ProgrammableMarketing/m2unyc.com (opens in a new tab)
PDF

Views

  • Plan
  • Roadmap
  • Research

On this page

  • The brief
  • Start here
  • Idea portfolio
  • Effort vs impact
  • This week · 6
  • This quarter · 10
  • Big bets · 3
  • Wildcards · 4
  • How we can help
Generated Oct 21, 2026
  1. Programmable
  2. Playbooks
  3. M2U NYC
M2U NYC logo

growth playbook · Oct 21, 2026

m2unyc.com (opens in a new tab)

M2U NYC growth playbook

Diagnosis

M2U NYC has the things a value beauty brand needs: well-reviewed hero products (Eye Crayon 186 reviews, Cream Blush 154), over 2 million units sold, PETA certification, a fast site and an H-E-B rollout to over 200 stores.

The gaps are in the catalogue and the funnel around it: new shades split from their reviews, sold-out items with no waitlist, offers stuffed into product names, a free-shipping line above the typical cart, stale 2019 pages, and no link between H-E-B shoppers and the website. This playbook fixes the catalogue first, then builds creator sales around the Eye Crayon, Klaviyo repeat buying, wholesale and a second retailer.

Growth Score

6/10

Biggest Opportunity

Make every shade inherit its product's reviews, then use the Eye Crayon and the H-E-B presence to pull shoppers into repeat online buying.

Biggest Risk

e.l.f., ColourPop and wet n wild sell the same low-price, cruelty-free promise with far bigger budgets, so a messy catalogue or stale site costs M2U NYC more than it costs them.

01

Start here

The three moves to make first. Each one is written up in full below.

  1. 1

    Fold the eight single-shade pages into their parent products, so new shades launch with 186 reviews instead of zero

    Redirect Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink to the Eye Crayon page with Passionate Pink selected.

    High impact First result in 2 weeks
  2. 2

    Turn the six sold-out listings into waitlists, starting with mascara and false lashes

    Switch on Klaviyo back-in-stock for the mascara and lashes.

    High impact First result in 2 weeks
  3. 3

    A free-shipping progress bar built around the $30 trio, since the median product is $12

    Turn on a free-shipping bar in the cart.

    High impact First result in 2 weeks

02

Your idea portfolio

23 ideas, grouped by when to run them. Open any idea for how to run it: the steps, who to approach, copy you can use, and how to measure it.

  • 6 ideas are marked Unexpected: plays you are unlikely to have tried.

Every idea placed by the effort it takes against the impact it could have. Quick wins sit top left; select a number to open that idea. The filters below narrow the list by status, timing, category and what Programmable can build.

Effort vs impactEach number is an idea. Select one to open it.
Impact →
Quick wins · 4Big bets · 5Fill-ins · 10Reconsider · 4
Effort →

Showing 23 of 23 ideas

This week 6

Quick wins with a clear first action.

  • 01

    Your newest shade, Eye Crayon Passionate Pink, went live on October 15 as its own product page with 0 reviews, while the same shade sits in the Eye Crayon page beside 186 reviews averaging 4.83. Seven more shades are split the same way: Metallic Liquid Lip Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold, and three Liquid Shadows. Two of them even live at URLs ending in "-copy" that name a different shade, and Ann costs $10 on its own page but $12 on the main one. A shopper who lands on a single-shade page sees no social proof and a different price from the one she sees a click away.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Redirect Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink to the Eye Crayon page with Passionate Pink selected.

    How to measure it

    Orders of the eight shades

    Now
    –
    Target
    +20%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      List the duplicates

      The eight single-shade products and their parents.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    2. 2

      Decide each

      Redirect to the parent, or keep for ads and share reviews.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Fix the price

      One price for Ann everywhere.

      Founder & CEO 15 minutes

    4. 4

      Set redirects

      Each old URL to the parent with the shade selected.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 hours

    5. 5

      Group reviews

      Share parent reviews on any page you keep.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    6. 6

      Update links

      Ads, emails and social bios that used the old URLs.

      Marketing Manager 2 hours

    7. 7

      Change the launch habit

      New shades as variants with a "New shade" badge.

      Ecommerce Manager ongoing

    8. 8

      Measure

      Conversion on the shades before and after.

      Ecommerce Manager 60 days

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Redirect Passionate Pink today and compare its conversion over two weeks.

    Why it works

    Keep one page per product. Redirect each single-shade URL to its parent with that shade preselected (Shopify can link straight to a variant), or, if the separate pages exist for ads, show the parent's reviews on them using your review app's product grouping. Settle the Ann price at one number. From now on, launch new shades as a variant of the parent with a "New shade" badge, so they inherit its reviews from day one.

    Reviews are the strongest conversion signal in low-price beauty, and splitting them hands every new shade a cold start. One page per product also concentrates search ranking, and gives AI shopping assistants one clear answer instead of two prices for the same lipstick.

    Ready to use

    ChecklistSingle-shade cleanup

    [ ] Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink -> /products/eye-crayon?variant=<Passionate Pink>
    [ ] Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann, Dream, Copper, Rose Gold -> /products/metallic-liquid-lip?variant=<shade>
    [ ] Liquid Shadow - Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose, Matte Terracotta -> /products/liquid-eyeshadow-matte-shimmer?variant=<shade>
    [ ] One price for Ann
    [ ] Ads, emails and bios updated
    [ ] New shades launched as variants from now on

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Ads point to the old pages

      Redirects keep them working; update the ads within a week.

    • Losing the single-shade search result

      The parent page ranks for the shade name when it is in the variant title.

    Evidence

    • Your catalogueEight shades are also listed as separate single-shade products, each with its own canonical URL: Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink (added October 15, 2026, 0 reviews, while the Eye Crayon page has 186 reviews averaging 4.83); Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann ($10 and 0 reviews, while Ann is $12 on the Metallic Liquid Lip page with 96 reviews), - Dream, - Copper (URL /products/metallic-liquid-lip-rose-gold-copy) and - Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow - Shimmer Warm Champagne, - Matte Dusty Rose and - Matte Terracotta (URL /products/liquid-shadow-matte-dusty-rose-copy).Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteThe store publishes Shopify's agents.md and an agentic discovery sitemap, so AI shopping assistants can search the catalogue, build carts and check out for a shopper; they read the same product names, prices and reviews that people see.Source
  • 02

    Six products are fully sold out but still published, including the tubing mascara and all six False Eyelashes styles, which are repeat-purchase items. A shopper who wanted them leaves with nothing and no way to hear when they return.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Switch on Klaviyo back-in-stock for the mascara and lashes.

