Hair Putty has 3,178 Yotpo reviews and Sea Salt Spray 2,213 averaging 4.8, but the theme's product markup tells search engines every one of these pages has a 5.0 rating from exactly 5 reviews. On Texture Powder the page carries two different ratings at once. Search engines tend to ignore or distrust rating markup that contradicts the page, so the brand's strongest proof, years of reviews, is not reliably reaching search results or AI shopping assistants.
First action
Open the product template and find the block that prints "reviewCount":"5".
How to measure it
Top-20 products with valid review markup
- Now
- –
- Target
- 20 of 20
- By
- 30 days
Steps
Find the block
The hard-coded rating in the product template.
Shopify Developer 1 hour
Pick one source
Yotpo or the review metafields, not both.
Shopify Developer 2 hours
Handle kits
No rating where a product has no reviews.
Shopify Developer 2 hours
Test
Rich Results Test on the top 20 products.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Resubmit
Request indexing in Search Console.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Watch
Review snippets and click-through for a month.
Ecommerce Manager weekly
Why it works
Remove the hard-coded rating block from the product template and keep one rating source: Yotpo's real count and average, or the Shopify review metafields the theme already loads. Check the top 20 products in Google's Rich Results Test, resubmit them in Search Console, and make sure kits without their own reviews show no rating rather than a made-up one.
Star ratings with a real count ("4.8, 2,213 reviews") are among the strongest click drivers on product searches, and accurate markup removes a mismatch that could cost the stars entirely.
Ready to use
ChecklistReview markup fix
[ ] Remove the hard-coded aggregateRating from the product template [ ] One rating source per page (Yotpo or review metafields) [ ] No rating on products with zero reviews [ ] Rich Results Test: Putty, Salt, Texture Powder, Combo Sets [ ] Request indexing for the top 20 [ ] Recheck after every theme update
Risks and how to handle them
A theme update brings the block back
Note the change in the theme's changelog and recheck after updates.
Stars still not shown
Google decides; the goal is correct, consistent data.
Evidence
- Your websiteReview data vs. product markup (checked October 20, 2026): Yotpo shows 2,213 reviews averaging 4.8 on Natural Sea Salt Spray, 3,178 on Hair Putty and 1,791 on the Shampoo & Conditioner Combo Sets, but the structured data the theme gives search engines on each of those pages says "ratingValue":"5", "reviewCount":"5". Texture & Volume Styling Powder carries two conflicting ratings on the same page: the theme's 5 from 5 reviews and Yotpo's 4.7 from 356.Source
- Your websiteHomepage: "1M+ Happy Customers!"; "As Seen on Shark Tank Season 7 Episode 29"; as seen in Esquire, GQ, AskMen, VICE and InsideHook; Sea Salt Spray is the "#1 Best Seller"; a hair quiz offers 15% off; Build A Kit gives 10% off $60+ orders; menus by hair type and a "Problem Solvers" menu (dandruff, thinning hair, body odor, patchy beard and more); free US shipping on $50+ orders; a Women section.Source
- Your websiteThe store publishes an /agents.md file and Shopify's Universal Commerce Protocol endpoints, so AI shopping assistants are invited to search the catalogue and build carts from the product data as it is.Source