PURE Whey is SFH's most reviewed product (4.9 from 1,442 reviews, some customers buying it for ten years), and every size and flavour is sold out, as is RECOVER Whey. The page has no way to leave an email, the price line reads "Save $-65.99", the GLP-1 stack still offers whey, and the article published on October 19 recommends it. Loyal buyers hit a dead end and may reorder from another brand.
First action
Turn on Klaviyo back-in-stock on the two whey pages.
How to measure it
Past whey buyers ordering again within 60 days
- Now
- –
- Target
- 40%
- By
- 60 days
Steps
Turn on the form
Klaviyo back-in-stock on both whey pages.
Shopify developer 2 hours
Fix the price label
Hide "Save" when the item is sold out.
Shopify developer 1 hour
Write the note
When whey returns, or that it is retired.
Co-Founder & CEO 1 hour
Set the bridge offer
PURE PLANT trial price for the list.
E-commerce Manager 1 day
Repoint links
Articles and the GLP-1 stack.
Content Writer 1 day
Email past buyers
Segment of whey customers.
Marketing Manager 2 days
Restock email
Ready to send the day whey returns.
Marketing Manager 1 day
Run this outreach. The sequence sent for you: addresses found and verified, replies routed to your CRM. Usually live within days.
Book a working sessionWhy it works
Add a Klaviyo back-in-stock form to both whey pages today, with a short note on when whey returns (or that it is retired). Offer PURE PLANT as a bridge with a one-time trial price for anyone who joins the list. Fix the "Save $-65.99" label, and point the whey links in articles and the GLP-1 stack to PURE PLANT until whey is back. Email past whey buyers directly.
A waitlist keeps the most loyal customers and gives an exact restock forecast; the plant bridge keeps their monthly order with SFH instead of a competitor.
Ready to use
EmailEmail to past PURE Whey buyers
Subject: About your PURE Whey You have been buying PURE Whey from us, and right now it is sold out. We are sorry. [When it is coming back / what is changing] Tap here and we will email you the day it is back: [Notify me] In the meantime, try PURE PLANT, 21 g of organic plant protein, at [trial price] for your next order: [Try PURE PLANT] Thank you for sticking with us, The SFH team
Risks and how to handle them
Restock date slips
Give a range and update the list honestly.
Plant protein does not suit some buyers
Offer the bridge as a choice, not a swap.
Evidence
- Your websiteThe Pure Whey page (checked October 20, 2026) is rated 4.9 from 1,442 reviews, with reviewers saying they have used it for about ten years; every option shows "Sold out", the price line reads "Save $-65.99", and there is no back-in-stock or notify-me signup.Source
- Your catalogueProduct feed (24 products, read October 20, 2026): every size and flavour of Grass Fed Pure Whey Protein (28-serving bags at $65.99, boxes of 10 single serves at $33.99, a Churro 20-serving bag) and of Recover Whey Protein is unavailable. PURE PLANT Protein ($52.99) was added in June 2026. The Omega 3 MCT Oil for Pets is also unavailable.Source
- Your websiteThe newest blog articles still send readers to the sold-out whey: "Protein Before Bed: Does a Nighttime Shake Help Build Muscle?" (published October 19, 2026) recommends "SFH Grass Fed Pure Whey Protein Powder", and "How Much Protein Per Meal Can Your Body Actually Use" links to it twice.Source
- Your websiteGLP-1 Support Stack page: "Select 3, get 15% off"; it lists PURE Whey Protein ("Grass-fed whey isolate") as a protein anchor, and labels PURE PLANT Protein "Dropping soon" although it is already on sale.Source