    How to measure it

    Restock orders from waitlists

    Now
    –
    Target
    30% of signups
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Sort the six

      Returning, or gone for good.

      Founder & CEO 1 hour

    2. 2

      Add the signup

      Back-in-stock form on sold-out items.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 hours

    3. 3

      Retire the rest

      Hide or redirect gone-for-good items.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    4. 4

      Write the flow

      Back-in-stock email and text.

      Marketing Manager 2 hours

    5. 5

      Reorder

      Use signups to size the next order.

      Founder & CEO ongoing

    6. 6

      Measure

      Signups and restock orders.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0 on the current Klaviyo plan
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Add the signup to the mascara page today.

    Why it works

    Add a back-in-stock signup to every sold-out product and variant (Klaviyo has this built in), hide or redirect the ones that will not return (the limited-edition Dumbo palette), and send the waitlist a text and email the day stock lands, with a suggested pairing.

    Waitlists turn lost visits into a list of buyers who already chose the product, and tell you which items are worth reordering first.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Long restock times

      Give an honest date in the signup message.

    Evidence

    • Your catalogueSix listings are fully sold out but still published: Everyday Volumizing + Lengthening Tubing Mascara (both options), False Eyelashes (all 6 styles), NYC Girls Eyelashes Collection (6 Pairs), Makeup Starter Box Set, Makeup Blending Sponge Box Set and the Dumbo Eyeshadow Palette (Limited Edition). Partly sold out: Eyeshadow Duo (2 of 6 shades left), Luminizer (1 of 3) and the Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (24 of 36 combinations).Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
  • 03

    Free shipping starts at $30 and most products cost $10-$15, so a typical one- or two-item cart pays $4.99. The best answer, the $30 Lip Trio where the shopper picks her own shades, is buried in a product name full of offer text.

    High impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Turn on a free-shipping bar in the cart.

    How to measure it

    Average order value

    Now
    –
    Target
    +12%
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check the data

      Share of orders under $30 today.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    2. 2

      Add the bar

      Cart and cart drawer.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    3. 3

      Pick fillers

      Three items at $5-$12.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    4. 4

      Add the trio prompt

      On lip product pages.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    5. 5

      Test

      Two weeks with and without.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 weeks

    6. 6

      Keep the winner

      And review fillers monthly.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    Developer time
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Add the bar today and compare a week of orders.

    Why it works

    Add a cart bar that shows how far the shopper is from free shipping and suggests one item to close the gap (a $10 Eye Crayon or a $5 pouch). Show the Pick-Your-Shades trio on lip product pages as "make it a trio and ship free".

    Shoppers add a small item rather than pay shipping, which raises order value without a discount.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Cheap fillers lower margin

      Suggest full-price items, not discounted sets.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping and returns: free USPS Standard over $30, $4.99 under $30, Priority $12.99; orders ship within 2 business days; "we are not able to ship internationally at this time. Please drop us a line and let us know which country we should go next!"; refunds "less shipping within 90 days".Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
    • Your catalogueOffers are written into product names: "Everyday Glam Eye Set – Save 20% + Free Shipping" ($34), "Metallic Liquid Lip Trio (Free Shipping + Free Gift, 35% OFF)" ($30), "Lip Trio – Pick Your Shades (17% OFF + Free Shipping)" ($30, 90 shade combinations), "Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (4 Products + Free Shipping)" ($45) and "Makeup Starter Box Set (FREE SHIPPING)" ($49).Source
  • 04

    Five product names carry their promotion, such as "Metallic Liquid Lip Trio (Free Shipping + Free Gift, 35% OFF)". Names like that show in search results, Google Shopping and AI assistants, look like spam, and go stale when the offer ends.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Rename the Metallic Liquid Lip Trio.

    How to measure it

    Organic clicks to the sets

    Now
    –
    Target
    +15%
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      List them

      Five products with offers in the name.

      Ecommerce Manager 15 minutes

    2. 2

      Rename

      Product name only.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Add badges

      Saving and free shipping.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    4. 4

      Set compare-at prices

      Where a saving is real.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    5. 5

      Check feeds

      Google Shopping titles.

      Marketing Manager 1 hour

    6. 6

      Measure

      Clicks and conversion.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Rename one set and watch it for two weeks.

    Why it works

    Rename each product to what it is (Metallic Liquid Lip Trio, Lip Trio - Pick Your Shades) and show the saving and free shipping as a badge and a compare-at price on the page and in collections.

    Clean names read as a real brand, rank for what shoppers type, and let you change offers without renaming products.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Losing the offer message

      The badge shows it on every listing.

    Evidence

    • Your catalogueOffers are written into product names: "Everyday Glam Eye Set – Save 20% + Free Shipping" ($34), "Metallic Liquid Lip Trio (Free Shipping + Free Gift, 35% OFF)" ($30), "Lip Trio – Pick Your Shades (17% OFF + Free Shipping)" ($30, 90 shade combinations), "Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (4 Products + Free Shipping)" ($45) and "Makeup Starter Box Set (FREE SHIPPING)" ($49).Source
    • Your websiteThe store publishes Shopify's agents.md and an agentic discovery sitemap, so AI shopping assistants can search the catalogue, build carts and check out for a shopper; they read the same product names, prices and reviews that people see.Source
  • 05

    The sitemap still lists a referral page promising rewards "when it launches in late 2019", a 2019 design contest, a COVID-19 notice, an empty refer-a-friend page and a partnerships page with only a heading. Anyone who finds them sees a brand that looks paused.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 week Marketing Manager

    First action

    Redirect /pages/revised-referral to the community page.

    How to measure it

    Stale pages live

    Now
    –
    Target
    0
    By
    2 weeks

    Steps

    1. 1

      List pages

      The six stale pages.

      Marketing Manager 30 minutes

    2. 2

      Choose targets

      Where each should point.

      Marketing Manager 30 minutes

    3. 3

      Redirect

      In Shopify URL redirects.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    4. 4

      Unpublish

      The old pages.

      Ecommerce Manager 15 minutes

    5. 5

      Check links

      Footer and old emails.

      Marketing Manager 1 hour

    6. 6

      Review

      Pages twice a year.

      Marketing Manager 6 months

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Redirect the 2019 referral page today.

