1820 Bag Co. shows two different sets of return terms. The Shipping & Returns page in the footer says to give notice within 7 days of receiving an item, with returns due back within 10 days, and describes exchanges for another colour or a different item. The Shopify refund policy says to email within 14 days of delivery, to post within 7 days of approval, that exchanges are not offered, and that sale items are final. The two pages also give different return addresses, and the older page has a garbled line ("Returns are Exchanges are due back"). A buyer weighing a $155 made-to-order Englewood cannot tell which rules apply, and the shop cannot hold a customer to either set.
First action
Open both pages side by side and mark every line where they disagree: days, exchanges, sale items, address.
How to measure it
Add-to-cart to checkout rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- +5%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Compare the two pages
List each difference: notice period, posting deadline, exchanges, sale items, return address, refund timing.
Founder 30 minutes
Choose one set of terms
Decide days, exchange stance and the single return address. Keep what the studio can honour for made-to-order work.
Founder 1 hour
Rewrite the footer page
Replace the returns section of Shipping & Returns with a four-line summary and a link to the policy. Remove the garbled sentence.
Founder 1 hour
Align the Shopify policy
Update the refund policy in Shopify settings so the wording and address match the summary exactly.
Founder 30 minutes
Show it where people decide
Add the summary under Add to Cart on product pages and in the cart.
Founder 2 hours
Update emails and inserts
Check the order confirmation, shipping email and any printed card in the parcel for old terms.
Founder 1 hour
Review after 60 days
Compare checkout rate and count return questions against the 60 days before.
Founder 30 minutes
Why it works
Pick one set of terms (the 14-day refund policy is the newer and more complete one) and make every page say the same thing. Replace the returns half of the Shipping & Returns page with a four-line plain-English summary that links to the policy: how long, what condition, who pays postage, where to send it. Use one return address. Decide the exchange question once and state it the same way everywhere. Then put the same short summary under the Add to Cart button on product pages and in the order confirmation email, so the promise is visible at the moment of decision.
For a handmade bag bought unseen, the return terms are part of the product. Conflicting terms read as a shop that is not kept up to date, which is the opposite of the brand's careful, built-to-last message. One clear promise removes a reason to hesitate and prevents disputes where a customer quotes the page that suits them. It costs nothing and takes an afternoon.
Ready to use
ChecklistOne returns promise, everywhere
[ ] One notice period (days from delivery) [ ] One posting deadline after approval [ ] Exchanges: offered or not, stated once [ ] Sale items: final or not [ ] One return address [ ] Who pays return postage, and the exception for damaged or wrong items [ ] Refund timing [ ] Same wording on: Shipping & Returns page, Shopify refund policy, product pages, cart, order emails, parcel insert
Risks and how to handle them
A longer window brings more returns of made-to-order pieces
Keep the unused-condition rule and final sale on sale items, and track return rate monthly.
Old terms survive in an email template or printed card
Search every notification template and reprint inserts when stock runs out.
Evidence
- Your websiteShipping & Returns page (footer link on every page; last modified April 10, 2024 per the sitemap): "allow 1 - 2 weeks for your item to be prepared for shipping"; buyers must give notice within 7 days of receiving an item and returns are due back within 10 days; it describes exchanges for another colour or a different item; it gives a Coral Springs street address for returns; one sentence reads "Returns are Exchanges are due back".Source
- Your websiteRefund policy (the store's Shopify policy page): email "within 14 days of delivery to request a return"; "Once your return is approved, please mail it within 7 days"; sale items are final sale; exchanges are not offered (return the item and place a new order); refunds come "within 5 business days of receiving your return"; the shop will "cover any necessary return shipping for a damaged, defective, or incorrect item"; returns go to a Coral Springs mailbox address, not the street address on the Shipping & Returns page.Source
- Your websiteHomepage (checked November 16, 2026): hero "Handcrafted Bags Made to Last." with one button, "SHOP THE ENGLEWOOD"; featured prices: Hobe Satchel Large from $80, Englewood Field Bag $155 (7 colours), Highland Tote $110, Daytona Hobo from $52 (was $65), Hendry Sling $55; reviews shown: Englewood 4.75 out of 5 from 4 reviews, Hobe 5.0 from 2; the newsletter box "From the Studio." offers "new pieces, small batch drops, and what I'm working on" with no incentive; "Shipping & taxes calculated at checkout" and no free-shipping threshold.Source