • 17

    The sitemap lists a /pages/test page, pages for Kalumi collagen bars ICONIC no longer sells, an early-bird opt-in for a past launch and duplicate subscription pages, and the footer still says © 2024. These pages show up in search and AI answers as if they were current.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks E commerce Manager

    First action

    List pages with no traffic in the last 90 days.

    How to measure it

    Retired pages redirected

    Now
    –
    Target
    100%
    By
    1 month

    Steps

    1. 1

      List pages

      All 35.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Decide

      Keep, merge or redirect.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      Redirect

      Retired pages.

      Shopify Developer 1 day

    4. 4

      Remove tests

      Test and opt-in pages.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    5. 5

      Fix footer

      Current year and the broken homepage link.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Check alt text

      Seven images.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    E commerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Redirect the Kalumi pages today.

    Why it works

    Review all 35 pages: redirect retired ones to the closest current product, remove test pages, merge the subscription pages and update the footer year.

    A tidy site keeps search and AI assistants describing ICONIC as it is today.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Breaking old links

      Redirect rather than delete.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteSitemap (323 URLs, checked October 20, 2026): 35 pages including /pages/test, /pages/kalumi-collagen-bars and /pages/kalumi-bfcm (a partner's bars ICONIC no longer sells), two Immunity Coffee pages, two store locators, an early-bird opt-in for a "gold launch", /pages/quiz ("Find the right product!") and SMS sign-up pages; 158 blog posts, with three news posts in July 2026 and none between June 2024 and then.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
    • Site checkUpkeep and email checks: 7 homepage images have no alt text and one homepage link (a Yahoo article) returns 404. The domain sends mail through Google Workspace and Klaviyo, checked October 20, 2026: Klaviyo already sends from a branded subdomain (send.drinkiconic.com) with its own SPF and DKIM, but drinkiconic.com itself, whose mail goes through Google Workspace, publishes no SPF record and no Google DKIM key under the default selector, and DMARC is "p=none" with no reporting address.Source

Big bets 3

Larger plays that can change the trajectory.

  • 18

    ICONIC has every piece of a program for people eating less: a 140-calorie, 20g protein drink, a creatine pitched for muscle "in the GLP-1 era", and customers already using them that way.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 3 quarters Founder

    First action

    Draft the 30-day email plan.

    How to measure it

    Program subscribers

    Now
    –
    Target
    1,000
    By
    3 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Define

      Products and plan.

      Founder 1 month

    2. 2

      Write content

      30 days of emails.

      Content Creator 1 month

    3. 3

      Price

      One subscription.

      Founder 1 week

    4. 4

      Partner

      Dietitians to advise.

      Founder 1 quarter

    5. 5

      Launch

      To the email list.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 month

    6. 6

      Measure

      Retention against regular subscribers.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    3 quarters
    Cost
    Content and partner costs
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Pilot with 50 existing customers.

    Why it works

    Package a monthly program: a drink subscription, creatine, a 30-day email plan with protein targets and recipes, and check-ins. Price it as one subscription, and partner with dietitians to deliver it.

    A program sells an outcome, not bottles, and it keeps customers longer than a single product.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Medical claims

      Nutrition guidance only, reviewed by a dietitian.

    Evidence

    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
    • Your websiteProduct pages offer "Subscribe & Save 20% Off Your First Order", "10% off all subsequent subscriptions", delivery every 15, 30, 45 or 60 days, flavor swaps and "Cancel at any time". The creatine page shows a cost per serving ($0.37 one-time, $0.33 subscribed); drink and powder pages do not.Source
  • 19

    ICONIC left grocery stores to focus on direct sales, but shelf-stable drinks that last 18 months suit office pantries, gyms and studios, and there is a Wholesale link already.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 2 quarters Founder

    First action

    Write a one-page offer for gyms and offices.

    How to measure it

    Active business accounts

    Now
    –
    Target
    100
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Design the offer

      Case pricing and codes.

      Founder 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Build the page

      Business sign-up.

      E-commerce Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Prospect

      Studios and offices.

      Growth Marketer 1 quarter

    4. 4

      Deliver

      Monthly cases.

      Operations Manager monthly

    5. 5

      Track codes

      Members buying direct.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    6. 6

      Review

      Keep or stop.