    Why it works

    Unpublish or redirect each: the old referral pages to one current referral or affiliate page, the contest and COVID pages to Our Story, partnerships to the community page. If the referral programme is gone, decide whether to bring it back (see the referral idea).

    Search engines and AI assistants read every page you publish, and stale ones dilute the brand.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Old links break

      Redirects keep them working.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteOlder pages still in the sitemap: /pages/revised-referral ("redeem free M2U NYC makeup products when it launches in late 2019"), /pages/design-contest (a packaging art contest that ran April 15-26, 2019), /pages/covid-19, /pages/refer-a-friend-ijy (a heading with no programme under it), /pages/partnerships (only the heading "Campus Ambassador") and /pages/campus-ambassador (reps who promote "on-campus pop up stores").Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
  • 06

    The footer TikTok link is titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr", the Liquid Shadow (launched in 2024) is still described as a new launch, and a post published October 2025 is titled "Halloween Makeup Trends for 2023". Each is small, but together they make the site look less looked-after than the brand is. Speed is fine: real visitors pass Core Web Vitals, though load time is 15% slower than a year ago.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 week Marketing Manager

    First action

    Relabel the TikTok link.

    How to measure it

    Field LCP

    Now
    –
    Target
    Back under 2.0s
    By
    90 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Relabel TikTok

      Footer and header.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 15 minutes

    2. 2

      Update copy

      Liquid Shadow description.

      Marketing Manager 30 minutes

    3. 3

      Refresh the post

      Title and looks for this year.

      Marketing Manager 2 hours

    4. 4

      Fix contrast

      Flagged text colours.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 hour

    5. 5

      Name links

      Icon links get labels.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 hour

    6. 6

      Check speed

      Apps and images added this year.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 2 hours

    First result
    1 week
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Relabel the TikTok link today.

    Why it works

    Relabel the TikTok link, replace "NEW LAUNCH!" with the Liquid Shadow's best review, update the Halloween post title and looks, fix the two accessibility flags (contrast and unnamed links) and check which app or image added weight this year.

    Details are trust signals for a brand that sells on value, and accessible links help screen readers and search engines alike.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Changes slip again

      Add a quarterly storefront check.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteBlog: 35 posts; the latest is "Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Makeup: Recreate Her Iconic '90s Beauty Look" (March 6, 2026), before it "Mastering the Nina Park Effect" (January 2026) and Taylor Swift's "Showgirl Era" look (October 2025). A post published October 20, 2025 is titled "Top Movie-Inspired Halloween Makeup Trends for 2023". Others: "Steal These 3 Met Gala Makeup Looks Using Dupes Under $15", "Affordable Quality Makeup Dupes You Need to Know About", "Pair Your Lipstick with Your Skin Tone" and two hooded-eye guides.Source
    • Google PageSpeedHomepage on mobile: performance 95/100, accessibility 93, SEO 100; lab LCP 2.4s (the heading "Makeup with Skincare Benefits at Exceptional Prices"). Real visitors pass Core Web Vitals (field LCP 2.16s, INP 164ms, CLS 0.03), but field LCP is 15% slower than a year ago. Flagged: low colour contrast and links without a discernible name.Source

This quarter 10

The core plays for the next three months.

  • 07

    M2U NYC is in over 200 H-E-B stores with over 60 SKUs, but product pages never mention it and H-E-B shoppers have no reason to come to the website for shades the store does not carry.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Retail Account Manager

    First action

    List which products H-E-B carries.

    How to measure it

    Orders with the in-store code

    Now
    –
    Target
    300
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Map the range

      Products and shades at H-E-B.

      Retail Account Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Add badges

      "Also at H-E-B" on those pages.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 2 days

    3. 3

      Design the card

      QR code and first-order offer.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Agree with H-E-B

      Pack insert rules.

      Retail Account Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Print and ship

      In the next production run.

      Founder & CEO 1 month

    6. 6

      Track

      Scans and code use.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Printing costs
    Owner
    Retail Account Manager

    Smallest test

    Add the H-E-B badge to the Eye Crayon page.

    Why it works

    Mark the products sold at H-E-B on their pages with a link to the store finder, and put a small card or QR code in store packs offering the full shade range online with free shipping on a first order. Track the QR scans and the code.

    Retail shoppers become direct customers, and showing retail presence on the site is social proof for online shoppers.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Retailer rules on inserts

      Clear it with the buyer first.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteH-E-B page: "Click the Map Below to Find Over 200 H-E-B Locations Carrying M2U NYC Products"; "Shop over 60 SKUs in the Beauty Department: Tools & Trends section"; a link to an M2U NYC search on heb.com. The press page lists a Beauty Independent article on the brand's retail expansion with H-E-B, alongside BuzzFeed, Bustle, Brit + Co, Essence, CEW Awards 2024 and a 2025 Editors Choice Award.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
  • 08

    The brand's biggest retail partner is a Texas grocer, and many of its shoppers prefer Spanish, but the site is English only.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Marketing Manager

    First action

    Translate the H-E-B page and the Eye Crayon.

    How to measure it

    Spanish-page orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    5% of orders
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick pages

      Top ten products and H-E-B page.

      Marketing Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Translate

      Native speaker review.

      Marketing Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Add the switch

      Language selector.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    4. 4

      Make videos

      Two bilingual demos.

      Social & Creator Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Promote

      Texas social ads.

      Marketing Manager 1 month

    6. 6

      Measure

      Orders by language.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Translation and ad test budget
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Translate one product page and run one Spanish ad.

    Why it works

    Translate the top ten products, the shade guides and the H-E-B page with Shopify's language tools, add a language switch, and post bilingual short videos of the Eye Crayon and Cream Blush.

    Few budget beauty brands speak to Spanish-first shoppers online, and the store presence is already there.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Machine translation sounds off

      Have a native speaker check every page.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteH-E-B page: "Click the Map Below to Find Over 200 H-E-B Locations Carrying M2U NYC Products"; "Shop over 60 SKUs in the Beauty Department: Tools & Trends section"; a link to an M2U NYC search on heb.com. The press page lists a Beauty Independent article on the brand's retail expansion with H-E-B, alongside BuzzFeed, Bustle, Brit + Co, Essence, CEW Awards 2024 and a 2025 Editors Choice Award.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
  • 09

    Older products carry most of the 1,333 reviews, while the Liquid Shadow line, which the homepage pushes, has four. New products look unproven next to the classics.

