Way of Wade's help centre says "We currently do not offer exchange services": a shopper with the wrong size must return the pair at their own cost and place a new order. Yet sizing is the top complaint in recent Trustpilot reviews ("runs small", width varied, "they didnt fit"), the size guide itself warns that most shoes use "a relatively narrow shoe last" and "Sizing may vary between different models", and reviewers say wide feet may need half a size up on the Way of Wade 12. Every one of those shoppers pays twice (postage, then a second checkout) and many will simply take the refund. One UK buyer paid about £30 to send a pair back.
First action
Pull last quarter's returns and count how many gave size or fit as the reason.
How to measure it
Size returns converted to exchanges
- Now
- –
- Target
- 50%
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Size the problem
Returns with a size or fit reason, by model and size, for the last quarter.
Customer Service Lead 2 days
Set the rule
Unworn shoes, within 60 days, one free exchange per order; refunds unchanged.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Set up the flow
Add an exchange option and size picker to the return request, with a prepaid label.
Shopify Developer 1 week
Ship the new size early
Release the replacement on carrier scan; immediately for Team Wade members.
Operations Manager 3 days
Tell shoppers
"Free size exchange" beside the size selector, in the cart and in the confirmation email; update the help article.
E-commerce Manager 2 days
Train support
Offer the exchange first on every fit complaint.
Customer Service Lead 1 day
Measure
Exchange rate, refund rate and conversion on shoe pages, monthly.
E-commerce Manager monthly
Why it works
Launch a one-step size exchange for unworn shoes within the existing 60-day window: the shopper picks the new size in the return request, gets a prepaid label for the first exchange, and the new pair ships as soon as the return is scanned (or straight away for Team Wade members). Keep refunds as they are. Say "Free size exchange" on every shoe page next to the size selector and in the order confirmation email. Track how many refund requests become exchanges.
A free exchange keeps the sale instead of refunding it, removes the main reason to hesitate over an imported, narrow-fitting shoe, and turns the most common complaint into a reason to buy direct rather than from a reseller. The cost of a label is small next to a $199 shoe kept as revenue.
Ready to use
CopyShoe page and help article copy
Beside the size selector: Free size exchange. Wrong size? Pick a new one in your return request and we cover the first exchange label. Help article, "How do I exchange my Way of Wade order?": You can exchange unworn shoes for another size within 60 days of delivery. Start a return, choose "Exchange for a different size", and use the prepaid label we send. Your new pair ships as soon as the return is scanned. Team Wade members get theirs straight away.
Risks and how to handle them
Return postage from overseas customers is expensive
Start with US orders and US return addresses, then extend.
Shoppers order two sizes and exchange freely
One free exchange per order, unworn only.
Evidence
- Your help centreExchanges: "We currently do not offer exchange services." Customers "return the item first and then place a new order for the correct product or size", and "the customer will be responsible for all return shipping costs" unless the return is for a quality issue.Source
- ReviewsTrustpilot (checked November 3, 2026): TrustScore 4.2 from 687 reviews, 444 in the last 12 months; 77% five-star and 18% one-star; replies to 98% of negative reviews, typically within 48 hours. Recent reviews say a shoe "runs small", that sizing and width varied, and one pair went back because "they didnt fit"; a UK buyer paid about £30 in return postage; one reported a "clearly defective pair" that fell apart within a month. Others praise quality and fast, polite service.Source
- Your help centreSize guide: all sizes are "US-M sizing"; most performance shoes use "a relatively narrow shoe last"; "Sizing may vary between different models", with model details left to each product page. It gives no true-to-size or wide-foot advice.Source
- Review siteThe Hoops Geek on the Way of Wade 12 (released November 2025): official retail $225, listed at $199.00 on Way of Wade and from $267.00 on GOAT; 9.0 from 10 expert reviews; "Runs true to size for most players", fits narrow to regular feet best, and wide feet may want half a size up; "Not recommended for outdoor play due to concerns with durability."Source
- Your help centreReturns: "Way of Wade offers a 60-day return policy"; items must be "unworn or unused, with tags, and in its original packaging", and "items sent back to us without first requesting a return will not be accepted".Source