The FAQ says Coffee Club members who tick the recurring-order box get 10% off repeat orders and free standard shipping on orders over $24.99. Five of the six coffees are listed at $23.99, so the most natural club order, one bag on repeat, falls $1.00 short at list price and $3.40 short after the 10% discount ($21.59). Meanwhile the homepage never mentions the club: its only offer, shown twice, is 30% off a first order for joining the newsletter, and the shipping page says rates appear at checkout. The FAQ was last edited in 2020, so the checkout may already behave differently; if it does, the pages are underselling the offer, and if it does not, the best customer LOVEz can win is being charged shipping for staying loyal.
First action
Place a test recurring order for one $23.99 bag and note the shipping charge shown at checkout.
How to measure it
Coffee Club share of orders
- Now
- –
- Target
- 20% of orders
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Test the checkout
Start a one-bag recurring order and a two-bag one; record the shipping shown for each against the FAQ's $24.99 rule.
Founder 30 minutes
Set the rule
Choose free standard shipping on all club orders, or a line of $21 so one discounted bag qualifies. Check the margin on a single shipped bag.
Founder 1 day
Change the shipping rate
Update the shipping rule in Shopify and the subscription app so the checkout matches the promise.
Storefront manager 2 hours
Add the homepage block
One block above the product grid: 10% off every repeat order, free shipping, skip or cancel by email.
Storefront manager half a day
Repeat it where people decide
Product page beside the recurring-order box, the cart, and the shipping page.
Storefront manager half a day
Rewrite the FAQ answer
Replace the 2020 wording with the new rule and how to pause or cancel.
Founder 1 hour
Measure
Club share of orders and repeat rate each week for eight weeks, against the four weeks before.
Founder weekly
Why it works
Decide the rule first: free standard shipping on every Coffee Club order, or a line at or below the price of one discounted bag. Then say it in one sentence everywhere a buyer decides: a homepage block above the product grid, the product page beside the recurring-order box, the cart, the shipping page and a rewritten FAQ answer. Keep the 30% welcome offer for now, but let the club be the second thing every visitor reads.
A one-bag repeat order is how most households buy coffee, and a shipping charge that appears at checkout is the moment many of them leave. Rivals already remove it: one ships every subscription free and another gives subscribers free shipping on two or more bags. Matching that on a single bag costs a few dollars per order and buys a customer who reorders without another discount.
Ready to use
CopyHomepage Coffee Club block
Never run out. Never pay shipping. Join the Coffee Club (free): 10% off every repeat order and free standard shipping, even on one bag. Roasted the day it ships. Skip, pause or cancel any time by email. [Start with one bag]
Risks and how to handle them
Free shipping on one bag thins the margin
Limit it to recurring orders and review the cost per order after 30 days.
The checkout already ships club orders free
Then only the pages need changing, which is the cheaper half of the work.
Evidence
- Your websiteFAQ page (last modified August 2020): the Coffee Club is free to join; ticking the recurring-order box at checkout gives 10% off repeat orders and free standard shipping on orders over $24.99; coffee cannot be returned, though LOVEz may refund or send a different bean; contact is by email only, usually answered within 24 hours; bloggers and ambassadors are asked to email; the referral program is described as still in development.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 16, 2026): H1 "Air Roasted Coffee That Tastes the Way Nature Intended"; six coffees, five at $23.99 or "From $23.99" and Kona SL34 at $47.52; the only offer is 30% off a first order for joining the newsletter, shown twice and not combinable with other discounts; no Coffee Club, subscription or free-shipping wording; the top banner reads "@SHOP STORE....LOVEz COFFEE AIR ROASTED IN SMALL BATCHES SHIPPED DIRECTLY TO YOU.....@SHOP STORE."Source
- Your websiteShipping page: orders placed before 11:00am CT are usually roasted and shipped the same day, weekends and US holidays excepted; standard delivery takes 3 to 5 business days to all 50 states and APO/FPO addresses, with two-day shipping available; rates are shown only at checkout and no free-shipping threshold is mentioned.Source
- Competitor researchVolcanica Coffee homepage: "GET 20% OFF YOUR FIRST SUBSCRIPTION ORDER" and "FREE SHIPPING $60+, SUBSCRIPTIONS or $6.95 FLAT RATE".Source
- Competitor researchEmber Coffee (air-roasted, Minnesota) homepage: "Low Acid, Tested for Mold, Never Burnt or Bitter"; most 12 oz bags at $22.00; free shipping on orders of $65 or more; subscribers get "free shipping on 2+ bags, triple points, and more"; advertises "5,000+ reviews".Source