    High impactLow effort First result in 1 quarter Customer Experience Lead

    First action

    List the last 90 days of Liquid Shadow buyers.

    How to measure it

    Liquid Shadow reviews

    Now
    –
    Target
    50
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pull buyers

      Last 90 days.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 hour

    2. 2

      Send requests

      Judge.me with photo prompt.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 day

    3. 3

      Pick sample group

      100 loyal buyers.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 week

    4. 4

      Ship samples

      One shade each.

      Customer Experience Lead 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Add cross-sell

      On the Eye Crayon page.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    6. 6

      Measure

      Reviews and conversion.

      Customer Experience Lead monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Product samples
    Owner
    Customer Experience Lead

    Smallest test

    Email 50 Liquid Shadow buyers this week.

    Why it works

    Send Liquid Shadow buyers a review request with a photo prompt, sample it to a group of loyal Eye Crayon buyers in exchange for honest reviews, and show "Eye Crayon fans also love" on its page.

    Fresh reviews lift conversion on new lines and tell you quickly which shades to keep.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Sampled reviews look biased

      Mark them as received free, as review rules require.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
  • 10

    The Eye Crayon is the most-reviewed product and the homepage pitch ("Dazzling Eye Looks in Seconds") is made for short video. The affiliate programme exists but only lists commission, gifting and codes.

    High impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Social & Creator Manager

    First action

    Pick 30 creators who already post budget makeup.

    How to measure it

    Affiliate orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    500 a month
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Find creators

      30 budget beauty creators.

      Social & Creator Manager 2 weeks

    2. 2

      Send kits

      Three shades each.

      Social & Creator Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Set commission

      Tracked links.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Test TikTok Shop

      Two hero products.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Repost winners

      Best clips as ads.

      Marketing Manager weekly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Orders by creator.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Product and commission
    Owner
    Social & Creator Manager

    Smallest test

    Send ten creator kits this week.

    Why it works

    Recruit 30 small beauty creators through the community page, send each three Eye Crayon shades, and pay commission on tracked sales. Test a TikTok Shop listing for the Eye Crayon and Cream Blush.

    A $10 product with a one-swipe result is the easiest thing to show and buy from a video.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Uneven creator quality

      Pay on sales, not posts.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
    • Competitor researchRivals' own homepages: e.l.f. Cosmetics sells "affordable, high-quality makeup and skincare" that is "Vegan and cruelty-free"; ColourPop and wet n wild sell low-priced colour cosmetics online and through mass retail.Source
  • 11

    The Lip Trio lets shoppers pick shades (90 combinations) and the Everyday Makeup Kit is customizable, but there is no mix-and-match across eyes, lips and face, and a third of the kit's combinations are sold out.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Price the three-for-$30 offer against margins.

    How to measure it

    Orders over $30

    Now
    –
    Target
    +20%
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      Check margins

      Any three at $30.

      Founder & CEO 1 day

    2. 2

      Pick an app

      Bundle builder.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Build the page

      Eyes, lips, face.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 week

    4. 4

      Clean the kit

      Drop sold-out options.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    5. 5

      Promote

      Email and social.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Bundle orders.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Bundle app fee
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Run the offer to email subscribers for one week.

    Why it works

    Add a "build your trio" page: any three products for $30 with free shipping, using a bundle app. Remove sold-out options from the kit.

    Choice raises order value, and a flat $30 bundle matches the free-shipping line exactly.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Bundles cannibalise singles

      Watch margin per order, not just order count.

    Evidence

    • Your catalogueOffers are written into product names: "Everyday Glam Eye Set – Save 20% + Free Shipping" ($34), "Metallic Liquid Lip Trio (Free Shipping + Free Gift, 35% OFF)" ($30), "Lip Trio – Pick Your Shades (17% OFF + Free Shipping)" ($30, 90 shade combinations), "Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (4 Products + Free Shipping)" ($45) and "Makeup Starter Box Set (FREE SHIPPING)" ($49).Source
    • Your catalogueSix listings are fully sold out but still published: Everyday Volumizing + Lengthening Tubing Mascara (both options), False Eyelashes (all 6 styles), NYC Girls Eyelashes Collection (6 Pairs), Makeup Starter Box Set, Makeup Blending Sponge Box Set and the Dumbo Eyeshadow Palette (Limited Edition). Partly sold out: Eyeshadow Duo (2 of 6 shades left), Luminizer (1 of 3) and the Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (24 of 36 combinations).Source
    • Your websiteShipping and returns: free USPS Standard over $30, $4.99 under $30, Priority $12.99; orders ship within 2 business days; "we are not able to ship internationally at this time. Please drop us a line and let us know which country we should go next!"; refunds "less shipping within 90 days".Source
  • 12

    The blog already explains how to pair lipstick with skin tone and how to work with hooded eyes, but shoppers choosing between ten shades at $10-$12 get no help on the product page.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 month Marketing Manager

    First action

    Draft the quiz from the existing post.

    How to measure it

    Quiz conversion

    Now
    –
    Target
    8%
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Write questions

      From the blog posts.

      Marketing Manager 2 days

    2. 2

      Map shades

      Answers to products.

      Marketing Manager 2 days

    3. 3

      Build quiz

      Quiz app.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 week

    4. 4

      Connect Klaviyo

      Save answers.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      Promote

      Homepage and email.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Completions and orders.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Quiz app fee
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Put the quiz on the lip collection page.

    Why it works

    Build a short quiz (skin tone, undertone, look) that recommends a lip, an eye and a blush shade, shows a trio at $30, and saves the answers to Klaviyo for later emails.

    Guided choice cuts hesitation, and the answers make emails personal.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Bad matches

      Test it on staff and ten customers first.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteBlog: 35 posts; the latest is "Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Makeup: Recreate Her Iconic '90s Beauty Look" (March 6, 2026), before it "Mastering the Nina Park Effect" (January 2026) and Taylor Swift's "Showgirl Era" look (October 2025). A post published October 20, 2025 is titled "Top Movie-Inspired Halloween Makeup Trends for 2023". Others: "Steal These 3 Met Gala Makeup Looks Using Dupes Under $15", "Affordable Quality Makeup Dupes You Need to Know About", "Pair Your Lipstick with Your Skin Tone" and two hooded-eye guides.Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
  • 13

    Mascara, liner and lipstick run out or get swapped for a new shade, and the brand already collects email and text consent through Klaviyo.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Marketing Manager

    First action

    Set up the mascara refill reminder.

