The medical, dental and veterinary refinance pages all carry the same comparison: Panacea against the 'Other Guys', named as "SoFi, Laurel Road, Commonbond". CommonBond stopped student loan refinancing in May 2022, so a third of the table is a lender nobody can choose. The five rows ("Hidden Maximums", "Cosigners Required", "Outsourced Servicing", "Limited Banker Hours", "No Personal Service") are applied to all three lenders at once with no source or date. The same pages say "Rates as low as 5.49%" with no date, and the linked disclosure is a rate card labelled effective May 22, 2025. A doctor with $300,000 of debt compares lenders line by line, and SoFi's page shows its rates by term.
First action
Open the three refinance pages side by side and list every claim about another lender, with the source you would cite for it today.
How to measure it
Refinance application starts per 100 page visits
- Now
- –
- Target
- +15%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
List the claims
Every comparative claim on the three pages, with today's source or 'none'.
Head of Student Financial Products half a day
Pick live lenders
Three or four lenders doctors actually compare today; drop any that no longer refinance.
Head of Student Financial Products half a day
Build the fact table
One column per lender: lowest fixed rate and date, terms, maximum, cosigner policy, training payments, servicer, contact hours, each with a link to the lender's own page.
Chief Marketing Officer 2 days
Date the rate
Add 'rates checked on' beside 5.49% and link a current rate card.
Head of Student Financial Products 1 day
Compliance review
Approve each comparative claim and its source.
Chief Compliance Officer 2 days
Publish once, three pages
One shared block on the medical, dental and veterinary pages; buttons go straight to the refinance application.
Chief Marketing Officer 1 day
Set a monthly check
A calendar task to re-read each lender's page and update the date.
Head of Student Financial Products monthly
Measure
Application starts from the three pages, before and after.
Head of Strategy & Operations monthly
Why it works
Rebuild the block as a dated, sourced comparison. Name only lenders that refinance today. Give each lender its own column and replace the slogans with facts a borrower can check: lowest fixed rate and its date, terms offered, maximum, cosigner policy, payments during training, who services the loan, and how to reach a person. Put a 'rates checked on' date beside the 5.49% and link a current rate card. Keep Panacea's real edges (no maximum, in-house servicing, a primary care banker) and point each button at the refinance application instead of the twelve-tile Get Started page. One shared block feeds all three pages, so the fix is made once.
Refinancing is a comparison purchase and the borrower will check the table against the other tab. A current, sourced table reads as confidence; a table naming a closed lender reads as a page nobody has looked at since 2022, on the product where the loan sizes are largest. It also lowers compliance exposure, because comparative claims about named lenders then have a source and a date.
Ready to use
ChecklistRefinance comparison rebuild
[ ] Only lenders that refinance today [ ] One column per lender, no shared 'Other Guys' column [ ] Lowest fixed rate with the date it was checked [ ] Terms, maximum, cosigner policy, payments in training [ ] Who services the loan and how to reach a person [ ] A source link under each rival column [ ] 'Rates checked on' beside 5.49% and a current rate card [ ] Buttons go to the refinance application [ ] Same block on medical, dental and veterinary pages [ ] Monthly re-check owner named
Risks and how to handle them
A rival's rate changes and the table goes stale again
Show the checked-on date and re-read monthly; idea 2 automates the check.
A side-by-side shows a rival with a lower headline rate
Compare on the rows where Panacea wins (no maximum, in-house servicing, a named banker) and show a worked example at a doctor's balance.
Evidence
- Your websiteStudent loan refinance pages (medical, dental and veterinary school, read November 16, 2026): each compares Panacea with the 'Other Guys', named as "SoFi, Laurel Road, Commonbond", using five unsourced rows: "Hidden Maximums", "Cosigners Required", "Outsourced Servicing", "Limited Banker Hours", "No Personal Service". Each says "Rates as low as 5.49%" with no date on the page, and the linked Refinance Disclosure is a rate card whose file name says "effective 5-22-2025". Every apply button goes to the general /get-started/ page.Source
- News coverageNerdWallet, "CommonBond Exits the Student Loan Business": "CommonBond stopped offering student loans in April 2022 and ended its student loan refinance program in May 2022"; open refinance applications were processed until June 1, 2022.Source
- Competitor researchRivals' own pages (read November 16, 2026): SoFi's refinance page leads with "Fixed Rates from 4.49% APR", shows an example table by term (5-year 4.850% to 20-year 6.350% on $50,000), a $5,000 minimum and a link to medical resident refinancing. Doc2Doc Lending offers personal loans "up to $100K" to doctors, nurses and advanced practice providers at 9.99% to 30.72% APR with 0% to 4% origination, and pays $500 to the referrer and $100 to the referred provider.Source