Your highest-priced products are two versions of the Cellular Nutrition Program: with Restore Pro at $472 and with Restore Non-Pro at $409. The Non-Pro page was made by duplicating the Pro one and kept its address: /products/copy-of-cellular-nutrition-program-with-restore-pro-vanilla-veggie-protein. So search results, shared links and AI assistants see "copy-of" and "restore-pro" on the page for the product that is not Pro, and a buyer comparing two pages that look alike has no clear reason to choose either. The same choice appears again with Restore Professional ($260) and Restore Veggie ($186).
First action
Rename the Non-Pro program handle with a redirect today.
How to measure it
Program page conversion
- Now
- –
- Target
- +15%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Find copies
Export products whose handle starts "copy-of".
Ecommerce Manager 30 minutes
Rename
Handle that matches the title, redirect ticked.
Ecommerce Manager 30 minutes
Update links
Emails, Rebuy offers, blog posts and ads that use the old URL.
Ecommerce Manager 2 hours
Write the comparison
Formula difference, who it is for, price per day.
Marketing Manager 1 day
Add to pages
Both programs and both Restore formulas.
Shopify Developer (contract) 1 day
Add help
Calendly link for a short product call.
Customer Support Lead 1 hour
Measure
Conversion and the Pro/Non-Pro split.
Ecommerce Manager monthly
Why it works
Rename the Non-Pro handle to match its title (for example /products/dr-tennants-cellular-nutrition-program-with-restore-vanilla-veggie-protein), ticking Shopify's "create a URL redirect" box so old links keep working. Then add the same short comparison table to both program pages and both Restore pages: what is different in the formula, who each is for, price per day, and a "talk to us" link through the Calendly booking you already use. Search the catalogue for any other "copy-of" handles and fix them the same way.
A $400+ purchase needs a clear choice. A clean address stops the cheaper version looking like a duplicate of the expensive one, and a comparison helps buyers pick the right program instead of leaving to think about it.
Ready to use
ChecklistProgram page fix list
[ ] Rename copy-of-cellular-nutrition-program-with-restore-pro-vanilla-veggie-protein to a handle with "Non-Pro" or without "pro" [ ] "Create a URL redirect" ticked [ ] Old URL replaced in Klaviyo, Rebuy and blog links [ ] Comparison table: formula, who it is for, price per day [ ] Same table on Restore Professional and Restore Veggie pages [ ] Calendly "help me choose" link [ ] Check for other copy-of handles
Risks and how to handle them
Brief search wobble
The redirect carries the old URL's value; request indexing in Search Console.
Comparison sounds like a health claim
Describe ingredients and use, not outcomes.
Evidence
- Your catalogueTwo versions of the top-priced program sit side by side: "Cellular Nutrition Program - with Restore Pro VANILLA VEGGIE Protein" ($472) at /products/dr-tennants-cellular-nutrition-program-with-restore-pro-vanilla-veggie-protein, and "Cellular Nutrition Program - with Restore Non-Pro VANILLA VEGGIE Protein" ($409) at /products/copy-of-cellular-nutrition-program-with-restore-pro-vanilla-veggie-protein. The cheaper Non-Pro program lives on an address that starts "copy-of" (Shopify's prefix for a duplicated product) and says "restore-pro". A whey version of the Pro program is also $472.Source
- Your catalogueStore catalogue (programmable.info scan, October 20, 2026): 28 products in 40 collections, priced $10 to $472, median $82. Top products include GI 60 Probiotic Formula ($65, or $100 for 3 bottles), Ancient Earth ($50), Restore Professional Formula Veggie and Vanilla ($260), Restore Veggie Formula ($186), Gut Bootcamp Bundle ($224), Brain Food Plus ($128), Fungal Detox ($78), N1O1 Nitric Oxide Lozenges ($59.95), a Shaker Bottle Pro ($16.50) and an Essential Oils Carrying Case ($10).Source
- Your websiteStore setup: Shopify with Klaviyo email, Recart, Stamped.io reviews, Rebuy, Gorgias chat and help center, Calendly, Common Ninja widgets and Microsoft Clarity; Affirm, Apple Pay and Venmo at checkout; free shipping from $125; 30-day returns (not free); ships internationally. Site title: "Natural Health Supplements | Tennant Products".Source