Zulily's own catalogue lists the same item at two addresses. "Love 1/2-Carat Diamond Stud Earrings" is at /products/love-1-2-carat-diamond-stud-earrings and again at the same address ending "-1", both at $699.99. The 1/4-carat pair is duplicated the same way at $399.99. Five more top jewellery items exist only at addresses ending "-1", which Shopify adds when a product is imported again. Around 45% of Zulily's Trustpilot reviews are one-star, so a shopper who sees a $700 diamond pair listed twice has one more reason to doubt the store. The duplicates also split reviews, search ranking and ad history across two pages.
First action
Export all products and filter for addresses that end in a dash and a number.
How to measure it
Duplicate product pages
- Now
- –
- Target
- 0, with conversion on merged items up 10%
- By
- 30 days
Steps
Export
All products with handle, SKU, vendor, price and options.
Ecommerce Manager 1 hour
Match twins
Pair each "-1" address with its original by SKU, title and price.
Merchandising Lead 1 day
Pick the keeper
Keep the page with more sales and reviews.
Ecommerce Manager 1 day
Move reviews
Merge reviews into the kept product in Yotpo.
Customer Experience Manager 2 days
Redirect
301 every retired address and rename "-1" handles to clean ones.
Shopify Developer 1 day
Fix the import
Match incoming vendor items on SKU so they update, not duplicate.
Shopify Developer 1 week
Monitor
A weekly report of any new "-1" addresses.
Ecommerce Manager weekly
Why it works
List every product whose address ends in -1, -2 and so on, and match each one to its twin. Keep the page with the most sales and reviews, move the reviews across in Yotpo, and 301-redirect the other page to it. Rename addresses ending "-1" back to clean ones, with redirects. Then fix the cause: change the import or vendor feed so that a re-imported item updates the existing product instead of creating a new one. Start with jewellery and other items over $100, where trust matters most.
One page per item keeps all the reviews, sales history and search signals in one place. It removes a visible red flag from high-ticket items and stops shopping feeds and ads from competing with themselves.
Ready to use
ChecklistDuplicate listing clean-up
[ ] Export products with handle, SKU, vendor, price, options [ ] Filter handles ending -1, -2, -3 [ ] Match each to its original by SKU [ ] Keep the page with more sales and reviews [ ] Merge reviews in Yotpo [ ] 301 the retired address [ ] Rename -1 handles to clean URLs (with redirects) [ ] Refresh the shopping feed [ ] Change the import to update on SKU match [ ] Weekly report of new -1 handles
Risks and how to handle them
Merging items that differ, such as another metal or stone size
Compare SKU, price and options first, and keep both pages if anything differs.
Broken links from ads, emails or affiliates
301 every retired address and refresh the shopping feed the same day.
Evidence
- Your websiteCatalogue feed (first 250 products, read November 3, 2026): prices from $19.99 to $2,099.99, median $146.17; the top items are Birkenstock sandals ($35 to $350) and fine jewellery ($199.99 to $1,299.99). The same product appears twice under two addresses: "Love 1/2-Carat Diamond Stud Earrings" at /products/love-1-2-carat-diamond-stud-earrings and /products/love-1-2-carat-diamond-stud-earrings-1 (both $699.99), and "Love 1/4-Carat Diamond Stud Earrings" the same way (both $399.99); five more top jewellery items sit only at addresses ending "-1".Source
- TrustpilotTrustScore 2.7 from 2,810 reviews, 420 in the last 12 months; 45% one-star and 30% five-star. Zulily replies to about 80% of negative reviews, usually within 48 hours. In the 20 newest reviews (October and November 2026), shipping time is the most common complaint (one order placed October 7 had not shipped by November), with sizing that runs small and sales tax charged on clothing and shoes in Massachusetts, refunded after an email; five-star reviews praise prices, free delivery and easy returns.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 3, 2026): title "Zulily | Daily Deals on Fashion, Home, Kids’ Items & More"; description promises "top brands and unique finds at up to 90% off"; a banner reads "Fresh drops daily at 6AM PT". The store runs on Shopify with Shop Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, PayPal and Klarna, Braze email, Yotpo and Trustpilot review widgets, ShareASale and Rakuten affiliate tags, and a third-party returns portal and FAQ; the footer links to X, Facebook, Instagram and YouTube.Source