    How to measure it

    Customers ordering again within 6 months

    Now
    –
    Target
    +5 points
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Map cycles

      Days to reorder by product.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Write emails

      Refill and new shade.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Build flows

      In Klaviyo.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Add texts

      For SMS subscribers.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      Test timing

      60 vs 90 days.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 month

    6. 6

      Measure

      Repeat rate.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    $0 on the current plan
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Turn on the refill reminder for liner buyers.

    Why it works

    Set a refill reminder 60-90 days after a mascara or liner order, a "new shade in your favourite" email when a shade launches, and a post-purchase how-to series for each product.

    Repeat buyers are the cheapest orders a $10 brand can get.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Email fatigue

      Cap sends per week.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
    • Your catalogueSix listings are fully sold out but still published: Everyday Volumizing + Lengthening Tubing Mascara (both options), False Eyelashes (all 6 styles), NYC Girls Eyelashes Collection (6 Pairs), Makeup Starter Box Set, Makeup Blending Sponge Box Set and the Dumbo Eyeshadow Palette (Limited Edition). Partly sold out: Eyeshadow Duo (2 of 6 shades left), Luminizer (1 of 3) and the Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (24 of 36 combinations).Source
  • 14

    m2unyc.com email runs on Microsoft 365 with a strict SPF record, but DMARC is set to "p=none" and no DKIM key was found. Mailbox providers now expect bulk senders to authenticate, and Klaviyo sends need their own signing.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 2 weeks Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Turn on DKIM in Microsoft 365.

    How to measure it

    Email open rate

    Now
    –
    Target
    +3 points
    By
    60 days

    Steps

    1. 1

      Enable DKIM

      Microsoft 365.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 hour

    2. 2

      Brand Klaviyo

      Dedicated sending domain.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 hour

    3. 3

      Add reports

      DMARC reporting address.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 30 minutes

    4. 4

      Read reports

      Two weeks.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Tighten

      Move to quarantine.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 30 minutes

    6. 6

      Monitor

      Monthly.

      Shopify Developer (contract) monthly

    First result
    2 weeks
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Enable DKIM today.

    Why it works

    Turn on DKIM in Microsoft 365, set up a branded sending domain in Klaviyo, then move DMARC to quarantine after two weeks of clean reports.

    Better inbox placement makes every flow and campaign pay more.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Blocking real mail

      Read reports before tightening.

    Evidence

    • DNS checkm2unyc.com email runs on Microsoft 365; SPF is strict ("-all"), DMARC is "p=none" and no DKIM key was found at the common selectors.Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
  • 15

    Wholesale already runs through Faire with a $150 minimum and 1-3 day lead time, and the brand once ran a campus ambassador programme. College bookstores and gift boutiques suit $10 makeup.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Retail Account Manager

    First action

    Build the $150 starter assortment.

    How to measure it

    Active Faire retailers

    Now
    –
    Target
    50
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Build assortment

      $150 starter pack.

      Retail Account Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Make a display

      Counter unit.

      Founder & CEO 1 month

    3. 3

      List targets

      100 stores.

      Retail Account Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Pitch

      Email and Faire messages.

      Retail Account Manager 1 month

    5. 5

      Follow up

      Reorder reminders.

      Retail Account Manager monthly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Accounts and reorders.

      Retail Account Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Display costs
    Owner
    Retail Account Manager

    Smallest test

    Pitch 20 boutiques this month.

    Why it works

    Build a $150 starter assortment (Eye Crayons, Cream Blush, lip trio, display), list it on Faire, and pitch 100 campus stores and boutiques with the Faire first-order offer.

    Small retailers reorder steadily and put the brand in front of new shoppers.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Small orders cost time

      Keep the starter pack fixed.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteWholesale page: wholesale runs through Faire with a $150 order minimum, shipping from New Jersey with a 1-3 day lead time, free returns and 60-day payment terms for retailers.Source
    • Your websiteOlder pages still in the sitemap: /pages/revised-referral ("redeem free M2U NYC makeup products when it launches in late 2019"), /pages/design-contest (a packaging art contest that ran April 15-26, 2019), /pages/covid-19, /pages/refer-a-friend-ijy (a heading with no programme under it), /pages/partnerships (only the heading "Campus Ambassador") and /pages/campus-ambassador (reps who promote "on-campus pop up stores").Source
    • Your websiteH-E-B page: "Click the Map Below to Find Over 200 H-E-B Locations Carrying M2U NYC Products"; "Shop over 60 SKUs in the Beauty Department: Tools & Trends section"; a link to an M2U NYC search on heb.com. The press page lists a Beauty Independent article on the brand's retail expansion with H-E-B, alongside BuzzFeed, Bustle, Brit + Co, Essence, CEW Awards 2024 and a 2025 Editors Choice Award.Source
  • 16

    The site has two referral pages from 2019 and an empty refer-a-friend page, so the programme exists in name but not in practice. At $10-$15, friends sharing shades is how budget beauty spreads.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 quarter Marketing Manager

    First action

    Pick a referral app that connects to Klaviyo.

    How to measure it

    Referral orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    5% of orders
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Pick an app

      Klaviyo integration.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Set reward

      Give $5, get $5.

      Founder & CEO 1 day

    3. 3

      Build page

      Replace the old pages.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day

    4. 4

      Add prompts

      Thank-you page and emails.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    5. 5

      Launch

      Email to customers.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    6. 6

      Measure

      Referral orders.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Referral rewards
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Email the offer to 500 recent customers.

    Why it works

    Launch a simple give-$5, get-$5 referral with a Klaviyo-connected referral app, shown after checkout and in the post-purchase emails.

    Referred customers cost less and trust the brand faster.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Reward abuse

      Pay on first orders only.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteOlder pages still in the sitemap: /pages/revised-referral ("redeem free M2U NYC makeup products when it launches in late 2019"), /pages/design-contest (a packaging art contest that ran April 15-26, 2019), /pages/covid-19, /pages/refer-a-friend-ijy (a heading with no programme under it), /pages/partnerships (only the heading "Campus Ambassador") and /pages/campus-ambassador (reps who promote "on-campus pop up stores").Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source

Big bets 3

Larger plays that can change the trajectory.

  • 17

    H-E-B carries over 60 SKUs in over 200 stores, and Beauty Independent covered the expansion. That sell-through is the best pitch for the next regional grocer or drugstore chain.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 3 quarters Founder & CEO

    First action

    Pull sales per store per week from H-E-B.

