The store banner promises free U.S. shipping on orders of $55 or more, but the "Free Shipping" block on product pages still says $75. Most of the catalogue is small: the median price is $6.99 and 275 of the 277 park stickers cost $3.99. A collector filling their Passport reads $75 on the sticker page and thinks they need 19 stickers, when 14 would do. The shipping page states no threshold at all.
First action
Change the product-page free-shipping text from $75 to $55.
How to measure it
Average order value
- Now
- –
- Target
- +10%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Fix the text
Change the product-page block to $55 so every page matches the banner.
E-commerce Manager (HQ eCommerce) 1 hour
Find every mention
Search the theme, FAQ, emails and ads for $75.
E-commerce Manager (HQ eCommerce) 1 day
Turn on the bar
Free-shipping progress bar in the cart drawer at $55.
E-commerce Manager (HQ eCommerce) 2 days
Add suggestions
Sticker, retro cancellation and stamp set suggestions under the bar.
Merchandise Manager (HQ Merchandise) 3 days
Update the policy
Threshold and rates on the Shipping & Handling page.
E-commerce Manager (HQ eCommerce) 1 hour
Measure
Order value and share of orders above $55, before and after.
E-commerce Manager (HQ eCommerce) weekly
Why it works
Change the product-page block to $55 today (it is one theme setting or snippet). Then show a live free-shipping bar in the cart drawer ("$11.03 to free shipping: that is 3 more park stickers"), with one-click suggestions from the shopper's own parks: missing stickers, the matching Retro Cancellation Sticker, the current stamp set. The store already loads Rebuy, which can drive this bar and the suggestions. Put the $55 threshold and the shipping rates on the Shipping & Handling page.
Shoppers who see one clear threshold and how close they are add items to get there, and Passport buyers already shop in small, repeatable pieces. Two conflicting numbers make the store look careless and push some buyers to stop well short of either.
Ready to use
ChecklistFree-shipping fix list
[ ] Product-page "Free Shipping" block says $55 [ ] No $75 left in theme, FAQ, order emails or ads [ ] Cart bar: "$X to free shipping" [ ] Bar suggests stickers in multiples of $3.99 [ ] Shipping & Handling page shows rates and the $55 threshold [ ] Weekly report: average order value, % of orders over $55
Risks and how to handle them
More orders ship free and margin drops
Track shipping cost per order; the threshold stays at $55 either way.
Suggestions feel pushy
Show three items at most, all from the shopper's own parks.
Evidence
- Your online storeThe banner on every page of the America's National Parks online store says "Free Shipping Just Got Easier: Now on U.S. Orders $55+", but the "Free Shipping" block on product pages (checked on the Acadia NP Passport Sticker, the 2027 Passport Stamp Set and the Passport Explorer Edition, October 20, 2026) still says "Enjoy FREE U.S. Domestic Shipping when you spend $75 or more!"Source
- Your online storeStore catalogue (October 20, 2026): 2,084 products with a median price of $6.99; 1,424 of 2,410 variants cost under $10. 275 of the 277 Passport Single Stickers cost $3.99, so a sticker-only order needs 14 stickers to reach $55 and 19 to reach $75.Source
- Your online storeThe Shipping & Handling page lists Standard U.S. Shipping (5-7 business days), Expedited (2-3 business days) and non-shipping holidays including Thanksgiving and Christmas Day, but it states no shipping rates, no free-shipping threshold and no holiday order cut-off dates.Source
- Customer reviewsThe Acadia NP Passport Sticker page shows 509 reviews, 95% five-star. Reviewers buy online to fill gaps: one says that on a second visit the park "were out of stickers", another that the visitor center was closed for remodeling, another that a park had no visitor center to buy from.Source
- Your online storeStore apps seen on the site: the Swym wishlist (pages "wishlist" and "swym-share-wishlist"), Omnisend for email sign-ups, Rebuy for cart offers, Lucky Orange session recording, and a Passport Store page.Source