      Founder 2 quarters

    First result
    2 quarters
    Cost
    Sales time and samples
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Sign five local gyms.

    Why it works

    Offer a monthly case subscription for offices, gyms and studios with a member discount code, starting with local studios and companies with wellness budgets.

    Each location introduces many new drinkers, and the code turns them into direct customers.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Low reorder rates

      Start with gyms where protein is routine.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
    • Your websiteTwo store locator pages are live: /pages/store-locator-1 says ICONIC "has made the decision to pull out of our retail partners"; /pages/store-locator-2 still says "Keep an eye out for us in your favorite stores" and lists Sprouts, H-E-B, Walmart, Kroger, Wegman's and Whole Foods as "Nationwide". The FAQ says "In 2023 we made the decision to pull out of retail".Source
    • Site checkTools on the store: Klaviyo email, Recharge subscriptions, LoyaltyLion rewards (/pages/iconic-rewards), Judge.me reviews, Refersion affiliates, TikTok, Meta and Google ad tags, Microsoft Clarity, Shop Pay and Apple Pay; a Wholesale link in the footer.Source
  • 20

    ICONIC's difference is milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", but competitors such as Premier Protein, fairlife and Slate sell on taste, protein numbers and sugar. No one shows the farm.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 3 quarters Founder

    First action

    Ask the milk protein supplier for access and footage.

    How to measure it

    Product page conversion

    Now
    –
    Target
    +10%
    By
    3 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Get access

      Supplier and farms.

      Founder 1 month

    2. 2

      Film

      Farm and process.

      Content Creator 1 month

    3. 3

      Edit

      Long and short versions.

      Content Creator 1 month

    4. 4

      Publish

      Page and YouTube.

      Content Creator 1 week

    5. 5

      Use in ads

      Short clips.

      Growth Marketer ongoing

    6. 6

      Measure

      Conversion.

      Growth Marketer monthly

    First result
    3 quarters
    Cost
    Production budget
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Publish supplier photos on a sourcing page.

    Why it works

    Produce a short documentary and a page: the farms, the filtration, the 99.99% lactose-free process and third-party testing, with clips for social and ads.

    A visible origin story supports the premium price and is hard for mass-market brands to copy.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Cost

      Use supplier footage first.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
    • Competitor researchRivals' own homepages: Premier Protein, shakes that "taste like your favorite desserts"; fairlife, ultra-filtered milk "with 50% more protein and 50% less sugar" and Core Power shakes; Slate, "high protein, lower sugar, lactose free shakes and iced coffees".Source
    • Your websiteSocial links: Instagram, Facebook, X and a YouTube channel (youtube.com/c/ICONICProtein); recipes live under /blogs/recipes (for example protein muffins and smoothie bowls credited to Instagram creators).Source

Wildcards 3

Unexpected experiments, each with a cheap way to test it.

  • 21

    ICONIC still has Immunity Coffee pages and sign-up pages for it, and Café Latte (100mg of caffeine) is a best seller. Coffee is the daily habit protein shakes compete with.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 2 quarters Founder

    First action

    Ask subscribers which coffee flavor they want.

    How to measure it

    Pre-orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    1,000 cases
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Survey

      Flavor preferences.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    2. 2

      Price

      Small run costs.

      Founder 1 month

    3. 3

      Announce

      Email and SMS.

      Email & Retention Marketer 1 week

    4. 4

      Take pre-orders

      Two weeks.

      E-commerce Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Decide

      Produce or refund.

      Founder 1 day

    6. 6

      Review

      Keep as a regular flavor.

      Founder 1 quarter

    First result
    2 quarters
    Cost
    Small production run
    Owner
    Founder

    Smallest test

    Send the flavor survey.

    Why it works

    Run a limited-edition coffee flavor (for example a mocha), announced only to email and SMS subscribers with a pre-order, and keep it if pre-orders pass a set number.

