The Point III is new and already has 97 reviews, but 14 are one-star and 17 of the 22 reviews at three stars or below are about size, width or the heel slipping, many from people who own several earlier Points. The old Point ran small (customers sized up half or a full size) and the Point III fits true to size, yet the fit guide has no Point III entry and the product page says only "Fits true to size." A loyal customer who orders her usual Point size gets a shoe that is too big, and once worn it cannot be returned.
First action
Read the 22 low Point III reviews with the fit team and write the two-sentence size note.
How to measure it
Point III reviews mentioning size or fit at 3 stars or below
- Now
- –
- Target
- -50%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Check the data
Compare usual size with size purchased in Point III reviews and returns.
Senior Manager, Product Development 2 days
Write the note
Two sentences for Point and Point II owners, approved by product development.
Product Manager Lead (Front End) 1 day
Place it
Next to the size picker on all 13 Point III colours.
Ecommerce Manager 1 day
Update the fit guide
Add a Point III entry beside The Point and The Point II.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Brief stores
Same advice for store teams and customer care.
Director of Retail 2 days
Email past Point buyers
Size advice before they order the new version.
Email and CRM Manager 1 week
Measure
Exchanges, returns and review mix before and after.
Product Manager Lead (Front End) weekly
Why it works
Add a short "Coming from The Point or Point II?" block next to the size picker: "If you sized up in The Point, order your true size in the Point III; if your heel is narrow, consider half a size down", plus the toe-box and vamp changes in one line. Add the Point III to the fit guide, use the review form's "usual size" and "size purchased" answers to check the advice, and show a "Fit for Point II owners" filter on reviews.
Many Point III buyers are repeat Point customers (16 reviews compare it with the older Point), so one sentence at the size picker prevents the wrong order, the one-star review that follows it, and the return or lost customer.
Ready to use
CopySize note for the Point III page
Coming from The Point or Point II? The Point III fits true to size. If you sized up in the original Point, order your true size here. Narrow heel? Many customers prefer half a size down. Not sure? Try them indoors first: unworn pairs exchange free within 30 days.
Risks and how to handle them
Advice is wrong for some feet
Phrase it as a starting point and link to customer care for a fit chat.
It highlights the complaints
Frame it as the new, truer fit the Point III was designed for.
Evidence
- Customer reviewsThe Point III (new; reviews start September 24, 2026): 97 reviews averaging 4.1 stars, with 14 one-star reviews. Of the 22 reviews at three stars or below, 17 are about size, fit, width or the heel; 16 reviews compare it with the older Point, e.g. "The old point fit me perfectly. These are sliding off my narrow heel" and "I have 8 pair of point both 1 and 2 the 3 fits totally different". A happy buyer: "True to size, no more sizing up a 1/2 or full size like the original point." By contrast the Ivy Sneaker averages 4.7 from 308 reviews.Source
- Your websiteFit guide and product page: the women's fit guide covers The Point ("most customers go up half a size for narrow feet, and a full size for wider feet") and The Point II ("runs true to size ... we suggest going half a size up" for wider feet), but has no entry for The Point III. The Point III page says only "Fits true to size." and "Wide sizes only available online", with no note for owners of earlier Points.Source
- Your websiteReturns: "easy returns and exchanges on unworn, unwashed merchandise with attached tags within 30 days"; "Worn, washed, or altered merchandise will not be accepted"; mail-in exchanges are free, mail-in refunds cost $7.99; items that cannot be returned are pointed to Poshmark for resale.Source
- Your websiteMeet The Point III page: "Lower V-shaped vamp. More arch support. Roomier toe box. And a sharper silhouette ... It's our best flat yet." The Point III sells in 13 colours at $165 while The Point II is still sold.Source
- HiringProduct Manager Lead (Front End), Director level, still open: builds a team of product managers for "Ecommerce/Marketing, Retail, and Wholesale", partners "with Marketing and Retail leaders to enhance digital customer journeys, in-store experiences, personalization, and conversion optimization", and acts as "the executive voice of the customer".Source