Essential Oxygen has two live FAQ pages. The footer links to the current one at /pages/faq-1, updated on October 30, 2026. The older one at /pages/faq is still in the sitemap, so search engines and AI assistants can read and quote it, and it gives different answers. It says a subscription has a "minimum of 3 billing cycles" and that cancelling earlier means contacting customer service, while the Subscribe & Save page says "You can cancel anytime in your customer portal." It also carries product answers the company has since rewritten: the old page says MSM "may be helpful in relieving tooth pain and root infections" and that a bulging bottle is fine, while the current page says the Tooth Polish "is not a treatment for tooth pain, gum disease, or dental infections" and "If a bottle is swollen, leaking, damaged, or unusually pressurized, do not use it." Nobody on the team sees the old page because the site no longer links to it, but anyone searching a question about the products can land on it.
First action
Open /pages/faq and /pages/faq-1 side by side and list every answer that differs.
How to measure it
FAQ clicks landing on /pages/faq-1
- Now
- –
- Target
- 100%
- By
- 30 days
Steps
Compare the two FAQs
List each question where the 2023 page and the 2026 page disagree: subscription minimum, cancelling, MSM, bulging bottles, internal use, international orders.
E-Commerce Manager 2 hours
Carry over what is missing
Add the delivery frequencies and any still-true answers to /pages/faq-1 and the Subscribe & Save page.
E-Commerce Manager half a day
Redirect the old FAQ
Permanent redirect from /pages/faq to /pages/faq-1 in Shopify, then unpublish the old page.
E-Commerce Manager 30 minutes
Clear the other duplicates
Redirect the two older careers pages, the older reviews page, the older mission page and the leftover 2022 to 2024 pages to their current versions.
E-Commerce Manager half a day
Check what search shows
Search the old sentences in quotes, note where they appear, and request recrawls in Search Console.
Senior Marketing Manager 2 hours
Check partner copies
Ask the customer service inbox and the wholesale portal owners whether any saved replies or product sheets still use the 2023 wording.
Customer Service Lead 1 day
Set the one-URL rule
Write a short rule: one page per topic, replaced pages are redirected the same day, and the sitemap is reviewed each quarter.
Senior Marketing Manager 1 hour
Why it works
Redirect /pages/faq to /pages/faq-1 with a permanent redirect, then do the same for the other duplicates the pages sitemap shows: three careers pages, two review pages, the older mission page and the leftover pages from 2022 to 2024. Before redirecting, copy across anything the old FAQ answers that the new one does not (the old page lists the 30, 60 and 90 day delivery options; the new FAQ and the Subscribe & Save page list none). Then search the old wording on Google and in the main AI assistants, and ask for a recrawl of the pages that still show it. Finish with a one-page rule: one URL per topic, and when a page is replaced it is redirected the same day.
A shopper deciding whether to subscribe, or checking whether a product is safe, should find one answer. The three-cycle wording makes the subscription look like a commitment the company no longer asks for, which costs sign-ups. The older safety and benefit wording is the kind the company has already chosen to tighten, so leaving it reachable undoes that work. Redirects take minutes in Shopify and pass the old page's search value to the new one.
Ready to use
ChecklistOld page clean-up list
[ ] /pages/faq redirected to /pages/faq-1 [ ] Delivery frequencies added to the current FAQ and to Subscribe & Save [ ] /pages/join-our-team and /pages/join-our-team-1 redirected to /pages/careers [ ] /pages/customer-love and /pages/real-people-real-reviews merged into one reviews page [ ] /pages/our-mission redirected to /pages/our-purpose [ ] Leftover 2022 to 2024 pages redirected or unpublished [ ] Old sentences searched in quotes; recrawls requested [ ] Saved customer service replies checked for 2023 wording [ ] One-URL rule written and shared
Risks and how to handle them
A useful answer is lost in the redirect
Compare question by question first and copy across anything still true.
Old wording lingers in search results for a few weeks
Request recrawls and re-check monthly until it is gone.
Evidence
- Your websiteOlder FAQ at /pages/faq (H1 "Essential Oxygen FAQ", last modified October 2023 in the sitemap, re-checked November 16, 2026): "When you subscribe to a product you save an additional 5% (minimum of 3 billing cycles)"; cancelling before three cycles means contacting customer service; on MSM, "may be helpful in relieving tooth pain and root infections"; on internal use, "We are not doctors and cannot recommend internal use of food grade hydrogen peroxide"; a bulging bottle is described as fine.Source
- Your websiteCurrent FAQ at /pages/faq-1 (H1 "Frequently Asked Questions", last modified October 30, 2026; the footer FAQ link points here): "No. Do not drink or ingest hydrogen peroxide."; "Tooth Polish is not a treatment for tooth pain, gum disease, or dental infections."; "If a bottle is swollen, leaking, damaged, or unusually pressurized, do not use it."; "Our consumer website currently serves customers in the United States."Source
- Your websiteSubscribe & Save page: "Save 5% on every recurring order"; "You can cancel anytime in your customer portal."; "Free shipping on subscription orders over $100"; "Promo codes cannot be combined with subscription discounts." The page does not list the eligible products or the delivery frequencies.Source
- Your websitePages sitemap (43 pages, checked November 16, 2026): two FAQ pages (/pages/faq from 2023 and /pages/faq-1 from 2026); three careers pages (/pages/join-our-team, /pages/join-our-team-1, /pages/careers); two review pages (/pages/customer-love, /pages/real-people-real-reviews); /pages/our-mission beside /pages/our-purpose; and several leftover pages last touched in 2022 to 2024.Source