    Limited drops grow the list, reward subscribers and test demand before a full launch.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Minimum order sizes

      Use pre-orders to fund the run.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteThe landing page /pages/creatine (listed in the sitemap) opens with creatine but keeps blocks from the old Immunity Coffee page: "200mg Caffeine ... sourced from Fair Trade Colombian Coffee beans", "Keto Friendly ... MCT oil" and "Keep Your Muscle. Lose The Weight." /pages/immunity-coffee now shows the same creatine content under the title "Immunity Coffee".Source
    • Your websiteSitemap (323 URLs, checked October 20, 2026): 35 pages including /pages/test, /pages/kalumi-collagen-bars and /pages/kalumi-bfcm (a partner's bars ICONIC no longer sells), two Immunity Coffee pages, two store locators, an early-bird opt-in for a "gold launch", /pages/quiz ("Find the right product!") and SMS sign-up pages; 158 blog posts, with three news posts in July 2026 and none between June 2024 and then.Source
    • Your websiteProduct promise: 20g of grass-fed milk protein from cows "raised on pasture in the rolling hills of Ireland", 0g sugar (monk fruit and stevia), 140 calories, 99.99% lactose-free, Non-GMO Project Verified and kosher; Café Latte carries 100mg of caffeine from Colombian coffee and Cacao + Greens a serving of organic greens. Drinks are shelf-stable for 18 months. The homepage quotes Forbes: "pack ICONIC Protein Drinks instead."Source
  • 22

    The creatine page calls ICONIC "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews", while the reviews page shows 8,534. Shoppers who compare may doubt both.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Customer Experience Lead

    First action

    Count reviews by source.

    How to measure it

    Pages using the agreed number

    Now
    –
    Target
    100%
    By
    1 month

    Steps

    1. 1

      Count

      Site and Amazon reviews.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 day

    2. 2

      Agree

      One number and source.

      Founder 1 hour

    3. 3

      Update

      Product pages.

      E-commerce Manager 1 day

    4. 4

      Update ads

      And emails.

      Growth Marketer 1 day

    5. 5

      Add to homepage

      Near the Sample Pack.

      Shopify Developer 1 hour

    6. 6

      Review

      Quarterly.

      Customer Experience Lead quarterly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Customer Experience Lead

    Smallest test

    Fix the creatine page line.

    Why it works

    Count reviews across the site and Amazon, pick one honest number with its source ("8,500+ reviews on drinkiconic.com"), and use it on the homepage, product pages and ads.

    Consistent proof is more convincing than a bigger number.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Smaller number

      Show the star rating with it.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCreatine product page: micronized creatine monohydrate, "One ingredient. 90 servings", "4 Based on 1 review". It argues that "In the GLP-1 era, it's essential for maintaining muscle mass", answers "Is creatine safe for women?", says "ICONIC Creatine stacks seamlessly with ICONIC Protein", and describes the brand as "the brand behind 25,000+ protein reviews".Source
    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
  • 23

    Powder reviews mention that the powder is "so fine and powdery" it makes a mess, and that some buyers dislike the new canister. These are small frustrations that cost repeat orders.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 quarter Customer Experience Lead

    First action

    Write the mixing guide.

    How to measure it

    Powder rating

    Now
    –
    Target
    4.8
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Read reviews

      Powder complaints.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 day

    2. 2

      Write the guide

      Mixing tips.

      Content Creator 1 day

    3. 3

      Add to page

      And the insert.

      E-commerce Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Test packaging

      Scoop or pouch.

      Operations Manager 1 quarter

    5. 5

      Contact reviewers

      Share the guide.

      Customer Experience Lead 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Measure

      Ratings.

      Customer Experience Lead monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Packaging test
    Owner
    Customer Experience Lead

    Smallest test

    Add the guide to the product page.

    Why it works

    Add a short mixing guide (liquid first, shaker, blender) to the package insert and product page, test a fitted scoop or a pouch option, and ask unhappy powder reviewers to try the guide.

    Fixing the use experience improves reviews and repeat purchases more cheaply than discounts.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Packaging costs

      Test small first.

    Evidence

    • Customer reviewsReviews page: "Based on 8534 reviews", 7,932 of them five stars. Recent reviews include a Cacao + Greens buyer who calls it "Great protein boost for my GLP-1 reduced appetite", a Vanilla Bean buyer who adds "my 5g of creatine" to each shake, a long-time customer who says the price reached "$4.11 a bottle" (about "$125 a month") as bottles got smaller, and powder buyers who find the powder messy or dislike the new canister.Source
    • Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source

03

How Programmable can help

Where an idea in this playbook is something Programmable builds or runs, it's listed here with what we'd do. Everything else is yours to run.