    How to measure it

    Doors outside H-E-B

    Now
    –
    Target
    200
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Gather data

      Sell-through by store.

      Retail Account Manager 1 month

    2. 2

      Build deck

      One page.

      Retail Account Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Pick targets

      Three chains.

      Founder & CEO 1 week

    4. 4

      Pitch

      Buyers and brokers.

      Founder & CEO 1 quarter

    5. 5

      Plan supply

      Inventory for launch.

      Founder & CEO 1 quarter

    6. 6

      Launch

      With the website link.

      Retail Account Manager 1 quarter

    First result
    3 quarters
    Cost
    Slotting and inventory
    Owner
    Founder & CEO

    Smallest test

    Send the deck to one chain.

    Why it works

    Build a one-page sell-in deck with H-E-B sales per store, the reviews, the awards and price position, and pitch three regional chains outside Texas.

    A second retailer spreads risk and multiplies reach, and the first one is the proof.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Cash tied in inventory

      Start with a test region.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteH-E-B page: "Click the Map Below to Find Over 200 H-E-B Locations Carrying M2U NYC Products"; "Shop over 60 SKUs in the Beauty Department: Tools & Trends section"; a link to an M2U NYC search on heb.com. The press page lists a Beauty Independent article on the brand's retail expansion with H-E-B, alongside BuzzFeed, Bustle, Brit + Co, Essence, CEW Awards 2024 and a 2025 Editors Choice Award.Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteFAQ and Our Story: prices "consistently 60% to 80% less than typical makeup brands" because the brand sources directly and uses no "middlemen, celebrity marketing, nor traditional ads"; "certified by PETA as a Vegan and Cruelty-Free brand"; the founder spent a decade as a beauty executive at L'Oreal and Estee Lauder; "20 products across 120 SKUs" at $5 to $15; designed in New York City.Source
  • 18

    The blog follows the trends (Taylor Swift's orange, the Nina Park Effect, a 90s look) and the Eye Crayon has the most reviews. New shades are added slowly and as separate pages.

    High impactHigh effort First result in 3 quarters Founder & CEO

    First action

    Choose the next two shades.

    How to measure it

    Eye Crayon orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    +30%
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Plan shades

      Two a quarter.

      Founder & CEO 1 month

    2. 2

      Produce

      Small runs.

      Founder & CEO 1 quarter

    3. 3

      Waitlist

      Signup before launch.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Seed creators

      Two weeks early.

      Social & Creator Manager 2 weeks

    5. 5

      Launch

      As variants.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    6. 6

      Review

      Keep or retire shades.

      Founder & CEO quarterly

    First result
    3 quarters
    Cost
    Production runs
    Owner
    Founder & CEO

    Smallest test

    Run one limited shade first.

    Why it works

    Release two limited Eye Crayon shades each quarter, named for NYC places as now, announced to the waitlist and creators first, and added as variants of the parent page.

    Drops give regulars a reason to return and creators something new to post.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Leftover stock

      Small runs and clear retirements.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Your websiteBlog: 35 posts; the latest is "Carolyn Bessette-Kennedy Makeup: Recreate Her Iconic '90s Beauty Look" (March 6, 2026), before it "Mastering the Nina Park Effect" (January 2026) and Taylor Swift's "Showgirl Era" look (October 2025). A post published October 20, 2025 is titled "Top Movie-Inspired Halloween Makeup Trends for 2023". Others: "Steal These 3 Met Gala Makeup Looks Using Dupes Under $15", "Affordable Quality Makeup Dupes You Need to Know About", "Pair Your Lipstick with Your Skin Tone" and two hooded-eye guides.Source
    • Your catalogueShade and product names come from New York: Eye Crayon "Pearl St" and "Greenwich V", Metallic Liquid Lip "Empire State", eyeshadow palettes "Lady Liberty", "Concrete Jungle", "Uptown Downtown" and "BKB"; the FAQ says the company is in downtown NYC ("come say hi if you are nearby!").Source
    • Your catalogueEight shades are also listed as separate single-shade products, each with its own canonical URL: Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink (added October 15, 2026, 0 reviews, while the Eye Crayon page has 186 reviews averaging 4.83); Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann ($10 and 0 reviews, while Ann is $12 on the Metallic Liquid Lip page with 96 reviews), - Dream, - Copper (URL /products/metallic-liquid-lip-rose-gold-copy) and - Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow - Shimmer Warm Champagne, - Matte Dusty Rose and - Matte Terracotta (URL /products/liquid-shadow-matte-dusty-rose-copy).Source
  • 19

    The shipping page asks shoppers to say which country should be next, so international demand is being collected but not served.

    Medium impactHigh effort First result in 2 quarters Founder & CEO

    First action

    Count international requests from the inbox.

    How to measure it

    Canada orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    200 a month
    By
    4 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Count demand

      Inbox and cart attempts.

      Customer Experience Lead 1 week

    2. 2

      Check rules

      Cosmetics labelling for Canada.

      Founder & CEO 1 month

    3. 3

      Set up Markets

      Prices and duties.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Pick carrier

      Rates and times.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Test ads

      Small budget.

      Marketing Manager 1 month

    6. 6

      Decide

      Next country.

      Founder & CEO 1 quarter

    First result
    2 quarters
    Cost
    Compliance and shipping
    Owner
    Founder & CEO

    Smallest test

    Survey the people who asked.

    Why it works

    Count the requests, turn on Shopify Markets for Canada with duties included, and test a small paid campaign before adding more countries.

    Canada is close, cheap to reach from New Jersey and shares the same beauty trends.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Labelling rules

      Check bilingual label requirements before launch.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteShipping and returns: free USPS Standard over $30, $4.99 under $30, Priority $12.99; orders ship within 2 business days; "we are not able to ship internationally at this time. Please drop us a line and let us know which country we should go next!"; refunds "less shipping within 90 days".Source
    • Your websiteWholesale page: wholesale runs through Faire with a $150 order minimum, shipping from New Jersey with a 1-3 day lead time, free returns and 60-day payment terms for retailers.Source

Wildcards 4

Unexpected experiments, each with a cheap way to test it.

  • 20

    The store publishes agents.md for AI shopping assistants that can search and check out for a shopper. They will see two prices for Ann, offers in product names and shades split from their reviews.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Ecommerce Manager

    First action

    Ask two assistants for vegan makeup under $15 and note the answers.

