The new Membership and Retention lead will own churn and customer reviews across DTC and Hair Color Bars. Madison Reed's own product data shows where that work starts: 15 of 19 permanent blonde shades average under 4 stars, 3.8 across 13,546 reviews, while browns average 4.13 and reds 4.27. Blondes are the shades most likely to come out brassy or the wrong level at home, and those stars sit on the pages, in search results and on the first kit of a subscription.
First action
Pull second-order and refund rates for first-time buyers of the 15 low-rated blonde shades.
How to measure it
Blonde first-buyer repeat rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- match brunettes
- By
- 2 quarters
Steps
Size the gap
Repeat, refund and cancel rates by shade family for first orders.
Sr Director, Membership and Retention 3 days
Read the reviews
Tag low blonde reviews: too dark, brassy, too light, uneven.
Membership Marketing Associate 1 week
Add the pre-ship check
Three questions and a colorist video-chat offer for blonde orders.
SVP, eCommerce 1 week
Fix the worst pages
Clearer level and undertone guidance on the ten lowest shades.
Director, Product Marketing 2 weeks
Send the tone check
Day-3 email with gloss fixes and a swap offer.
Membership Marketing Associate 1 week
Bridge to the Bar
New client perk for unhappy buyers near a Hair Color Bar.
President, Hair Color Bars 2 weeks
Report
Monthly repeat and rating trend by shade family.
Sr Director, Membership and Retention monthly
Why it works
Treat a blonde kit order as a risk signal. Before the first box ships, send blonde buyers a short check (natural level, past color, highlights) and offer a free video chat with a colorist; flag mismatches for a shade swap. After the first use, send a tone check with a Crema or gloss fix for brassiness, and offer the nearest Hair Color Bar's new client perk to anyone unhappy. Read the low reviews by shade, fix the "Is This Shade Right For Me?" guidance on the worst ten, and report second-order rates for blonde buyers against brunettes.
A wrong first result is the most common reason a subscriber never orders again, and it is fixable before it happens. Turning an unhappy blonde home buyer into a Hair Color Bar guest also keeps her inside Madison Reed instead of returning to a salon elsewhere.
Ready to use
ChecklistBlonde first-order save plan
[ ] Repeat and refund rates by shade family [ ] Low-review reasons tagged for the 15 blonde shades [ ] Pre-ship check: natural level, past color, highlights [ ] Colorist video-chat offer for blonde first orders [ ] Day-3 tone check with gloss fixes [ ] Hair Color Bar new client perk for unhappy buyers [ ] Monthly rating and repeat report
Risks and how to handle them
Too many chats to staff
Start with first-time buyers of the five lowest-rated shades.
Swaps raise costs
Compare swap cost with the lifetime value of a kept subscriber.
Evidence
- HiringSr Director, Membership and Retention (remote, posted October 29, 2026): will "grow customer membership, improve retention, and reduce churn across the DTC & Hair Color Bar channels", "Monitor and improve customer satisfaction metrics, including CSAT, NPS, and customer reviews", optimize "take rates, retention rates, and engagement metrics", and "optimize customer touchpoints across the digital and physical customer journey"; reports to the SVP of eCommerce and manages a Membership Marketing Associate.Source
- Review analysisRatings in the product data of Madison Reed's own product pages (checked November 4, 2026): of 19 permanent blonde shades, 15 average under 4 stars, with a review-weighted 3.8 across 13,546 reviews (for example Bologna Blonde 3.6 from 1,777 reviews, Sicily Blonde 3.9 from 1,685, Roma 3.6, Granara 3.3). Browns average 4.13 (38,841 reviews), reds 4.27 and blacks 4.28. Prime for Perfection primer shows 3.1 (737 reviews), Crema gloss 3.3 and the Sorrento highlighting kit 3.2.Source
- Your websiteRadiant Hair Color Kit pages: $35 one-time or $29.50 on Subscribe & Save (15% off), delivery every 2 to 7 weeks, "Try It On", "Find My Perfect Shade", an "Is This Shade Right For Me?" section, "Try it risk-free with our 100% money-back guarantee"; the homepage offers a "2 minute quiz" and the site has a schedule-video-chat page.Source
- Your websiteFlatiron Hair Color Bar page (one of 100 location pages): Roots Coverage "$0 member or / $90 non-members", All Over Color "$29.60 member or / $127 non-members", a "New Client Perk Roots $70 | All-Over Color $102 (Available Mon–Wed)", and "Join today to get unlimited root touch ups" with no membership price on the page.Source