Kentucky Bourbon is "Our signature bar", with 1,158 bars sold and 50 reviews at 92% five stars, and today its page says Sold Out with nowhere to leave an email. The "Recommended For You" row suggests the same sold-out bar. Meanwhile the Kentucky Bourbon 3-Pack and 6-Pack are in stock. It is not just one bar: 7 of 15 products in The Prohibition Collection and 5 of the 10 Top Reviewed Products are sold out right now. The most-wanted products are the ones visitors can't buy.
First action
Turn on Klaviyo back-in-stock for the 16 sold-out products today.
How to measure it
Back-in-stock signups
- Now
- –
- Target
- 300 in 60 days
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Turn on alerts
Klaviyo back-in-stock form on sold-out product pages.
Marketing and Email (part-time) 2 hours
Write the message
"Next batch is curing" with an honest timing.
Founder and Soap Maker 30 minutes
Link the packs
Kentucky Bourbon page links to the 3-Pack and 6-Pack.
Founder and Soap Maker 30 minutes
Fix recommendations
Exclude sold-out items from Recommended For You.
Marketing and Email (part-time) 1 hour
Sort collections
In-stock items first.
Marketing and Email (part-time) 1 hour
Plan batches
Bestsellers first, sized by signups.
Founder and Soap Maker each cycle
Send the alert
Restock email the day bars are ready.
Marketing and Email (part-time) each restock
Measure
Signups, alert sales and pack sales.
Marketing and Email (part-time) monthly
Why it works
On every sold-out product, add a back-in-stock signup (Klaviyo, which the store already uses, has this built in) and a line such as "Next batch is curing; leave your email and we will tell you first". On Kentucky Bourbon, add a button to the in-stock 3-Pack and 6-Pack. Hide sold-out items from Recommended For You and sort them last in collections. Then make the bestsellers the first batch in each production cycle, and use the signup count to size it.
A restock list turns lost visits into a queue of buyers who are told the day the bar is back; redirecting to the packs saves the sale today; and putting sold-out items last keeps collections looking full.
Ready to use
ChecklistSold-out page checklist
[ ] Back-in-stock form on every sold-out product [ ] "Curing now" message instead of a bare Sold Out [ ] Link to an in-stock pack or similar scent [ ] Sold-out items excluded from recommendations [ ] Collections sorted in-stock first [ ] Restock email template ready [ ] Signup count reviewed before each batch
Risks and how to handle them
Alert emails arrive after stock sells out again
Hold back part of the batch for the alert list.
Promising dates you can't keep
Say "curing now" rather than a date.
Evidence
- Your websiteKentucky Bourbon product page (checked October 20, 2026): "Best Seller & Most Reviewed. Our signature bar. Our most-reviewed scent."; "Bars Sold - 1158"; 50 reviews, 92% five stars; $9.65 or Subscribe & Save every 1, 2 or 3 months; the button reads "Sold Out", with no back-in-stock signup, and the "Recommended For You" row shows the same sold-out bar.Source
- Your catalogueProduct feed, October 20, 2026: 160 products, 16 sold out, 14 of them bar soaps. The single Kentucky Bourbon bar is sold out while the Kentucky Bourbon 3-Pack ($24) and 6-Pack ($40) are in stock; the Soap Starter Kit ($30, four best-selling bars) is sold out.Source
- Your catalogueCollections: The Prohibition Collection has 7 of 15 products sold out (Kentucky Bourbon, Barbershop, Mojito, Ward Eight, Grandpa's Elixir, Gin Rickey, Soap Starter Kit); Top Reviewed Products has 5 of 10 sold out; the Reuniting After War Camo Collection has 4 of 8 sold out (full-size Jungle, Squid Wash and Smoke Pit, and the Smoke Pit sample).Source
- Your websiteHomepage: "722 Verified Reviews" (Judge.me); the search description says "Free shipping over $55. Veteran-owned small business."; a banner says the Area 51, Supernova, Spacewalk, Zero-Gravity, Sunday Dinner and Absinthe bars "are now even bigger At no extra charge"; Klaviyo email signup for "special offers, free giveaways"; Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Venmo and Shop Pay Installments.Source