    How to measure it

    Queries where M2U NYC is suggested

    Now
    –
    Target
    5 of 20
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Baseline

      20 queries.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Clean data

      After ideas 1 and 4.

      Ecommerce Manager 2 weeks

    3. 3

      Rewrite descriptions

      Top 15 products.

      Marketing Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Add ingredients

      Key skincare actives.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Retest

      Same queries.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 month

    6. 6

      Repeat

      Quarterly.

      Ecommerce Manager quarterly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Ecommerce Manager

    Smallest test

    Run the 20-query baseline.

    Why it works

    After the single-shade cleanup, write clear product descriptions with shade, finish and skincare ingredients, and test what assistants recommend for "vegan eye crayon under $15".

    Assistants favour clear, consistent product data, and budget beauty is a common query.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Assistants change often

      Retest quarterly.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteThe store publishes Shopify's agents.md and an agentic discovery sitemap, so AI shopping assistants can search the catalogue, build carts and check out for a shopper; they read the same product names, prices and reviews that people see.Source
    • Your catalogueEight shades are also listed as separate single-shade products, each with its own canonical URL: Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink (added October 15, 2026, 0 reviews, while the Eye Crayon page has 186 reviews averaging 4.83); Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann ($10 and 0 reviews, while Ann is $12 on the Metallic Liquid Lip page with 96 reviews), - Dream, - Copper (URL /products/metallic-liquid-lip-rose-gold-copy) and - Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow - Shimmer Warm Champagne, - Matte Dusty Rose and - Matte Terracotta (URL /products/liquid-shadow-matte-dusty-rose-copy).Source
    • Your catalogueOffers are written into product names: "Everyday Glam Eye Set – Save 20% + Free Shipping" ($34), "Metallic Liquid Lip Trio (Free Shipping + Free Gift, 35% OFF)" ($30), "Lip Trio – Pick Your Shades (17% OFF + Free Shipping)" ($30, 90 shade combinations), "Customizable Everyday Makeup Kit (4 Products + Free Shipping)" ($45) and "Makeup Starter Box Set (FREE SHIPPING)" ($49).Source
  • 21

    Shades are named Pearl St, Greenwich V, Empire State, Lady Liberty, Concrete Jungle, Uptown Downtown and BKB, and the team is in downtown NYC.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Social & Creator Manager

    First action

    Film Pearl St on Pearl Street.

    How to measure it

    Video views

    Now
    –
    Target
    200,000
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      List shades

      Seven NYC names.

      Social & Creator Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Plan shoots

      One a week.

      Social & Creator Manager 1 week

    3. 3

      Film

      Phone video.

      Social & Creator Manager weekly

    4. 4

      Build map page

      Shade pins.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 1 week

    5. 5

      Post

      TikTok and Instagram.

      Social & Creator Manager weekly

    6. 6

      Measure

      Views and product clicks.

      Social & Creator Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    Staff time
    Owner
    Social & Creator Manager

    Smallest test

    Film one shade this week.

    Why it works

    Film one short video per shade at its namesake place, wearing the shade, with a pin on a shareable map page that links to each product.

    It turns the product names into a story competitors cannot copy and gives creators a ready format.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Low reach at first

      Boost the best two.

    Evidence

    • Your catalogueShade and product names come from New York: Eye Crayon "Pearl St" and "Greenwich V", Metallic Liquid Lip "Empire State", eyeshadow palettes "Lady Liberty", "Concrete Jungle", "Uptown Downtown" and "BKB"; the FAQ says the company is in downtown NYC ("come say hi if you are nearby!").Source
    • Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
    • Competitor researchRivals' own homepages: e.l.f. Cosmetics sells "affordable, high-quality makeup and skincare" that is "Vegan and cruelty-free"; ColourPop and wet n wild sell low-priced colour cosmetics online and through mass retail.Source
  • 22

    The FAQ says prices are 60-80% less than typical brands because there are no middlemen or celebrity marketing, but the site never shows it.

    Medium impactLow effort First result in 1 month Marketing Manager

    First action

    Gather category average prices.

    How to measure it

    Page visitors who buy

    Now
    –
    Target
    6%
    By
    1 quarter

    Steps

    1. 1

      Gather prices

      Category averages.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    2. 2

      Calculate

      Cost per gram.

      Marketing Manager 1 day

    3. 3

      Write page

      Savings explained.

      Marketing Manager 1 week

    4. 4

      Design

      Simple chart.

      Shopify Developer (contract) 2 days

    5. 5

      Link

      From FAQ and products.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 day

    6. 6

      Measure

      Visits to orders.

      Ecommerce Manager monthly

    First result
    1 month
    Cost
    $0
    Owner
    Marketing Manager

    Smallest test

    Add one comparison to the Eye Crayon page.

    Why it works

    Make one page that compares cost per gram of an Eye Crayon, cream blush and liquid lip with typical prestige prices (no brand names, just category averages), and explain where the savings come from.

    Shoppers who buy on value want proof, and the page answers "is it really that cheap?".

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Comparison claims

      Use category averages and date the page.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteFAQ and Our Story: prices "consistently 60% to 80% less than typical makeup brands" because the brand sources directly and uses no "middlemen, celebrity marketing, nor traditional ads"; "certified by PETA as a Vegan and Cruelty-Free brand"; the founder spent a decade as a beauty executive at L'Oreal and Estee Lauder; "20 products across 120 SKUs" at $5 to $15; designed in New York City.Source
    • Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
    • Competitor researchRivals' own homepages: e.l.f. Cosmetics sells "affordable, high-quality makeup and skincare" that is "Vegan and cruelty-free"; ColourPop and wet n wild sell low-priced colour cosmetics online and through mass retail.Source
  • 23

    The campus ambassador page still describes on-campus pop-ups and reps. Students are the core budget-beauty audience and now find products on TikTok.

    Medium impactMedium effort First result in 1 quarter Social & Creator Manager

    First action

    Update the campus page and open applications.

    How to measure it

    Campus orders

    Now
    –
    Target
    300 a term
    By
    2 quarters

    Steps

    1. 1

      Rewrite page

      Creator-first.

      Social & Creator Manager 1 day

    2. 2

      Recruit

      20 students.

      Social & Creator Manager 1 month

    3. 3

      Send kits

      Pop-up and samples.

