On colehaan.com each colourway is a separate product with exactly the same title. "Men's Stockbridge Chelsea Waterproof Boots" exists as at least three products (-c44926, -c44928, -c44929), and the same happens with the Venetian slippers, the Elsie messenger bag and the Women's Pinch Long-Weekender loafers, which have three pages at two different prices ($119.95 and $135). In Google, one Stockbridge page shows full product copy while another shows only the size guide. Shoppers who land on one colour may not see the others, reviews are split into thin piles, and Google sees near-duplicate pages competing for the same name.
First action
Export the catalogue and list every title that appears on more than one product.
How to measure it
Conversion on merged style pages vs unmerged
- Now
- –
- Target
- +8%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Find the duplicates
Group products by identical title; rank the groups by revenue.
E-commerce Analyst 1 day
Choose the method
Combined listings on Shopify Plus, or a grouping app; confirm that analytics still attributes sales to each colour.
Director, E-commerce Merchandising 2 days
Fix the thin pages
Give every colour page full copy, images and price, like the black Stockbridge page has.
E-commerce Content Manager 1 week
Pool the reviews
Set up Yotpo so all colours of a style show one review set and one star count.
CRM and Reviews Manager 3 days
Set canonicals
Point identical-copy colour pages at the style page; keep the old URLs live.
SEO Manager 2 days
Launch the top 20
Merge the 20 biggest styles first and hold the rest as the comparison group.
Director, E-commerce Merchandising 1 week
Measure and roll out
Compare conversion, reviews per page and search clicks; then merge the rest.
E-commerce Analyst 4 weeks
Why it works
Group every colourway of a style under one parent product with a colour selector, using Shopify's combined listings (a Shopify Plus feature, and the store was rebuilt on Shopify in the last year) or a grouping app. Keep each child URL so existing links and ads still work, point canonical tags to the main style page where the copy is the same, give every colour page full product copy, and show one combined review count for the style. Start with the 20 best-selling styles that have two or more colourways, then do the rest of the 250-product catalogue.
A style page with every colour and all its reviews answers the two questions that stop a $160 shoe purchase (does it come in my colour, and do other buyers like it) without a second search. It also puts all the ranking signals for a style name on one page instead of three.
Ready to use
ChecklistColourway merge checklist (per style)
[ ] All products sharing the title listed with style number and colour [ ] Parent style chosen (best seller or most reviews) [ ] Every colour has full copy, images, price and sizes [ ] Colour swatches visible above the fold [ ] Reviews pooled; colour shown on each review [ ] Canonical set where copy is identical; old URLs still return 200 [ ] Product feed and ads still point to the right colour [ ] Before and after conversion recorded
Risks and how to handle them
Ads and links to old colour URLs break
Keep every child URL live; only change what the page shows.
Reviews about one colour (for example a suede finish) mislead buyers of another
Show the colour bought on each review and let shoppers filter by it.
Evidence
- Your websiteCatalogue scan (250 products on Shopify): each colourway is its own product with an identical title, for example "Men's Stockbridge Chelsea Waterproof Boots" at -c44928 and -c44929, "Men's Microsuede Venetian Slippers" at -c48787 and -c48788, "Women's Elsie Medium Messenger Bag" at -u09067 and -u09068, and "Women's Pinch Long-Weekender Penny Loafers" at -w35592 and -w35593 ($119.95). Prices run from $34.95 to $498, median $160.Source
- Search resultsGoogle's index of colehaan.com shows a third Stockbridge Chelsea page (-c44926, black, $260, full product copy) next to -c44929 (Gray Pinstripe-Dark Chocolate), whose result shows only the size guide; and a third Women's Pinch Long-Weekender page (-w36978) at $135.Source
- Shopify documentationCombined listings "bring together products that are merchandised by an option"; they are "available only to stores on a Shopify Plus plan"; each child product keeps "their own images and URL handles".Source
- Your websiteSite stack: a Shopify storefront (new since a November 2025 scan, which also found Optimizely and reCAPTCHA, both now gone), Google Tag Manager, Microsoft Clarity, Zendesk chat, Attentive email and SMS, Yotpo reviews, Afterpay, Klarna and Shop Pay Installments, and the Rakuten affiliate network.Source