Society6.com's "Returns" link points to help.society6.com/en-US/what-is-the-society6-return-policy-1261632 and its "Help Center" link to /en-US/submit-a-request-1270426. Both returned 404 Not Found in two checks on November 3, 2026. The help centre has been rebuilt, and the same articles now live at -6266658 and -6647360. The two links most likely to be clicked by a customer with a late or damaged order are the two that are dead. That customer is the one who writes a one-star Trustpilot review, and 39% of Society6's 2,637 reviews are one-star.
First action
Update the footer and header links to /en-US/what-is-the-society6-return-policy-6266658 and /en-US/submit-a-request-6647360.
How to measure it
404 visits from society6.com help links
- Now
- –
- Target
- Zero, and 20% fewer one-star reviews mentioning returns or contact
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Fix the two links
Footer and any header or account-page copies of Returns and Help Center.
Shopify Developer 1 hour
Map old article IDs
Export old and new help-centre article IDs and build a redirect table.
Customer Experience Lead 1 day
Add redirects
Redirect every old ID in the help-centre platform, not only the two in the footer.
Customer Experience Lead 1 day
Sweep emails and macros
Order confirmations, shipping emails in Klaviyo and Narvar, and Gorgias chat macros.
CRM Manager 2 days
Rebuild the Returns Center entry
One page: window, fee, defect path, shipping-protection claims, what is final sale.
Customer Experience Lead 2 days
Monitor links
Weekly automated check of footer, email and help-centre links.
Shopify Developer weekly
Track the effect
Ticket volume, return-start rate and Trustpilot one-star share by theme.
Customer Experience Lead monthly
Why it works
Point both links at the live articles today. Then add redirects in the help-centre platform from every old article ID to its new one, so old emails, order confirmations, chat macros and search results land on content too. Put a link check on the footer, the order emails and the help centre. Finally, make the Returns Center the first thing a problem customer sees, with the 30-day window, the $7.95 standard-return fee, the defect path and the shipping-protection claim path on one page.
A customer with a problem who hits a dead page assumes the company is hiding. The same customer who reaches a clear Returns Center within one click usually gets a fix. Support replies on Trustpilot already ask people to contact support, so the self-serve path should work before they get that far. It costs almost nothing, and it protects the conversion gains from the Shopify rebuild.
Ready to use
ChecklistHelp-path repair list
[ ] Footer "Returns" -> /en-US/what-is-the-society6-return-policy-6266658 [ ] Footer "Help Center" -> /en-US/submit-a-request-6647360 [ ] Redirect table for all old help-centre article IDs [ ] Order, shipping and delivery emails checked [ ] Chat macros checked [ ] Returns Center page: 30-day window, $7.95 standard fee, defect path, shipping-protection claims, final-sale list [ ] Weekly link check on footer, emails and help centre
Risks and how to handle them
More old IDs are linked from places nobody remembers
Redirect the full old-to-new table, not only known links.
Easier returns raise return volume
Track defect reasons separately; a defect found early is cheaper than a chargeback or a public review.
Evidence
- Help centerThe site's "Returns" link (help.society6.com/en-US/what-is-the-society6-return-policy-1261632) and "Help Center" link (help.society6.com/en-US/submit-a-request-1270426) both returned 404 Not Found when checked twice on November 3, 2026. The same content now lives at /en-US/what-is-the-society6-return-policy-6266658 and /en-US/submit-a-request-6647360. The "Shipping Information" and "Contact Us" links still work.Source
- ReviewsTrustpilot (November 3, 2026): 3.6 out of 5 from 2,637 reviews, about 1,513 in the last 12 months; 41% five-star and 39% one-star. Reviewers praise the designs, colours, print quality and helpful support; complaints are orders delayed for weeks or never delivered, wrong addresses or materials, defects such as poor stitching on pillows and badly cut shower-curtain holes, and prints that look blurrier than online. Society6 replies to many negative reviews asking the customer to contact support.Source
- Help centerReturn policy: "Return requests must be submitted within 30 days of your delivery date"; "A $7.95 return shipping fee will be deducted from your refund for standard returns"; "Original shipping fees are non-refundable"; no exchanges; furniture, eGift Cards, "orders of 20 or more items, and wholesale orders" are final sale; shipping-protection claims go to the protection provider.Source
- Help centerContact Us offers ticket forms for Customers, Artists and Trade Clients; the team "typically respond[s] within 1-2 business days, excluding U.S. holidays."Source