      Social & Creator Manager 2 weeks

    4. 4

      Track

      Affiliate links.

      Ecommerce Manager 1 week

    5. 5

      Feature

      Best posts.

      Social & Creator Manager monthly

    6. 6

      Renew

      Each term.

      Social & Creator Manager term

    First result
    1 quarter
    Cost
    Kits and commission
    Owner
    Social & Creator Manager

    Smallest test

    Recruit five ambassadors first.

    Why it works

    Recruit 20 student creators at schools near H-E-B stores and in New York, pay commission through the affiliate programme, and give each a dorm pop-up kit.

    Student creators reach the right audience cheaply and become long-term fans.

    Risks and how to handle them

    • Uneven effort

      Pay on sales.

    Evidence

    • Your websiteOlder pages still in the sitemap: /pages/revised-referral ("redeem free M2U NYC makeup products when it launches in late 2019"), /pages/design-contest (a packaging art contest that ran April 15-26, 2019), /pages/covid-19, /pages/refer-a-friend-ijy (a heading with no programme under it), /pages/partnerships (only the heading "Campus Ambassador") and /pages/campus-ambassador (reps who promote "on-campus pop up stores").Source
    • Your websiteCommunity page: "Apply to earn affiliate commission and get early access to our new launches", US addresses only; partnership types listed as affiliate marketing, gifting and discount codes. A text-message signup page offers automated marketing texts "(e.g. cart reminders)"; the newsletter runs on Klaviyo and reviews on Judge.me.Source
    • Your websiteH-E-B page: "Click the Map Below to Find Over 200 H-E-B Locations Carrying M2U NYC Products"; "Shop over 60 SKUs in the Beauty Department: Tools & Trends section"; a link to an M2U NYC search on heb.com. The press page lists a Beauty Independent article on the brand's retail expansion with H-E-B, alongside BuzzFeed, Bustle, Brit + Co, Essence, CEW Awards 2024 and a 2025 Editors Choice Award.Source

03

How Programmable can help

Where an idea in this playbook is something Programmable builds or runs, it's listed here with what we'd do. Everything else is yours to run.

ProgrammableDigital

Show it, don't just describe it

These ideas need something to show: a demo, a video, an animation, graphics or a deck. Digital turns screenshots or the site into all of them, in the company's own brand.

Make a demo (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
More example playbooks and reviews

More growth playbooks

Other companies we have researched, each read from what they are hiring for.

  • Mirai Clinical growth strategyA Nevada body-care brand, seen on Shark Tank, making Japanese persimmon soaps, body washes, shampoos, wipes, deodorant and laundry and…20 growth ideas
  • Hale growth strategyAn internal nasal dilator (the Hale breathing aid) designed by a Johns Hopkins nasal surgeon, sold as a three-size trial kit with refills…21 growth ideas
  • Peakora growth strategyA go-to-market design and engineering firm from Baar, Switzerland. It builds AI-supported lead generation, sales, CRM and customer success…22 growth ideas
  • Stayhard growth strategyA Swedish online menswear store, founded in 2005, selling branded fashion, basics, shoes, watches and accessories on Shopify.21 growth ideas
  • Ninth Wave growth strategyOpen finance software for banks, credit unions, wealth managers and card issuers: FDX-standard APIs and consent for sharing customer data…21 growth ideas
  • Dynamic Creatures growth strategyBuilds mobile, interactive character robots for hospitality and entertainment, on Boston Dynamics and other platforms or as fully original…21 growth ideas
  • Rho growth strategyA finance platform for startups and growing companies: business banking and savings (through partner banks), corporate cards, bill pay…21 growth ideas
  • TrophySmack growth strategyMakes custom fantasy football trophies, championship belts, rings, turnover chains, draft boards, loser awards and WallSmack metal art in…21 growth ideas

See every playbook and website review

Independent research. Programmable wrote this playbook from public sources, as they stood on October 21, 2026, and cites them throughout. M2U NYC did not commission, review or endorse it, and Programmable is not affiliated with M2U NYC. Company and product names are trademarks of their owners, used only to identify them. The ideas are suggestions and opinion, not professional, legal or financial advice, and not statements about how M2U NYC runs its business.

Something wrong, or do you represent M2U NYC? Email [email protected] and we will correct it or take it down.

30/60/90 roadmap

What to focus on in each month, and the ideas that carry it.

  1. Days 1 to 308 ideas

    Single-shade cleanup, waitlists, the free-shipping bar, clean product names, stale pages and storefront fixes; email signing and refill flows.

  2. Days 31 to 6010 ideas

    H-E-B badges and insert, Spanish pages, reviews for new lines, Eye Crayon creators, build-your-trio, the shade finder, Faire wholesale and referrals; AI readiness and the NYC series.

  3. Days 61 to 905 ideas

    Second retailer, quarterly shade drops, Canada, the price comparison page and the campus creators.

The research behind the plan

2 research areas, each summarised in a few lines. Open any of them for the full detail.

Customers

What customers say

Customers value bright, pigmented colour at $10-$12. The most cited problem: free shipping needs $30 when products cost $10.

  • Vegan, cruelty-free and paraben-free
  • Favourites sold out
  • In their words: “obsessed”

Market

Competitive landscape

3 competitors compared: e.l.f. Cosmetics, ColourPop and wet n wild.

  • Gap to exploit: Skincare-infused makeup at under $15
  • e.l.f. Cosmetics: Less personal brand story
  • ColourPop: Crowded catalogue

From the team that wrote this playbook

All products
  • ProgrammableAgencyWorking AI systems in days, not quarters (opens programmable.agency in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableInfoAn agent that finds, researches and asks firstNew accounts get 100,000 free enrichment credits with code BETA100K (opens programmable.info in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableDigitalScreenshots in, an animated product demo out (opens programmable.digital in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableWatchKnow the day a supplier falls out of compliance (opens programmable.watch in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableTalkGet registrants for your events, and know who’s coming (opens programmable.talk in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableMediaAn AI note taker, interpreter and webinar host for your calls (opens programmable.media in a new tab)
  • ProgrammablePageText what you need, your customer gets a page that works (opens programmable.page in a new tab)
  • ProgrammableCommunityForums with labelled AI members, never empty (opens programmable.community in a new tab)
ProgrammableMarketing
ExamplesLeaderboardsProductsTermsPrivacyCookiesDPALegalContact

© 2026 AI-Powered Growth Intelligence