A shopper on vintandyork.com today sees three different free-shipping rules. The bar at the top of every page says free shipping over $300; the benefits row on the homepage says over $250; the Shopify shipping policy says free shipping on orders of $150 or more; the Shipping and Handling page says $300 with $9.99 below it. The UK store shows the same "$300" line on GBP prices. The difference matters most at your price points: a $149 bestseller or a $269-$299 Italian frame clears one threshold but not another, so the shopper whose order is closest to the line is the one who reads the rule.
First action
Choose the threshold and edit the announcement bar and homepage row today.
How to measure it
Cart-to-order rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- +5%
- By
- 30 days
Steps
Decide the number
Compare margin and order values at $150, $250 and $300.
Founder & CEO 1 day
Edit the theme
Announcement bar and homepage benefits row.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Edit the policies
Shopify shipping policy and Shipping and Handling page.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Match checkout
Shipping rates in Shopify settings for each market.
Ecommerce Manager 2 hours
Localise
The threshold in GBP, CAD, AUD, EUR and JPY on the regional stores.
Ecommerce Manager 1 day
Add a cart countdown
Distance to free shipping with one suggested add-on.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Sweep old mentions
Klaviyo flows, ads, FAQ and chat replies.
Email & Retention Manager 1 day
Measure
Cart abandonment and order value before and after.
Ecommerce Manager 4 weeks
Why it works
Decide one domestic threshold on purpose (for example $250, so one Italian frame plus a lens upgrade qualifies, or $300 if margin requires it) and put that exact number in four places on the same day: the announcement bar, the homepage benefits row, the Shopify shipping policy and the Shipping and Handling page. Show it in local currency on each regional store. Add a cart message that counts down ("You're $31 from free shipping") and suggests an accessory or lens upgrade to cross the line. Search the theme, Klaviyo emails and ads for the old numbers.
Conflicting delivery costs are one of the most common reasons shoppers abandon a cart, and an inconsistent rule also creates customer service tickets and refund requests when the checkout charge differs from the promise. A single clear threshold placed in the cart becomes a lever that raises order value.
Ready to use
ChecklistFree-shipping consistency check
[ ] Announcement bar [ ] Homepage benefits row (desktop and mobile text) [ ] /policies/shipping-policy [ ] /pages/vint-york-shipping-and-handling [ ] FAQ shipping answer [ ] Shopify shipping rates per market [ ] Regional stores in local currency [ ] Klaviyo welcome and abandoned-cart emails [ ] Chat and support macros [ ] Cart countdown message
Risks and how to handle them
Lower threshold costs margin
Pair it with the cart add-on suggestion, which raises order value.
Customers who were charged under the old rules ask for refunds
Have customer service honour the lowest published number for orders already placed.
Evidence
- Your websiteHomepage (checked October 20, 2026): the announcement bar says "FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $300", while the benefits row lower on the same page says "FREE SHIPPING OVER $250" and "Complimentary shipping on orders over $250". The same row claims "5,000+ FIVE-STAR REVIEWS", "INCLUDED RX LENSES" with every full-price optical frame and a "1 YEAR LIMITED WARRANTY"; "Our Most-Loved Frames" are Belle, Myrtle, Henri and Cats Meow at $149; there is a Decade Edit (1950s to 1990s) and a "Keep your frames. Upgrade your lenses." section. Positioning: "Vintage-inspired frames. A distinctly New York point of view."Source
- Your websiteShopify shipping policy page: "Domestic Shipping Free Shipping for orders of $150 or more. Order usually arrives within 5-7 business days after shipping"; processing takes 3 to 7 business days depending on the prescription.Source
- Your websiteShipping and Handling page: "Orders $300 or more: Free standard shipping. Orders under $300: $9.99 standard shipping"; typical delivery 5-10 business days after shipping.Source
- Your websiteThe homepage lists hreflang alternates for regional stores (ca., uk., au., de., fr., jp., nz. and eu.vintandyork.com). The UK store prices in GBP but its announcement bar still reads "FREE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $300" in dollars.Source
- Your cataloguePublic product feed (443 products): 267 eyeglasses, 106 sunglasses, 57 lens and add-on items, 11 accessories and a gift card. Price points cluster at $129 (141 products), $149 (59), $269 (83) and $299 (64); 118 products are tagged Made in Italy at $199-$329; accessories run $20-$69 (cases, chains, portfolios); 38 products are sold out in every variant; no product currently shows a compare-at (sale) price.Source