All 109 account-opening links on climatefirstbank.com carry utm_source=OE and utm_medium=referral, and the same tag container runs on the join site. In Google Analytics 4, a link with UTM tags starts a new session with that source, so a visitor who came from a Google ad, a Meta ad, a newsletter or a nonprofit partner and then clicks "Open Impact Checking" is likely recorded as an OE referral when they apply. The new paid media lead is asked to make UTMs and conversion tracking "reliable" and to judge CAC and ROAS, and that is hard to do while every application looks like it came from the same place.
First action
Open GA4 and compare how many applications are credited to "OE / referral" with how many come from paid search.
How to measure it
Applications attributed to their real channel
- Now
- –
- Target
- 90%+
- By
- 30 days
Steps
Confirm the effect
In GA4, look at sessions and conversions on join.climatefirstbank.com by source; check how much sits under OE / referral.
Marketing Operations 1 day
Agree a link format
product= stays; utm_source and utm_medium go; add entry=website if OneEthos needs it.
Senior Manager, Paid Media 1 day
Update the links
All 109 links across 39 pages, in the Webflow components and page templates.
Web team 2 days
Cross-domain setup
Add both domains to the GA4 cross-domain list and exclude them as referrers.
Marketing Operations 1 day
Carry the source
Store the original source, campaign, click ID and landing page with each application.
Data Engineer 1 week
Test every product
Click through each Open button from a tagged ad URL and confirm the source survives.
Senior Manager, Paid Media 2 days
Report
Applications, opened and funded accounts by channel, weekly.
Data Analyst weekly
Why it works
Take the UTM tags off the internal links and pass the product in a plain parameter (keep product=impact-checking, drop utm_source and utm_medium). Set up cross-domain measurement between www and join in the one GA4 property, and keep the visitor's original source, click ID and landing page through to the application. If OneEthos needs to know the click came from the website, use a non-UTM field such as entry=website. Then check, channel by channel, which sources really produce opened and funded accounts.
Paid media can only be tuned if you know which ads open accounts. Fixing the links costs an afternoon, and from then on every campaign, email and partner page is credited with the applications it brings.
Ready to use
ChecklistAccount-opening link check
[ ] No utm_ tags on internal links to join.climatefirstbank.com [ ] product= parameter kept for every product [ ] Both domains in GA4 cross-domain settings [ ] www and join excluded as referrals [ ] Original source, campaign and click ID saved with the application [ ] Test from a Google Ads, Meta, email and nonprofit link [ ] Weekly report of applications and funded accounts by channel
Risks and how to handle them
OneEthos reporting relies on the OE tag
Agree a replacement field with OneEthos before removing it.
History breaks
Annotate the change date in GA4 and compare like with like.
Evidence
- Your websiteEvery account-opening button on the site goes to join.climatefirstbank.com with "utm_source=OE" and "utm_medium=referral" written into the link (109 links across 39 pages, checked October 21, 2026), for example "/accounts?utm_source=OE&product=impact-checking&utm_medium=referral". The same Google Tag Manager container runs on www and on join.Source
- HiringSenior Manager, Paid Media (posted October 13, 2026): owns paid search and paid social "for Climate First Bancorp, Climate First Bank, OneEthos, and future portfolio companies" across Google Ads, Microsoft Advertising, Meta and LinkedIn; owns "naming conventions, UTMs, and platform settings"; makes sure "conversion tracking, UTMs, audience logic, and reporting are reliable"; analyzes "CPL, CAC, ROAS, conversion quality"; works with "pixels, tags, CRM data, Salesforce, and offline conversion feedback".Source
- Your websiteHomepage: Impact Checking "Earn 3.26% Annual Percentage Yield (APY)" plus "We donate $100 to an eligible nonprofit you choose"; a Deposit Impact Calculator "Powered by Topo Finance" comparing earnings and climate impact with "Wall Street Banks". The footnote says the $500 recurring direct deposit "must be set up within 90 days of account opening" or the account "will revert to a non-interest earning account".Source
- Your websiteNonprofit Referral Program (July 2026): each partner gets "customized, co-branded landing pages powered by our sister company, OneEthos"; the bank donates "$100" per eligible individual account and "$250" per eligible business account opened through the partner's page or promo code; launched as a pilot with five nonprofits.Source