Your newest shade, Eye Crayon Passionate Pink, went live on October 15 as its own product page with 0 reviews, while the same shade sits in the Eye Crayon page beside 186 reviews averaging 4.83. Seven more shades are split the same way: Metallic Liquid Lip Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold, and three Liquid Shadows. Two of them even live at URLs ending in "-copy" that name a different shade, and Ann costs $10 on its own page but $12 on the main one. A shopper who lands on a single-shade page sees no social proof and a different price from the one she sees a click away.
First action
Redirect Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink to the Eye Crayon page with Passionate Pink selected.
How to measure it
Orders of the eight shades
- Now
- –
- Target
- +20%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
List the duplicates
The eight single-shade products and their parents.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Decide each
Redirect to the parent, or keep for ads and share reviews.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Fix the price
One price for Ann everywhere.
Founder & CEO 15 minutes
Set redirects
Each old URL to the parent with the shade selected.
Ecommerce Manager 2 hours
Group reviews
Share parent reviews on any page you keep.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Update links
Ads, emails and social bios that used the old URLs.
Marketing Manager 2 hours
Change the launch habit
New shades as variants with a "New shade" badge.
Ecommerce Manager ongoing
Measure
Conversion on the shades before and after.
Ecommerce Manager 60 days
Why it works
Keep one page per product. Redirect each single-shade URL to its parent with that shade preselected (Shopify can link straight to a variant), or, if the separate pages exist for ads, show the parent's reviews on them using your review app's product grouping. Settle the Ann price at one number. From now on, launch new shades as a variant of the parent with a "New shade" badge, so they inherit its reviews from day one.
Reviews are the strongest conversion signal in low-price beauty, and splitting them hands every new shade a cold start. One page per product also concentrates search ranking, and gives AI shopping assistants one clear answer instead of two prices for the same lipstick.
Ready to use
ChecklistSingle-shade cleanup
[ ] Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink -> /products/eye-crayon?variant=<Passionate Pink> [ ] Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann, Dream, Copper, Rose Gold -> /products/metallic-liquid-lip?variant=<shade> [ ] Liquid Shadow - Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose, Matte Terracotta -> /products/liquid-eyeshadow-matte-shimmer?variant=<shade> [ ] One price for Ann [ ] Ads, emails and bios updated [ ] New shades launched as variants from now on
Risks and how to handle them
Ads point to the old pages
Redirects keep them working; update the ads within a week.
Losing the single-shade search result
The parent page ranks for the shade name when it is in the variant title.
Evidence
- Your catalogueEight shades are also listed as separate single-shade products, each with its own canonical URL: Eye Crayon - Passionate Pink (added October 15, 2026, 0 reviews, while the Eye Crayon page has 186 reviews averaging 4.83); Metallic Liquid Lip - Ann ($10 and 0 reviews, while Ann is $12 on the Metallic Liquid Lip page with 96 reviews), - Dream, - Copper (URL /products/metallic-liquid-lip-rose-gold-copy) and - Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow - Shimmer Warm Champagne, - Matte Dusty Rose and - Matte Terracotta (URL /products/liquid-shadow-matte-dusty-rose-copy).Source
- Your catalogueProduct feed (45 products, read October 20, 2026): median price $12. Eye Crayon has 10 shades at $10 including Passionate Pink; Metallic Liquid Lip has 10 shades at $12 including Ann, Dream, Copper and Rose Gold; Liquid Shadow has 10 shades at $10 including Warm Champagne, Matte Dusty Rose and Matte Terracotta.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): title "Skincare-Infused Makeup at Affordable Prices"; meta description "Affordable makeup essentials all under $15", "free US shipping over $30"; banners "100% VEGAN. Cruelty-Free. Paraben-Free" and "Over 2 MILLION Products Sold"; a tile "SHOP M2U NYC at Over 200 H-E-B Stores". Fan favourites: Eye Crayon (186 reviews, $10), Cream Blush (154 reviews, $12) and Liquid Shadow (4 reviews, $10, described as "NEW LAUNCH!"). Store-wide reviews block: "from 1333 reviews". The footer icon titled "M2U NYC on Tumblr" links to the TikTok account @m2u_nyc.Source
- Your websiteThe store publishes Shopify's agents.md and an agentic discovery sitemap, so AI shopping assistants can search the catalogue, build carts and check out for a shopper; they read the same product names, prices and reviews that people see.Source