Hearthy has 148 recipes, and they all end the same way. The Jell-o recipe, whose only Hearthy ingredient is gelatin, finishes with a "Shop Best Sellers" shelf of six flours and apple cider vinegar powder, three of them marked sold out, and no gelatin. The apple flour cake recipe is built on "Hearthy apple flour", which is not among the 32 products on sale, and offers no substitute. Meanwhile gelatin is one of the company's top Amazon products. The recipes bring in cooks who are ready to buy the ingredient, and the page shows them something else.
First action
List the 148 recipes in a sheet with the main Hearthy product each one uses, and mark which products are still sold.
How to measure it
Recipe-to-product click rate
- Now
- –
- Target
- 8% of recipe sessions
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Map recipes to products
One row per recipe: main Hearthy ingredient, whether it is still sold, best substitute if not.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Tag the gelatin recipes first
Gummies, jello, panna cotta, whipped cream and marshmallow recipes get a gelatin tag.
E-commerce Manager 2 hours
Swap the shelf
Replace the fixed "Shop Best Sellers" block on article pages with one that reads the recipe's tag and hides sold-out items.
Shopify developer 2 days
Add a buy block by the ingredients
Product image, price, reviews and add to cart next to the ingredient list; link the ingredient name.
Shopify developer 1 day
Fix discontinued-flour recipes
Add a tested substitute from the seven flours still sold, or redirect to the closest current recipe.
Founder 1 week
Add recipe details
Prep time, servings and recipe markup so search results can show the recipe card.
Shopify developer 2 days
Measure
Clicks and orders from recipe pages, by product, every month.
E-commerce Manager monthly
Why it works
Tag every recipe with the Hearthy product it uses, and replace the fixed flour shelf with a block that shows that product first: price, size, reviews and an add-to-cart button, plus one natural add-on (agar with gelatin, collagen with broth). Put the same block beside the ingredient list, and link the ingredient itself. For recipes built on flours that are no longer sold, add a tested substitute from the seven flours still stocked, or a line saying which current product works. Hide sold-out items from the shelf automatically. Start with the gelatin recipes (gummies, jello, panna cotta, whipped cream), because gelatin is a proven seller and the fix is one tag per recipe.
A recipe reader has already chosen what to make; the only open question is where to get the ingredient. Showing the exact product at that moment converts far better than a generic shelf, and it stops recipes for discontinued flours from being dead ends. It costs nothing in traffic: the visitors are already there.
Ready to use
ChecklistRecipe page checklist
[ ] Recipe tagged with its main Hearthy product [ ] Ingredient name links to the product [ ] Buy block (price, size, reviews, add to cart) beside the ingredients [ ] Shelf at the end shows that product first, then one add-on [ ] Sold-out items hidden or replaced by a back-in-stock form [ ] Discontinued flour? Substitute stated and tested [ ] Prep time, servings and recipe markup added
Risks and how to handle them
The main product for a recipe is out of stock
Show a back-in-stock form in the block instead of hiding the product (see idea 2).
Substitute flours change the bake
Test each substitute once before publishing it.
Evidence
- Your websiteTwo recipe pages read on November 18, 2026: the Jell-o recipe links once to the gelatin product in its intro, has no shop-this-recipe block, and ends with a "Shop Best Sellers" shelf of six flours and apple cider vinegar powder (three marked sold out) with no gelatin on it; the apple flour cake recipe calls for "Hearthy apple flour", has no ingredient links and shows the same shelf.Source
- Your websiteRecipe library (sitemap checked November 18, 2026): 148 articles, all in /blogs/recipes, with no explainers or comparison pages. Many recipes are built on flours that are not in today's catalogue, such as apple, banana, cassava, kabocha, butternut squash, oat and red lentil flour.Source
- Your websiteProduct sitemap: 32 products. Wellness: collagen peptides, capsules, marine collagen and Collagen+, gelatin, colostrum (4oz and 16oz), beef and chicken bone broth (liquid and powder), creatine, whey protein isolate, agar agar, apple cider vinegar powder, Wagyu beef tallow (preorder) and pink salt. Marshmallows: vanilla, chocolate dipped, s'mores and a multipack. Seven flours remain: sweet potato, almond, split pea, green split pea, cashew, pecan and pumpkin. Bundles include a Bone Broth Duo, a 6-Day Bone Broth Meal Plan, The Ultimate Shake and a Collagen and Bone Broth Bundle.Source
- MarketplacesAmazon seller tracker SellerRatings: Hearthy Foods Inc. is rated 4.8 out of 5 from 1,413 seller reviews, ranked 4,095th on Amazon.com (up from 5,321st the month before), selling since 2013; top products listed are creatine monohydrate, beef gelatin powder, agar agar powder and marine collagen.Source