The homepage features the Sample Pack for shoppers with "commitment issues", but at $53.99 for 12 bottles it costs $4 more than any single-flavor 12-pack ($49.99). It also sits under the $100 free-shipping line, so a first-time buyer pays $59.98 with $5.99 shipping, while a loyal customer buying 36 bottles pays $3.89 a bottle and ships free.
First action
Change the Sample Pack price and add a free-shipping rule for first-time Sample Pack orders.
How to measure it
Sample Pack buyers who subscribe within 30 days
- Now
- –
- Target
- 25%
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Check the margin
Landed cost of a mixed 12-pack with Amazon fulfillment at the new price.
Founder 1 day
Set the price
Sample Pack at or below $49.99, per-bottle price on the card.
E-commerce Manager 1 hour
Free first shipping
Shipping rule or discount for first-time Sample Pack orders.
E-commerce Manager 2 hours
Build the flavor email
Day 5: "Which flavor won?" with four one-click answers.
Email & Retention Marketer 2 days
Pre-fill the cart
Each answer opens a 24-pack subscription of that flavor at 20% off.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Add a reminder
Day 12 follow-up for non-clickers with the most-loved flavor.
Email & Retention Marketer 1 day
Measure
Sample Pack conversion, repeat rate and subscription starts against last quarter.
Growth Marketer weekly
Why it works
Price the Sample Pack at or below a single-flavor 12-pack (for example $47.99) and ship the first Sample Pack free. Show the per-bottle price on the card. Then follow up: a Klaviyo email on day 5 asks which flavor won and offers that flavor as a 24-pack subscription with the existing 20% first-order discount, linked straight to a pre-filled cart.
A trial offer only works if it feels like the low-risk choice. Removing the $4 premium and the shipping fee lowers the cost of a first try to under $50, and the flavor-pick email turns a one-off sampler into the subscription where the margin is.
Ready to use
ChecklistSample Pack trial setup
[ ] Sample Pack price at or below a single-flavor 12-pack [ ] Per-bottle price on the card and product page [ ] Free shipping on first Sample Pack orders [ ] Day 5 "Which flavor won?" email with four buttons [ ] Each button opens a pre-filled 24-pack subscription at 20% off [ ] Day 12 reminder for non-clickers [ ] Track sample-to-subscription rate weekly
Risks and how to handle them
Lower first-order margin
Judge on 90-day value per Sample Pack buyer, not first-order profit.
Repeat buyers use the trial price
Limit free shipping and the trial price to first orders.
Evidence
- Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the featured product is the Sample Pack, "Commitment issues? You're in luck", 12 bottles (3 each of Vanilla Bean, Chocolate Truffle, Café Latte and Cacao + Greens) at $53.99, rated 4.83 from 688 reviews. The banner reads "SUBSCRIBE & SAVE 10% ON EVERY ORDER"; a hero announces "CREATINE IS HERE". The "Shop best sellers" row lists "Chocolate Truffle $49.99" (drinks) next to "Chocolate Truffle $27.99" and "Vanilla Bean $27.99" (half-pound powders) with no format shown. The page H1 is empty, the footer says "© 2024 ICONIC" and the blog row shows posts from 2022 to 2024.Source
- Your websiteCatalogue (19 products): each ready-to-drink flavor costs $49.99 for 12, $95.99 for 24 and $139.99 for 36; the Sample Pack comes only as a 12-pack at $53.99; protein powders run from $27.99 (0.5 lb) to $116.99 (3 lb); creatine from $29.99 (1 lb); 11 bundles from $79.99 to $169.99.Source
- Your websiteShipping policy: "fast, flat rate ($5.99) shipping, with FREE shipping offered on orders over $100." "Orders are fulfilled by Amazon" and "may be delivered in Amazon-branded packaging." "We do not ship internationally."Source
- Your websiteProduct pages offer "Subscribe & Save 20% Off Your First Order", "10% off all subsequent subscriptions", delivery every 15, 30, 45 or 60 days, flavor swaps and "Cancel at any time". The creatine page shows a cost per serving ($0.37 one-time, $0.33 subscribed); drink and powder pages do not.Source