WhatTheFont is MyFonts' widest door: 3.7M+ installs on Android alone. But it is rated 2.69 on Android (7.9K ratings) and 2.4 on the App Store (591 ratings), and the reviews give the same two reasons. Matches seem to lean to fonts MyFonts sells ("overlooks commonly available font matches"; on Trustpilot in May 2026, "only found paid results"), and searches fail with server errors. The latest iOS release notes say only "minor fixes". Low ratings push the app down store results and lower install rates, and millions of people form their view of the MyFonts brand before they ever reach the store.
First action
Pull 90 days of WhatTheFont searches: failure rate by app version, and how often the top result is a paid font compared with what the user does next.
How to measure it
WhatTheFont new-rating average (rolling 90 days)
- Now
- –
- Target
- 4.0 or higher
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Measure failures
Error and timeout rate per search, by platform and app version.
Mobile Engineering Lead 2 days
Tag the reviews
Last 500 reviews on both stores, tagged by reason: wrong match, paid-only, error, other.
Product Manager, WhatTheFont 2 days
Label the results
Closest match first with "On MyFonts", "Free font" or "On your device", then similar licensable fonts.
Product Manager, WhatTheFont 2 weeks
Fix the errors
Automatic retry, keep the crop, offer the forum fallback.
Mobile Engineering Lead 2 weeks
Ask at the right moment
Native review prompt only after a saved or tapped match.
Mobile Engineering Lead 2 days
Reply and explain
Answer recent low reviews; write release notes that say what changed.
Customer Support Lead 1 week
Track
New-rating average, install conversion, taps to MyFonts and revenue per search.
Data Analyst weekly
Why it works
Make three changes. 1) Honest results: show the visually closest match first with a clear label ("On MyFonts", "Free font" or "On your device"), then the licensable fonts most like it. A user who trusts the first answer is more likely to buy one of the alternatives. 2) Reliability: measure the failure rate of every search, retry automatically, keep the user's crop when something fails and offer the manual identification forum as a fallback. 3) Ratings: show the built-in store review prompt only after a user saves or taps a match, reply to recent low reviews with what has changed, and write release notes that explain the changes. Track new-rating averages, install conversion and taps through to MyFonts.
Store rating drives both ranking and the share of viewers who install. Changing who gets asked (people who just succeeded) and why people complain (failed or slanted results) moves new ratings quickly, while the closest match builds the trust that sells the licensable alternatives.
Ready to use
ChecklistWhatTheFont rating recovery list
[ ] Failure rate per search, by platform and version [ ] 500 reviews tagged by reason [ ] Closest match first, labelled On MyFonts / Free font / On your device [ ] Similar licensable fonts under the closest match [ ] Retry and keep the crop on errors [ ] Forum fallback when no match [ ] Review prompt only after a saved or tapped match [ ] Replies to recent low reviews [ ] Release notes that say what changed [ ] Weekly: new-rating average, install rate, revenue per search
Risks and how to handle them
Showing free matches first lowers sales
Show licensable look-alikes on the same screen and compare revenue per search before and after.
Prompt fatigue
The stores limit how often the prompt appears; trigger it only after a successful match.
Evidence
- App dataWhatTheFont on Android (com.monotype.whatthefont, developer Monotype): 3.7M+ installs and 2.69 stars from 7.9K ratings, labelled "poor"; last updated October 5, 2026.Source
- App StoreWhatTheFont for iPhone, iPad and Mac (seller MyFonts Inc., free, "powered by AI"): 2.4 out of 5 from 591 ratings; version 3.0.23 (October 7) notes only "minor fixes". Reviews say it "overlooks commonly available font matches", suspect licensing shapes the results, and report server connection errors.Source
- ReviewsTrustpilot (UK): 2.1 out of 5 from 27 reviews, 67% one-star, only 3 reviews in the last 12 months and no recent history of inviting customers to review. Recent themes: the font identifier "only found paid results" (May 2026); free fonts asking for payment details ("Why should I give MyFonts my payment data for free stuff?", 2025); web licences charged yearly but sized on monthly pageviews; support that takes "days, sometimes weeks to reply" (March 2026).Source