The Sandalwood & Saffron Magic Soap is the brand's best-known product, yet the live sitemap lists it under at least three product URLs: "magic-soap-sandal-wood-and-saffron_soap-copy", "magic-soap-saffron-and-sandal-wood-soap-1" and "magic-soap-sandal-wood-and-saffron-soap-bestdetansoap". Four more listings end in "-copy" (gloves, glove and soap, trio, soap-face wash-cream combo). The prices disagree too: the store lists "Magic Soap (Sandal Wood and Saffron_Soap)" at ₹399, while a brand tracker shows "Magic Soap (Sandal Wood and Saffron)" at ₹192 and a "Variant" at ₹299. Google, ad platforms and shoppers see three competing versions of one product. Reviews and ranking signals are split, and nothing answers the simple question "how much is one bar?"
First action
Export every product whose handle contains "magic-soap", ends in "-copy" or ends in "-1", with 90-day sessions, orders and review counts.
How to measure it
Magic Soap page conversion rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- +15%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Audit the duplicates
List every Magic Soap, "-copy" and "-1" product with its traffic, orders, reviews, price and where it is linked from (ads, Instagram, emails, blog).
Shopify Developer 1 day
Pick the winner
Keep the URL with the most organic traffic and reviews as the canonical Magic Soap page.
Head of D2C Growth 1 day
Build the pack variants
1, 3 and 6 bars and the face wash pack as variants, each showing its per-bar price and saving.
Shopify Developer 2 days
Move the reviews
Merge reviews from the retired listings onto the canonical page in the review app.
Customer Experience Lead 1 day
Redirect
301 redirects from every retired URL to the canonical page; remove them from collections.
Shopify Developer 2 hours
Update every link
Ads, the product feed, Instagram bio and story links, email flows and blog posts.
Performance Marketing Manager 2 days
Repeat for the other "-copy" listings
Gloves, trio and combo pages: merge, redirect and rename the handles.
Shopify Developer 3 days
Measure
Conversion, organic clicks and ad cost per purchase on the canonical page against the month before.
Head of D2C Growth 4 weeks
Why it works
Choose one canonical Magic Soap page. Make pack sizes (1, 3 and 6 bars, and the soap-plus-face-wash pack) variants on it, each with its per-bar price. Send the other URLs to it with 301 redirects, move their reviews onto it, and update every ad, the product feed, Instagram links, emails and blog links to the one URL. Then do the same for the "-copy" glove, trio and combo listings and drop "-copy" and "-1" from the handles. The hero page ends up with all the review count and all the search signal, and shoppers see one clear price ladder.
Duplicate product pages compete with each other in search and shopping results, and split the social proof that convinces a first-time buyer. One page with every review and a clear pack ladder converts better, ranks better and is easier to advertise, and the fix is all inside Shopify.
Ready to use
ChecklistMagic Soap one-page checklist
[ ] Export products with handles containing magic-soap, -copy or -1 [ ] Choose the canonical Magic Soap URL [ ] Add 1 / 3 / 6 bar and face wash pack variants with per-bar prices [ ] Merge reviews onto the canonical page [ ] 301 redirect retired URLs [ ] Update ads, product feed, Instagram, emails and blog links [ ] Repeat for gloves, trio and combo -copy listings [ ] Compare conversion after 30 days
Risks and how to handle them
A retired URL was ranking or used in live ads
Keep the handle with the most organic traffic, redirect the rest, and update ads and the feed on the same day.
Some duplicates are deliberate price tests
Run price tests as variants or with the testing tool on one page, not as separate products.
Evidence
- Your websiteSitemap (216 URLs, read 3 November 2026): 60 product pages, 59 collections, 51 blog posts, 44 pages and an /agents.md file. The hero Sandalwood & Saffron Magic Soap appears under at least three product URLs: "magic-soap-sandal-wood-and-saffron_soap-copy", "magic-soap-saffron-and-sandal-wood-soap-1" and "magic-soap-sandal-wood-and-saffron-soap-bestdetansoap". Other live listings end in "-copy" ("magic-soap-and-exfoliating-body-gloves-copy", "exfoliating-body-glove-copy", "brighten-up-trio-copy", "magic-soap-face-wash-cream-combo-copy") or "-1" ("exfoliating-back-scrubber-1", "swarg-bar-1"). Pages include "spri-invoice-cancel" and "spri-reminder-cancel".Source
- Your websiteCatalogue (3 November 2026): 91 products from ₹140 to ₹1,899, median ₹399. Items include "Magic Soap (Sandal Wood and Saffron_Soap)" at ₹399, "3 Pack Magic Soap + Free Magic Face wash 30ml" at ₹329, Kojic Acid Soap at ₹179, Swarg Bar and Palash Soap at ₹192, Magic Mask For Tan Reduction at ₹299, Magic Underarm Brightening Deo and HeadMaster Anti-Dandruff Shampoo at ₹349, combos at ₹399 and ₹599, and Diwali gift boxes ("De-Tan Patakha" ₹499, "Bada Patakha" ₹799, "Dhamakedar Patakha" ₹999). Accessories include a Kansa Facial Massager, a Face Clean Towel, exfoliating body gloves and a back scrubber.Source
- Market dataD2C Story brand tracker (updated 1 September 2026): Instagram 926.47K followers, up 20% from 770.41K; LinkedIn 25.86K. Launches in June and July 2026 include a Master Clay Mask Cleanser (₹299), Magic Skin Brightening Gel (₹399), Star Spray Serum (₹499) and a Buy 1 Get 1 Magic Face Wash (₹499). It lists "Magic Soap (Sandal Wood and Saffron)" at ₹192 and "Magic Soap (Sandal Wood and Saffron Soap Variant)" at ₹299, plus a "Mystery Soap", "Mystery Face wash" and "Mystery Gift" at ₹149 each.Source
- Customer reviewsLoox review feed for the store: 11,487 reviews. Praise centres on fragrance ("The smell is like heaven"), tan ("really helpful for removing tan") and not drying the skin. Complaints: delivery ("delivery time is little longer"), the bar melting in heat (it "meltdowns", so keep it somewhere cool), price ("The cost is little high"), and results that reviewers saw anywhere from three days to several weeks.Source