ProgrammableDigital

Show it, don't just describe it

These ideas need something to show: a demo, a video, an animation, graphics or a deck. Digital turns screenshots or the site into all of them, in the company's own brand.

Make a demo (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
More example playbooks and reviews

More growth playbooks

Other companies we have researched, each read from what they are hiring for.

  • XPENG growth strategyDesigns and sells smart electric vehicles (SUVs, sedans and MPVs) with driver assistance, an intelligent cockpit and over-the-air updates…21 growth ideas
  • Bazillion Dreams growth strategyAn online shop for officially licensed fan merchandise, now led by its own Bazillion Dreams line of licensed fleece throw blankets…20 growth ideas
  • Kombo growth strategyA unified API for HR, payroll, recruiting, learning and assessment systems: HR-tech, benefits and spend companies integrate once and…23 growth ideas
  • HomeLight growth strategyA real estate platform that matches buyers and sellers with top agents and adds services to the move: Buy Before You Sell equity unlocks…21 growth ideas
  • Pediatrics Plus growth strategyA specialized pediatric healthcare provider offering physical, occupational and speech therapy, applied behavior analysis, early…22 growth ideas
  • EMBR growth strategyAn online store for durable, affordable wedding bands in tungsten, ceramic, Damascus steel, titanium and silicone, with matching couples…21 growth ideas
  • Cambly growth strategyAn online English learning platform connecting learners with native-speaking tutors for one-on-one and small-group conversation, with…21 growth ideas
  • Our Kids growth strategyA family-owned online store (OurKidsASD.com) selling professional and specialist supplements and skin care from brands such as Pure…21 growth ideas

See every playbook and website review

Independent research. Programmable wrote this playbook from public sources, as they stood on October 21, 2026, and cites them throughout. ICONIC Protein did not commission, review or endorse it, and Programmable is not affiliated with ICONIC Protein. Company and product names are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. The ideas are suggestions and opinion, not professional, legal or financial advice, and not statements about how ICONIC Protein runs its business.

Something wrong, or do you represent ICONIC Protein? Email [email protected] and we will correct it or take it down.

30/60/90 roadmap

What to focus on in each month, and the ideas that carry it.

  1. Days 1 to 307 ideas

    Sample Pack trial offer, locator cleanup, creatine page copy, clear product names, email authentication, the rewards pop-up and old-page cleanup.

  2. Days 31 to 6013 ideas

    Creatine stack, GLP-1 page, per-bottle pricing, Buy with Prime, script trimming, the blog, professionals, quiz, recipe videos and bundles; one review number and the powder guide.

  3. Days 61 to 903 ideas

    Commit to the small-appetite program, the workplace and gym channel and the farm-to-bottle story.

The research behind the plan

2 research areas, each summarised in a few lines. Open any of them for the full detail.

Customers

What customers say

Customers value taste that is not too sweet. The most cited problem: price per bottle.

  • Easy on the stomach
  • Smaller bottles than before
  • In their words: “clean protein”

Market

Competitive landscape

3 competitors compared: Premier Protein, fairlife Core Power and Slate.

  • Gap to exploit: Protein made for people eating less
  • Premier Protein: Not grass-fed or clean-label led
  • fairlife Core Power: Mass-market brand

From the team that wrote this playbook

All products
  • ProgrammableAgencyWorking AI systems in days, not quarters (opens programmable.agency in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableInfoAn agent that finds, researches and asks firstNew accounts get 100,000 free enrichment credits with code BETA100K (opens programmable.info in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableDigitalScreenshots in, an animated product demo out (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableWatchKnow the day a supplier falls out of compliance (opens programmable.watch in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableTalkGet registrants for your events, and know who’s coming (opens programmable.talk in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableMediaAn AI note taker, interpreter and webinar host for your calls (opens programmable.media in a new tab)
  • ProgrammablePageText what you need, your customer gets a page that works (opens programmable.page in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableCommunityForums with labelled AI members, never empty (opens programmable.community in a new tab)
ProgrammableMarketing
ExamplesLeaderboardsProductsTermsPrivacyCookiesDPALegalContact

© 2026 AI-Powered Growth Intelligence