Scholl's Trustpilot profile has a TrustScore of 1.1 from 430 reviews, 112 of them in the last year, and the company has not replied to any negative review. The 20 most recent reviews (April to October 2026) are all one star, from shoppers in the UK, Switzerland, Belgium, France, the Netherlands, Greece and more, and the most common single complaint is the return label: five reviewers say it never arrived, failed in the returns portal or had to be paid for. One needed 14 emails, another eight, another waited six weeks for a manual label. Four more say refunds took one to three months. These are not complaints about the shoes. The 5-star reviews praise comfort and fit. The problem is one broken step after the purchase, and every shopper who checks the shop before a €90 order sees the result.
First action
Place a test return in five market versions today and record where the label fails.
How to measure it
First-try return-label success
- Now
- –
- Target
- 98%, and TrustScore above 3.0
- By
- 90 days
Steps
Test every market
Place test returns in each market version and log label failures by country, carrier and product type.
E-commerce Manager 2 days
Fix the portal
Repair the label generation errors found, starting with the markets that fail most often.
Shopify Developer 1 week
Add a 24-hour fallback
A Zendesk macro and tag that sends a working label within one working day to anyone who reports a failure.
Head of Customer Care 2 days
Clear the backlog
Contact every open return or refund older than 14 days and close it with a label or a refund.
Head of Customer Care 1 week
Reply to reviews
Answer every Trustpilot review from the last 12 months, then every new one within two working days.
Head of Customer Care 2 weeks, then ongoing
State the costs
Show return steps and any fee on the returns page and in the order confirmation email.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Track weekly
Label success rate, refund time and TrustScore in one weekly report.
E-commerce Manager weekly
Why it works
Treat the return label as a product. First, test the returns portal end to end in every market version this week, and log every failure. Second, give customer care a fallback: any customer who reports a failed label gets a working label within 24 hours, by a Zendesk macro, without needing another email. Third, clear the backlog: contact everyone with an open return or refund older than 14 days, refund or send a label, and apologise. Fourth, reply publicly to every Trustpilot review from the last 12 months with a short, specific answer and a direct contact route, then reply to every new review within two working days. Finally, publish the return steps and costs clearly on the returns page and in the order confirmation email, so the €10 deduction, where it applies, is never a surprise.
Returns are a normal part of buying shoes online, and what turns a return into a 1-star review is silence and friction, not the return itself. A working label and a public reply fix the cause and show future shoppers that someone is listening. A higher TrustScore helps on every channel the brand pays for, because shoppers check reviews before a first order with an unfamiliar store.
Ready to use
ChecklistReturn-label repair checklist
[ ] Test return placed in IT, DE, FR, GB, NL, CH, BE versions [ ] Label failures logged by market and carrier [ ] Portal errors fixed for top-failing markets [ ] Zendesk macro: working label within 24 hours [ ] Open returns and refunds older than 14 days closed [ ] Return steps and any fee shown on the returns page and order email [ ] Every Trustpilot review from the last 12 months answered [ ] New reviews answered within 2 working days [ ] Weekly report: label success, refund days, TrustScore
Risks and how to handle them
Public replies read as copy-paste
Use a short template but always mention the customer's actual problem and the fix.
Backlog is larger than expected
Prioritise by age of the case and add temporary care capacity for two weeks.
Evidence
- Customer reviewsTrustpilot profile for www.scholl-shoes.com (checked November 3, 2026): TrustScore 1.1 from 430 reviews, 112 of them in the last 12 months; 90% are 1-star and 4% are 5-star. The profile was claimed in December 2021, the company has not replied to negative reviews, and Trustpilot shows no recent history of the company inviting reviews.Source
- Customer reviewsThe 20 most recent Trustpilot reviews (April 30 to October 22, 2026) are all 1-star. Five describe return labels that never arrived, failed in the returns portal or had to be paid for (one took 14 emails, another eight, another waited six weeks for a manual label); four report refunds taking one to three months; two say €10 was deducted from the refund; four are about size or width (too big, too small, “very narrow”, mismatched sizes in one box); two say one pair of a two-pair order was missing or deformed. The reviewers are in the UK, Switzerland, Belgium, France, the Netherlands, Greece, Poland, Denmark, Italy and New Zealand.Source
- Customer reviews5-star Trustpilot reviews praise comfort for daily use, relief for painful heels during long shifts on their feet, correct sizes and delivery from Italy within four days; models named include the New Bogotà wedge sandal, Amalfi mules and New Massage.Source
- Your websiteShopify store (checked November 3, 2026): 1,040 products and 178 collections in the sitemap, prices from €10.90 to €590 (median €90); free shipping from €100; a 30-day return window without free returns; Shop Pay, PayPal and Google Pay; Zendesk chat, Klaviyo email and Yotpo reviews (Yotpo added in the last year, while Google Tag Manager and Microsoft Clarity were removed); Hotjar analytics.Source