Payhip's new growth hire is asked to scale beyond organic channels, and the App Store is one of them: the Payhip app is the result anyone gets when they search "Payhip" on an iPhone, and it is rated 1.98 from 40 ratings, against Stan at 4.87 and Gumroad at 4.68. The reviews are not about Payhip itself ("Payhip Is Great, This App Is Not"). They come from three fixable things: people without an account try to sign up and are told "incorrect email and or password"; sellers get the same sale notified twice; and the listing says it shows analytics, while users expect to manage their store. The last update (April 2026) changed nothing visible.
First action
Add the sign-up button and fix the duplicate notification.
How to measure it
US App Store average rating
- Now
- –
- Target
- 4.0 or higher
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Reproduce the issues
Sign-up attempt without an account; double notification.
Mobile Developer 1 day
Add web sign-up link
On the login screen.
Mobile Developer 1 day
One alert per sale
De-duplicate notifications.
Mobile Developer 2 days
Rating prompt
Native prompt after a sale notification.
Mobile Developer 1 day
Rewrite the listing
Subtitle, description, first screenshot.
Growth Marketing Manager 1 day
Reply to reviews
Recent one- and two-star reviews.
Customer Support Lead 1 day
Release
Version 1.2 to iOS and Android.
Mobile Developer 1 week
Track
Rating, installs and app sign-ups weekly.
Growth Marketing Manager weekly
Why it works
This week: (1) add a "New to Payhip? Create your free store" button on the login screen that opens web sign-up, (2) send one notification per sale, (3) rewrite the subtitle and first screenshot to say exactly what the app does ("Sales alerts and stats for your Payhip store"), and (4) call the native iOS review prompt after a seller's sale notification, at most a few times a year. Reply to the recent one-star reviews with the fix. Then add one or two quick actions people ask for (create a coupon, mark an order shipped).
Most ratings come from frustrated users because happy sellers are never asked. Asking at the moment a sale arrives, from sellers who rate Payhip 4.5 on Capterra, usually moves a small rating count quickly, and a sign-up button turns lost app installs into new stores.
Ready to use
ChecklistApp Store fix list
[ ] "Create your free store" on the login screen [ ] One notification per sale [ ] Native review prompt after a sale (Apple limits it) [ ] Subtitle: "Sales alerts and stats for your store" [ ] First screenshot shows what the app does [ ] Replies to recent low reviews [ ] Same fixes on Google Play [ ] Weekly rating and install tracking
Risks and how to handle them
Prompting annoys sellers
Use Apple's own prompt, which limits frequency.
Users still expect store editing
Say clearly on the listing what the app does, and add quick actions next.
Evidence
- App StoreThe Payhip iOS app (seller Payhip Ltd, released February 20, 2024) is rated 1.98 out of 5 from 40 ratings in the US App Store (checked November 4, 2026). The latest version, 1.1.0 (April 23, 2026), says only "Updated underlying frameworks and libraries for better performance and reliability." The listing promises: "Get notified anytime you receive a new sale. The analytics stats also help you keep your finger on the pulse on your business."Source
- App Store reviewsRecent App Store reviews: "This current version only shows a list of sales. Like a receipt." (1 star, October 2026); "It doesn't show all the pages like it says. It only shows the earnings" (2 stars, September 2026); "Payhip Is Great, This App Is Not" (2 stars, May 2026); "Why can't we make changes, add products, or make payments on this app?" (2 stars, February 2026); people who never had an account report the app says "incorrect email and or password" when they try to make one (January 2026 and earlier); "Always double notifies you of Sales" (3 stars, 2025).Source
- Help centerPayhip Mobile App article: the app lets sellers "monitor your sales in real time, view analytics and sales metrics, and receive instant notifications for new orders". Product uploads and store design "must be managed via the web dashboard". Asked "Will more features be added?", it answers "Not at the moment, but we're not closing the door on it." Login trouble steps end with emailing support with device, OS version and IP address.Source
- App StoreRival seller apps in the US App Store (checked November 4, 2026): Stan: Link in Bio for Creators 4.87 from 13,452 ratings; Gumroad 4.68 from 36,847; Kajabi 4.33 from 7,446; Sellfy 2.94 from 16.Source
- Job listing (via search)Payhip is recruiting a remote Growth Marketing Manager to grow its reach through SEO, content marketing and performance marketing, saying "We've grown exponentially through organic channels - now we're ready to step on the gas." Its listings describe a profitable, bootstrapped company of 11-50 people.Source
- ReviewsCapterra rates Payhip 4.5 from 27 verified reviews; reviewers praise ease of use for digital products, and the common critiques are limited design customization and weak marketing analytics.Source